I just bought this item at my local WalMart without opening it first. I should have known better but it was late at night and I simply did not notice the brand name CAREX on the package......had I, I would have at least opened the box to see what I was getting.....but hey! , come on now....it's a urinal for pete's sake..... how can you screw up the design on a urinal. The lid on this urinal is designed like the new bottle caps on the water bottles....SUPER THIN ! ! 1/8" or less. Now, this is O.K. for a water bottle, after all, you figet around with the WATER bottle trying to get the lid screwed back on and drop it, you simply have water all over yourself.....however, you slip up trying to get this urinal lid on and in place and drop it.... well, I think you can "catch" the drift as to where I am going with this. I simply will NEVER buy anything with the Carex name on it. A few months back, I bought three boxes of cane tips for what appeared to be a killer price at WalMart. within LESS than two weeks the first set were completely worn out.