7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great character-driven romance, September 15, 2008
This review is from: Valentine (Mass Market Paperback)
Over the weekend I re-read Valentine by Jane Feather. This is a classic marriage-of-convenience book written in 1995, and it has a treasured space on my keeper shelf. I think what I like about it so much is the characters -- not just the hero and shero, but the secondary characters as well.
In this story, 35-year-old Sylvester Gilbraith learns that his eldely cousin has died, making Sylvester the new 5th Earl of Stonebridge. Unfortunately for Sylvester, however, the crafty old earl had arranged his will in such a way that while Sylvester inherits the entailed title and three houses that go along with the title, he does not inherit one acre of land or one pound of the old earl's fortune...UNLESS, that is, he can marry, on one month's time, one of the old earl's four granddaughters. So Sylvester sets off for his new home, fully intending to offer for one of the young women, whether they suit or not. Once arrived at Stonebridge, he discovers that the eldest daughter is already engaged, the youngest daughter is but 12, and the second-eldest daughter -- his natural choice, given her age -- would not suit him in the least. That leaves the third-eldest daughter, Theodora: fifteen years his junior, her grandfather's favorite, and a frighteningly competent and strong-willed steward of the estate. Sylvester and Theo naturally spark off one another upon their very first meetting, but Theo's mother Elinor, informed by Sylvester of the details of the old earl's will, agree that they may suit perfectly and so Sylvester sets off to woo his prickly bride.
What I liked about Theo and Sylvester's relationship is that, in general, they're both very much up-front with each other about their feelings and reactions. Theo, who loved her grandfather intensely and still grieves the loss of her father when she was a child, is heartbroken over the old man's death and views Sylvester very much as an unwelcome intruder. But she also instinctively recognizes, as do the rest of her family members, that Sylvester is, at the core of him, a nice man. He doesn't try to shove them out of their home, and it's Sylvester who comforts Theo when the dam breaks and she finally grieves in earnest. There's an instant sexual attraction between Sylvester and Theo, and while he's not above using that attraction to help lure Theo in, he's not callous or unfeeling. Theo, for her part, is honest enough to admit that part of her hesitancy to accept Sylvester's suit is due to the fact that she fears he will swallow her up...that she'll lose her identity and sense of Self as his wife. But it's clear that that's not something Sylvester wants. He WANTS them to have a partnership and not a relationship in which he dominates.
The conflict in this story has to do with an event in Sylvester's past, when he was an officer in the Napoleonic Wars. Unfortunately, he sustained a head injury during the final battle and was then imprisoned for twelve months by the French, and he cannot remember important events of that last battle. But there are accusations of cowardice and he was court-martialed, although he was acquited. Still, despite his acquittal, his reputation has suffered, and since he can't quite recall the events in question, there's little he can do to clear his name. Gradually, though, the pieces start to fall into place and Theo insists on helping him uncover the truth, whether he wants her help or not. Initially he's hesitant to involve her, mostly because he fears her reaction and he can't bear the thought that she would look at him with suspicion and believe the accusations of cowardice, but he learns soon enough that Theo has his back, both literally and figuratively, and that she won't be shut out of his private battles.
In my mind, this is not necessarily a strong A-rating book, but it still hits all the right chords for me. What wins me over with a romance is the characters, and I loved the relationship between Theo and Sylvester. There were no games between them and neither had to pretend to be something he or she wasn't, and their relationship has all the markings of a true partnership. This is one of those books in which I turned the last page and immediately began imagining what the rest of their life would be like together. I have no doubt that that there would be respect and friendship and deep mutual love, punctuated by moments of temperamental fireworks. Which all in all, I guess, sounds just wonderful.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Older man and younger woman- hot, July 5, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Valentine (Mass Market Paperback)
First of all, the HEROINE's name is Theo, one of 4 sisters. The HERO's name is Sylvester, once accused of cowardice during the Napoleonic Wars! He is 15 years older, darker, brooding, etc. She is called a "hoyden, wild, and impulsive". The story concerns their love and the problems they solve together.
I wish reviewers could SPELL correctly! A typical Jane Feather- great plot, dialogue, etc. All of her books enthrall me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best Romance has to offer . . ., September 21, 2000
This review is from: Valentine (Mass Market Paperback)
This, quite plainly, is the best romance novel I've ever had the pleasure of engrossing myself into. It was the 1ST romance novel I read & I realized that I continue to read everyone I come across to see if it will equal up to Valentine, Unfortunately, they never do. The use of language is exquisite, the characters are sensual yet quirky and the plot easily followed but hard to guess at. Gabrielle is funny, innocent, stubborn, and hopelessly in love while her sensual counterpart, Slyvester is strong, cumbersome, forceful, and in charge of every situation. Buy it, Read it, Love it, Dream it. Valentine. & if you liked Valentine, Vice, also Jane Feather, and Master of Midnight, by Penelope Neri will also capture your heart.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No