Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Objective and engineering-based, June 1, 2008
Too many books on tube musical instrument amplifier design descend into subjectivity and waffle. Some, in attempting try to appeal too widely, lose rigor in explanation.
Kuehnel's volume manages to avoid becoming mired in theoretical detail yet remains analytically rigorous. The reader is expected to have a firm grasp of basic electronics and electronic components but explanations do not extend into the realm of system-function in frequency domain, laplace and fourier analysis. This contrasts with Kuehnel's seminal volume on the Fender Bassman 5F6-A, which is mathematically much more demanding.
The reader here is led quickly through basic triode operation and resistive divider networks. A reasonably comprehensive chapter on guitar pickup characteristics is included, this is extremely welcome as many works on similar subject neglect this topic, which is of fundamental importance. Further chapters cover topics of Miller capacitance, pentode operation, headroom, distortion, noise, cathode degeneration and parallel operation of triodes. The Ampeg B42X pre-amp is analysed, chosen because it does differ somewhat from the more familiar Fender Marshall circuits.
In keeping with the desire to use an engineering approach rather than that of a 'guru', Kuehnel includes data on real-world capacitor and resistor performance. He resists the temptation to pontificate on the vintage-component-tone-mojo debate and leaves it to the reader to assess the implications.
Tube gear is currently making a bit of a comeback in hi-fi, but it never really went away for guitar amplification.
To become a true guru on the topic one can't neglect the value of formal engineering training and recourse to the great texts of the 1950s and earlier by Frederick Terman and Langford-Smith etc. But those texts are general whilst this is specific to subject. Kuehnel doesn't include nearly as much information as contained within Kevin O'Connor's "Ultimate Tone" series but this book is better written, is more textbook like in nature, has fewer errors and in my opinion it is a far better initial investment for those serious about the subject.
So, I've just ordered Kuehnel's follow up volume on the power amp to keep the other two volumes that I've already bought company.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
A very serious book, May 28, 2009
Thanks to Dave Hunter, many musicians now have a grasp on what is happening inside their tube amp. If you are not interested in designing or modifying an amp, Hunter's books are all you need. But, if you want to start with a blank sheet of paper and build something from the ground-up; the info in Kuehnel's books (he also has a power amp book in this series), are the best of their type and unlike old school tube books that you find at a used book store; this book is specifically geared toward guitar and bass amps. There is alot of detailed info here so it is not something you can just read through, cover-to-cover. it is best to take it in small sections or, go directly to a section that interests you (I started with the effect of cathode bypass capacitors). All told, I am not sure if I will ever build an amp from scratch but using this info, I actually think that I can do it.
|
|
|
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Ouch my Head Hurts!!, December 6, 2008
This book is NOT for beginners...... I would say that if you do not have a degree in electronics, I would stay away from this book. If you do, then this would be a great book for you. I have no degree, and have read the book several times, and I would say I understand 10-20% of the book. Just Find another book.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|