Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful love story based on true story, January 3, 2007
For lovers of history and romance, this accurate portrayal of the Roman Empire with all its glory and debauchery, is revealed through intimate details of a few men and one very special woman.
The story begins when Valentine, a teenager and slave, is assisting his master, Dr. Theophrastus, with the difficult birth of a child. Valentine is awestruck and fascinated by the drama, yet unaware of how his life will be changed for eternity by this tiny newborn girl, Julia--born without sight.
The event compels him to study medicine and he becomes a compassionate and caring doctor, and eventually the personal physician to Quintus--the procurator of the games. Valentine struggles between the pagan lifestyle of the Romans and the moral teachings of ancient philosophers. He does not, however; chose to follow the teachings of one "philosopher," Jesus Christ--the radical from Galilee who claimed he could raise people from the dead and give them eternal life. Preposterous, thought Valentine.
Displeasing his employer whose son Valentine could not heal, he finds himself in jail on false charges of being a Christian--a death sentence. This is where the love story begins.
Julia and Valentine have met only once before (excluding her birth), but neither can forget their meeting. Secret visits from Julia in jail are Valentine's only comfort. Julia, now a devoted Christian, is determined to change Valentine's heart before he meets his fate.
A wonderful story that is very moving.
Armchair Interview says: Excellent read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not Raymo's best, May 8, 2011
This review is from: Valentine: A Love Story (Hardcover)
I love Chet Raymo. He's written books that have changed the way I've experienced the world, such as WHEN GOD IS GONE, EVERYTHING IS HOLY, and CLIMBING BRANDON. I also loved his novel, THE DORK OF CORK, and thoroughly enjoyed IN THE FALCON'S CLAW. In this novel, loosely based on the life of St. Valentine, there is much to admire. Raymo does lovely things with language. However, there are huge point of view problems in this work, and the structure didn't quite work for me, although I admire its ambitions. Raymo chooses four POVs -- epistolary, first person -- both Valentine's and that of his jailer/father of his lover -- and third. The letters are adequate although the language doesn't ring quite true (a bit too flowery, and the corresponding characters sound too alike), the third confusing and the two firsts (if you will), flawed. By flawed I mean that the first person narrator often narrates action that takes place while he's out of the scene, and meanders into the private thoughts of other characters, which of course (unless he's telepathic) he simply can't do. It's jarring, and for me it spoiled what should have been a better book.
Still, the pleasure of the book lies in the philosophical tension between those who believe in a Christian God (or any god, for that matter, Mithras does not come off well), and those who don't. And here Raymo, who is a fabulous science writer and who calls himself a religious naturalist, is in peak form. When the characters are arguing their respective positions it's deeply thought-provoking and satisfying.
Still, if you aren't well acquainted with Raymo's other, superior, work I wouldn't suggest you begin here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
I could not put it down, February 22, 2007
This review is from: Valentine: A Love Story (Hardcover)
Reviewed by Stephanie Rollins for Reader Views (12/06)
I really did not want to read "Valentine" by Chet Raymo. I do not like any story that is historical. The cover of "Valentine" turned me off even more. It reeked of history.
I was quite surprised that as I delved into the story, I could not put it down. The love story really did not unfold until the end. Until then, Chet Raymo blended history into this intriguing novel, and he made it exciting.
He showed how the early Christians were considered to be superstitious, and traitorous. He created characters that had to suffer for their religious beliefs. As an American, I have always taken the right of religious freedom for granted. I now realize how fortunate we are.
Chet Raymo reminded me of the advances we have in medicine. Valentine, a physician, was considered to be strange, because he actually studied medicine. On the other hand, there were many other healers who simply were ignorant of physiology and pharmacy or were simply quacks.
Perhaps the most unsettling tradition was that of the death matches in the amphitheatre. Crowds would gather to see a person fight another person or animal until one dies. The crowd enjoyed seeing it! "Aptus, too, will thrill when his sword slips under the Egyptian's helmet and the blood gushes downward like water spilled from a bowl."
The fighting and death are seen as sexual. "The managers of the games know what they are doing when they recruit the best looking female slaves for these diversions. Every cock in the amphitheatre was stiff when she went down."
The love story is between Valentine and Julia. Valentine assisted in Julia's birth. He ended up falling in love with her. When Valentine held Julia after her birth, he "was astonished at its miniature perfection." He describes his desire for her as a woman. "I see Julia's slender body--her breast, her belly, the cottony swelling of her sex." If you stop to think of that with today's standards, that is a little twisted. Just look past that. Julia supports Valentine through imprisonment and escape.
Julia is punished for her belief in Christianity by having to fight a pack of wolves in the amphitheatre. Her father debates on whether or not to see his only child, who is blind, suffer a horrendous death. He wants to go. He thinks maybe his presence will provoke pity, leading to her release. What if it does not? He will see his daughter torn from limb to limb, chewed on and digested by beasts.
"Valentine" is a page-turner. Just when I thought the story had come to a finish, another turn was taken. For a thrilling historical adventure, "Valentine" is a great choice.
Book Received FREE of Charge
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|