Customer Reviews

VMware Infrastructure 3: Advanced Technical Design Guide and Advanced Operations Guide (No. 3)

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Last week while speaking at TechTarget's Advanced Enterprise Virtualization seminar, I was asked a question I get quite often - "What book do you recommend if we want to learn more?" The answer to that was easy. The audience consisted pretty much of senior level administrators who were either running or planned to deploy VMware-based virtual environments, so I asked if everyone had purchased a copy of the VMware Infrastructure 3 Advanced Technical Design & Advanced Operations Guide. The attendees were surprised that I didn't mention my own book, but why should I? My virtualization book was published in 2005, so it's a dinosaur in terms of virtualization books. Even back then, I wrote a good virtualization book that covered many platforms, but at the time the best book for ESX environments was the VMware ESX Server: Advanced Technical Design Guide.

I had pre-ordered the VMware Infrastructure 3 Advanced Technical Design and Operations Guide and received my copy from Amazon a few days before my seminar last week. If you're thinking about deploying VMware or are already running VMware Virtual Infrastructure, I consider this book to be a requirement. The authors, Ron Oglesby, Scott Herold, and Mike Laverick are three of the foremost VMware experts in the world. Together, they delivered a highly comprehensive book that takes you from planning and architecture to operations and advanced management. Let's face it, you can find a lot of information online today, so to me the value of a good book is in the information that goes beyond what is already there in a vendor's how-to guide. This book certainly does not disappoint. Of course, some of the book's content is online, like Mike Laverick's excellent how-to on PXE installing ESX, but that's no reason to forgo this treasure. There's a lot to say about having all of your go-to information in one place, and this book is it.

The book weighs in at over 800 pages, and unlike other technical books, size does not equal fluff. The authors are very to-the-point and clear in their explanations, and I'm sure likely struggled with having to draw the line on content. The size is also due to the fact that it is two books (Advanced Technical Design Guide and Advanced Operations Guide) packaged as one. By packaging this way, you're saving money. I wanted to name my favorite chapter, but found this impossible, because all of the chapters contain excellent information. That being said, here's a list of my personal favorites:

Advanced Technical Design Guide

* Chapter 4 - Virtual Center and Cluster Design
* Chapter 5 - Storage
* Chapter 6 - Networking Concepts and Strategies
* Chapter 7 - VMs and VM Selection
* Chapter 8 - Managing the Environment
* Chapter 10 - Recovery and Business Continuity

Advanced Operations Guide

* Chapter 2 - Networking
* Chapter 3 - Storage
* Chapter 10 - VMotion, DRS, and HA
* Chapter 11 - Backup and VMware Consolidated Backup
* Chapter 12 - ESX Command Line Configuration

Each chapter is loaded with tips, tricks, and gotchas founded on real experience. In fact, many of the gotchas that I've run into myself were right there in print, and the authors highlighted a few that I have yet to see. You'll find that having this book is like having an extra VMware consultant on staff. It's that good.

I waited for months to be able to purchase the VI3 ATDG once I first heard good reviews of the first version of the book from two VMware employees. However, I was unfortunately somewhat disappointed when I received the book and began reading. The book does cover most of VMware VI3 topics; though the authors took a very high level approach where items are quickly brushed over and you are left with the feeling that this book really isn't an "advanced" design guide but more of an addition to what you would receive in official VMware training. I also found the book to be poorly edited as there were numerous spelling and grammatical problems throughout the entire book--to the point it was distracting when reading. All in all, I do have to give the book 3-stars as it would be valuable to someone who was going to be implementing VMware VI3 without previous training. If you have taken VMware courses on VI3, save your money and continue using the material in your course books.

Technically sound and accurate. Learned a lot from the content, even though I have worked extensively with VMware products. The downside is that the editing is the worst I have seen in any book I have ever read. After hours of rereading for comprehension due to typos and grammatical errors, I started counting editing screw ups. I was at an error for every second paragraph, and at least 2 sections per page by the time I finally put the book away. I may pick it up again this year, but will probably just buy the next version's book. I will definitely take a look at the book on the shelf for readability before the purchase. Again, content is fantastic and very instructional, you just have to get past the horrible editing.

I bought the previous revision of this book when I stepped into my first VMware environment consisting of two SANs, six hosts, and a lot of questions. It was fairly insightful but lacked enough support of VI3.5. Now that I am running a global VM infrastructure with 3.5 throughout, it was time to upgrade the text. I was not disappointed. I have essentially based the new production farms' configs on examples from this book (tweaked for our environment) but the underlying logic has earned several compliments from VMware support.

For those of you who enjoy reading about technology in bed before embarking on a new adventure, this one actually comes along on pleasure trips as well. It's fun.

Oglesby and Herold have combined with well known RTFM author Mike Laverick to deliver a second knockout in their VMware ESX Advanced Technical Design Guide series. With coverage of VMware ESXi, you will not find a more complete and up to date book. I was fortunate enough to receive a preview copy of this book in February and look forward to receiving the final print edition soon. The previous books published by these authors have always traveled with me to the job site and to various VMware User Group meetings and conferences as a technical reference. This book will be no exception. I am confident each reader will find value in the concepts, discussions, and working examples the authors bring to the table from real world experience, in-depth research, and collaboration with other virtualization experts from around the world. This book is an ABSOLUTE_MUST_HAVE!

Probably it's not fair to leave a review for this item after 4 years since its publish date but generally speaking it still sounds "not too bad" if you would like to learn "some" fundamental topics of ESX. Some important chapters, however, are no longer useful like the networking chapter which basically is outdated now after introducing technologies like DVS and Cisco Nexus 1000v.
If you're after a funky very latest ESX technical document it's not for you but if you're still using ESX 3.x and are looking for some clarification on fundamental topics (pretty much the same across differnet versions and builds) this could be a nice resource.

The guys who brought you VMware ESX Server: Advanced Technical Design Guide have done it again - Ron Oglesby, Scott Herold and along with Mike Laverick delivered the ultimate guide to VI-3 which in addition to a Design Guide now includes an Operations Guide. The wait has been worth it - as a VMware Consultant and a VMware Certified Instructor it is critical to have a reference guide that is complete and accurate and this book delivers! Whether you are an end user of VMware products, a consultant or work for VMware this should be your key reference guide - I would suggest buying two because I am already well on my wearing out my first one.

I thought this book did a great job of first explaining how to design a virtual environment using VMWARE and a good job of how to install a Virtual environment using VMWARE.

This book is as good or better than the class room training. If you are looking to get up and running on VMWARE quick and want to do it right, this is the book for you.

This is an outstanding functional manual on VMware infrastructure 3 - specifically the design, technical nuances and intermediate to advanced operations of this virtualization software. Purchase of this is highly recommended if you have anything at all to do with installing, configuring or operating VMware software.

A VMware consultant suggested that this book was the ultimate VMWare reference, and the one book which any ESX admin should own. I found that not to be the case. I have found some useful info, but most of what I'd read was introductory material or high-level descriptions of the complexities of managing a complex VMware environment. It may be better suited to a beginner admin, but is not what I would expect from an "Advanced" guide.

The book actually consists of two manuals back-to-back, with a shared index (if you can call it that). That wouldn't be bad, except that there's quite a bit of repetition. For example, the sections covering resource pools and resource sharing are copied verbatim between the two sections, amounting to 8 pages of fluff which should have been edited out.

The index is nearly useless: only 6 pages to index an 800 page technical manual. Some of the index terms point to sections where the topic is barely covered, and miss other sections with more detail. The index also appears to have been generated by a word processor with little or no editing; the "HA" entry contains 65 page references, with no subdivisions. You basically have to skim through chapters to find the info you need.

The book does cover quite a bit of info in it, and it may be an okay choice for a beginner who wants to read it cover to cover. But if you already know a fair amount and want to use this as a detailed reference, I'd stay clear.