From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6-A fascinating chronology of the discoveries and explorations-by professionals and amateurs-of the tombs in the Valley of the Kings. The first two chapters look at earlier organized projects beginning with Napoleon's French Expedition and the discovery of the Rosetta Stone up to the early 20th century. Next, the text is devoted to Howard Carter's famous discovery of Tutankhamun's tomb. Following this is a chapter discussing on-going work on a "missing" tomb, KV5, by Kent Weeks and his team. In addition to providing this informative history, the authors also give insight into the politics and personalities of the various projects involved in archaeological work in the Valley. The final chapter tells of the discoveries of caches of mummies removed from their tombs by ancient officials as well as thieves looking for loot, and how scientists are using modern research methods and DNA to identify remains, prove family relationships, health problems, and causes of death. The easy-to-read text is enhanced by good-quality, color photographs of artifacts, period photographs, reproductions of artwork, and maps. An interview between the authors discusses Smith's archaeological career and Egyptology consultant work on several movies, which should interest young readers. Unfortunately, most of the titles recommended for further reading are for adults. Melvin and Gilda Berger's Mummies of the Pharaohs (National Geographic, 2001) has spectacular photographs but lacks much of the detail found in this new title.
Cynthia M. Sturgis, Ledding Library, Milwaukie, ORCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"This book sets a benchmark for quality nonfiction....Pairing an archaeologist with a science writer has produced a strong text....Students will be particularly intrigued with the interview that discusses Smith's initial interest in archaeology in the fifth grade, as well as his work with such contemporary movies as
The Mummy and
The Mummy Returns....A surefire winner. Highly recommended." --
Library Media Connection"The text is fascinating while being literate and easy to undertand. The illustrations include photographs that have not been used in other books on the topic....A good addition to any library. Although the book is intended for readers in junior high and high school, adults will enjoy it as well." --
Catholic Library World"This account of the archaeological exploration of Egypt's Valley of the Kings includes the discoveries of 19th-century circus strongman-turned-archaeologist Giovanni Belzoni and Howard Carter's sensational uncovering of King Tuthankhamun's tomb in the 1920s. Photographs of stunning artifacts and creepy, desiccated pharaohs will surely fascinate elementary school readers." --
Odyssey