7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Tom Pawlik's "Valley of the Shadow": A Review, July 15, 2009
This review is from: Valley of the Shadow (Paperback)
Vanish was terrifying. I remember reading through the night just to make sure there would be sunlight shining through the slats if I woke from a nightmare. There is nothing more frightening than waking up to a pitch black room that still manages to have shadows playing tricks on your mind.
And sometimes it's more about what you don't see than what you see. Because, as I sit here and consider Pawlik's latest offering, Valley of the Shadow, the sequel to Vanish, I don't recall blood, guts, or gore that would haunt my visions at night. That seems to be Pawlik's strength--allowing your imagination to run wild. He's a minimalist like that. Your mind does most of the work for you, while he tells the story.
Pawlik uses the same formula he used in Valley's predecessor, an ensemble cast of characters traversing a strange place between life and death called "Interworld." The first book's protagonist and hero Connor Hayden is back, as are Mitch and Devon. Only, this time around, Pawlik spends more time outside "Interworld" than he did in the first one.
But, this time around, there seems to be more a malevolent, pointed force trying to destroy our wandering souls. A mystery surrounds farmer Howard Bristol and that forces the reader to grapple with questions about our choices and the consequences of abusing the free will given to us. The interplay of the story and moral are not as easy to ascertain as the first book, but its there if you're looking for it. The characters, at times, come across as a little cookie cutter, but they're easily identifiable and believable enough that it's forgivable. Also, Pawlik does a good job of humanizing these cardboard cutout characters, making them infinitely relatable, despite the fact we've met them time and time again in novels, both Christian and secular.
My only difficulty with this story is that in one sense it panders to those kinds of readers who need tidy bows and resolution to make their faith-based reading make sense. Vanish left the story open-ended. You didn't exactly know what way it went for certain characters, but you got the sense that it continued and you didn't have to know what happened to them in order for the present story to feel complete. Actually, that gave the story a sense of beauty and mystery that I appreciated. Thus, creating a sequel messes with that beauty somewhat. Those readers got their nice tidy bow and we all got more story, but we lost a little of the beauty we were initially left with.
My personal concerns aside, Pawlik's Valley of the Shadow is still a strong offering that will leave the reader looking for things that go bump in the night. And, more than that, Pawlik treads theological minefields that make for really interesting dialogue between the characters. In many ways, the dialogue is so good, it feels as if you're watching a good movie on DVD. Though, if I'm honest, it didn't always feel as organic as it was in the first book. I wonder if this is a problem of all sequels? Did I so fall in love with Vanish that Valley of the Shadow could never live up to it? I hope that is not the case, but I freely admit that it could be.
If you haven't read Vanish, I'd suggest starting there. Valley of the Shadow will be a much richer experience if you do. In the end, Pawlik never preaches. He tells a story. A parable of sorts. And the lessons our characters learn of choice, temptation, sacrifice, risk, influence, and reward are all lesson we would do good to learn. An emotionally compelling thriller that will keep you up at night. Nice job, Tom. Keep `em coming.
All told, I'd recommend Valley of the Shadow to anyone. It is fast-paced, engaging and is a great continuation of what was started in Pawlik's debut, Vanish. A strong second offering, we look forward to reading more from this exciting author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Filled out the series, July 6, 2011
This review is from: Valley of the Shadow (Paperback)
In my review of the previous book in this series, Vanish, I mentioned that the book didn't go to very many possible story angles. In this book, however, much more possibility is explored. Many, many things were unexpected. Also unlike the last book, the story ended in a very satisfying way. It also presents more opportunity to delve into the idea. The Christian themes of the book were pretty apparent, some being Heaven, faith, and prayer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No