Now, I love Third Eye Blind and this is the first review I have written for anything. I have seen them five times, every time was amazing; one of the best live bands going. But I am baffled by the number of 5-star reviews going on here. I was torn between a 3-star and 4-star review, but in the end, I think it was a matter of me wanting the album to be better than it really is. So, if I am being honest with myself, it only rates as a 3-star, 3 and a half if it were possible. But come on people! With the exception of a handful of bands, like The Beatles and U2, most bands do not have multiple 5-star albums on their resume, and if 3eb has one, this ain't it. It is still a good album, and there are definitely worse ways to spend 4 bucks. If you are looking for a reason why, heck, I say why not.
It does feel a little underwhelming for a 6 year wait. There are a number of good tunes, not as hook-y as usual, but frankly, it's disappointing that these are the lyrics Stephen came up while "suffering" from writers block. Here his words come off a little average and pedestrian. Some people describe him as a 'profound' lyricist, but I think that is a little off the mark. He is certainly witty and clever and heartfelt, and even deep, but not what I would consider profound. I don't want to turn this into a "they're not what they used to be" rant, but I think the songs have been lacking since Kevin Cadogan's departure years ago. There was just something about his use of alternate tunings that made their early songs more interesting and unique instead of standard and somewhat blah.
I'm not going to give each song an individual review, but there a few things I'd like to comment on. The first two songs are nice and punchy, but pretty average. The following two songs get better, with A Sharp Knife, in my opinion, being the best song on the album. Now, the next song, One in Ten, seems to be bringing out the most diverse opinions. I agree with the people that say it breaks the flow of the album, but I still think it is a pretty interesting, even with its juvenile lyrics. I do think it would be better suited for an EP release. I think Red Star would have fit in much better here. After this point, I don't think it ever really gets back on track, maybe with the exception of Summer Town. Some people are turned off by the little sing-rap at the end. But I always liked Can't Get Away, and it is pretty similar to that song.
With the last two songs, Monotov and Carnival, I, for some reason, was under the assumption that there were only supposed to be ten songs on this album and now these two have kind of a tacked-on feel to me. I enjoy the mellow attitude of both songs, especially Carnival Barker, but it just feels, to me anyway, like filler.
The one song that I think absolutely bites is Why Can't You Be. It plods along for way too long, he sounds whine-y, and I hate that he dropped the Robbie Williams lyric. And no, throwing in a beej reference does not make it good, and the more I listen to it, the worse it gets. Oddly, I didn't mind it so much on the Red Star EP.
One last thing: it took me awhile to figure out what it is in most of their songs on all their albums that is so d**n good. And it finally hit me: it's Brad. This guy comes to play on every outing and this one is no different. He turns another amazing, powerful performance. Just listen to his stellar work on A Sharp Knife. Since Arion has gone MIA, I think Brad is definitely the soul of this band.
In closing, it is far from their best, but still good enough to pick up, especially at $4.00. I think that it will grow on me, much like Out Of The Vein did. I think OOTV was a solid 3-star that worked its way to a borderline 4-Star. If nothing else, I am looking forward to Ursa Major getting better with repeat listens, which is more that I can say for the latest U2, which has gotten worse with each subsequent spin. Thanks for reading, hope you weren't too put off by the rambling.