From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 2—An African-American girl imagines that travelers come to town and that she changes places with a vagabond boy and goes traveling everywhere, ending: "A traveler,/a vagabond!/To wander/and to roam,/for maybe oh…/an hour or so…/And then I'll go back home!" The cartoon illustrations are well done and full of action, as the youngster visits the Taj Mahal, Holland, the Eiffel Tower, etc., and the text is framed on some pages with tassels hanging off a curtain, as if from a gypsy wagon. The overall effect is good, but the text is puzzlingly inconsistent, sometimes rhyming and sometimes not. A literal child might also wonder what the vagabond boy is wearing while the girl traipses around the world in his clothes-and apparently loses his red head scarf by the end. The book might conceivably be used as an example for a simple creative-writing assignment on a student's summer vacation experiences, imaginary or real. The illustrations are full of life, but the story is very slight and somewhat awkward.—
Judith Constantinides, formerly at East Baton Rouge Parish Main Library, LA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
As a vagabond caravan passes by a young girl's home, it sparks her to imagine trading places with one of the traveler children and going on a worldwide trek. She imagines visiting the windmills in Holland, dancing the hula in Hawaii, deep sea diving, visiting a Buddhist temple, the Eiffel Tower, and Taj Mahal, and riding a camel in the Egyptian desert. Her imaginary travels wind up at home where she realizes that she' d really only like to be gone maybe an hour or so. Although the story line is rather simple, the illustrations have an appealing whimsy that should kindle a child's own imaginary travels to exotic locales. --ChildrensPictureBook.info Review (Feb. 2007)
When reviewing books by college kids, do I shelve my standards? Do I give ''em a break, put my skepticism on hold, temporarily suspend my snarky disdain for the mediocre, the boring, the been-there-read-that cliches? Or do I give 'em a dose of harsh, welcome to the real world, Toto-we're-not-in-Kansas-anymore reality? I didn't know what to expect when the nice folks at Red Cygnet emailed to say they had this new idea for an imprint: picture books by college art students. I was pretty sure I wouldn''t see stick figures in crayon. After that, who knew? Fortunately, the lot has proved decent enough, and this one stood out for its simplicity, though darned if that rhyme scheme keeps fading in and out. The illustrations, however, are sprightly and appealing as a girl trades places with a gypsy or "vagabond" and dons a red kerchief and gold hoop earrings. We get a quickie around-the-world tour--from Sydney to Tibet to the Taj Mahal and Paris and then, of course, back home in time for supper. The back flap says George studied travel sketching, and the book has the simplicity of doodles filled out with dabs of watercolor. Bonus points for portraying a full rainbow of ethnicities too. Rating: *\*\*\ (Excellent) --BookBuds, October 2006
This story traverses the mind of a young girl eager to travel and explore. With ideas of traveling to enchanting places in the world, this story promotes the power of imagination and of dreams. It speaks also of the comfort of home. The descriptive illustrations take us on a journey all over world and even under the sea. Through example, this story gives the opportunity for the reader to understand exactly what it means to be a vagabond. --Children's Literature