201 of 204 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Make this your first book on vaccinations, June 13, 2002
This review is from: Vaccinations: A Thoughtful Parent's Guide: How to Make Safe, Sensible Decisions about the Risks, Benefits, and Alternatives (Paperback)
Objectivity in the controversy of vaccinations is almost non-existent. Aviva Jill Romm has accomplished a singular feat in providing parents with an intelligent discussion of the issues without telling the parent which they should choose. Rather, she presents summaries of the most pertinent vaccination studies, analyzes difficulties in interpreting existing data, and explores thoughtful questions involved in the decision. She makes it clear that "to vaccinate or not to vaccinate" is not an easy question, and it has no easy answers that will suit everybody. To help parents make an educated decision, Romm also offers a succinct primer on how the immune system works, what symptoms and risks present with each "vaccine-preventable disease," and standard treatments for each disease. The last half of the book includes herbal remedies and recipes for common childhood diseases, as a supplement to other healthy choices to improve immune system functioning. This book serves as an outstanding reference on vaccination-related facts, a balanced decision guide for parents, and a handy cookbook for home remedies. I buy this book for my friends who are seriously and genuinely investigating the vaccination decision without prejudice.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
264 of 272 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Balanced, Informative, Well Documented, Essential, May 26, 2004
This review is from: Vaccinations: A Thoughtful Parent's Guide: How to Make Safe, Sensible Decisions about the Risks, Benefits, and Alternatives (Paperback)
Amidst the plethora of fanatical and unbalanced writing on vaccinations (both pro and anti), this book is the ONE book you should read on vaccinations. The author, a midwife who is supposedly working on her MD, covers the history of vaccinations, including the mistakes made. She covers each disease, it's risks and likelihood of complications, as well as each vaccine, it's risks and efficacy. It also provides a section on naturopathic approaches to immunity.
What I like about this book is:
- it does NOT tell you what to do
- it presents the pros and cons in a balanced fashion, almost to the point that you can't tell which side the author takes (in the end, I think she is mostly against vaccination)
- it discusses how to approach exemption, and how to deal with schools etc.
- it is fairly complete and up to date, and includes discussions of the more recent DTaP (v. DTP), and the chicken pox vaccine.
Check out this quote: " I have made an effort to substantiate the information in this book by relying heavily on medical literature and not vaccine-critical books or popular health books so that you have a fairly objective view of vaccine issues." p. 151.
What I don't like about this book is:
- it does NOT tell you what to do ;)
- if you decide to selectively vaccinate, it doesn't tell you enough about how you can deal with finding, for instance, vaccines that are just Diptheria and Tetanus, without Perstussis, or just one of the three of MMR.
WHAT I DECIDED TO DO
--------------------
I have a 6 month old daughter, who has not had any vaccinations yet. Here's a per vaccine list that I have decided so far:
- Hepatitis B: NO. They recommend that all children get this at birth, but according to Romm, this is because they can't actually vaccinate the real at-risk patients ahead of time, those who are IV-drug users and sexually promiscuous. I figure that the risks of getting Hep-B when the baby is so small are not worth it. She may get it when she approaches puberty, when her body is stronger. Romm also reports that between 10 and 17 percent of pediatricians are against hep-B immunization at birth.
- DTaP: Selective. First of all, the goverment's own guideline says that this can be given as early as 2 months (which most pediatricians do), but that the *optimal* time is 15 months! Not only that, it's 2 years old in Japan, and in Europe, the Pertussis vaccine is no longer given. Imagine that! However, since Diptheria and Tetanus are pretty serious, we plan on getting just those, but NOT pertussis. One of the problems with all vaccines, btw, is that they do NOT give you life-long immunity (with Pertussis, it's as low as 50%), so you are often better off getting the disease as a child - most of the diseases we vaccinate for, including chicken pox, measles, and mumps, have almost no long term affects for healthy children who get standard and timely medical attention. And, if you get the disease, you usually get lifetime immunity.
- Polio: NO. We may get this before we travel overseas, but there is no risk of getting it here in the States, and again, every time you inject a vaccine into the bloodstream, not only are you injecting all of the *other* ingredients (including other animal genetic material from the culture of the vaccines, and often metals such as mercury and aluminum) in a vaccine, but you are tampering with the immune system, and conferring questionable immunity (may not last). Of course, we no longer use the live OPV (Oral Polio Vaccine), and the non-live IPV can not give you polio.
- MMR: Still deciding, probably NOT.
- Chicken Pox: Still deciding, probably NOT.
- HiB (influenza B): Still deciding, probably YES.
Anyway, you get the idea. Now get this book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
140 of 142 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
From a father of a 2-yr old boy, September 8, 2003
This review is from: Vaccinations: A Thoughtful Parent's Guide: How to Make Safe, Sensible Decisions about the Risks, Benefits, and Alternatives (Paperback)
I am a father of a two-year old boy. Until the baby was born, I had never been aware of any issues surrounding pro or anti vaccination. My wife, I found out, is adamantly against just about every vaccination. Being deeply confused and frustrated when my wife simply refused to have the boy vaccinated, I decided to educate myself on the issue - so I can actually have civilized and educated discussions with my wife. In summer 2002 the reviewer below freedom2think kindly replied to me by stating that this book was the only non-biased book she had found on the subject issue. One by one, the book breaks down and discusses every major vaccine preventable disease and its respective vaccine known today in America in a manner that is easy to understand. It talks about the bio-chemical mechanism of how vaccines are supposed to work, its history, risks involved in both cases of vaccinated versus non-vaccinated, statistics, data, symptoms to watch and what-to-do in both cases where symptoms are observed. If does not tell you which side you should join, but rather helps you understand what really the issue is about and perhaps decide more comfortably. I would strongly recommend this book to you especially if you are a novice on the topic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
