Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Vanishing American, October 22, 2004
This review is from: The Vanishing American (DVD)
For anyone under the impression that Hollywood's sympathetic treatment of the American Indian occurred no earlier that BROKEN ARROW, and certainly no later than DANCES WITH WOLVES, and that John Ford discovered and was the first to paint cinematic masterpieces against the magnificent backdrop that is Monument Valley, THE VANISHING AMERICAN will come as a shock and revelation. Not only was Hollywood doing it before the movies talked, in many ways they were doing it much better.
Richard Dix stars as Nophaie, leader of a Navajo Indian tribe living on a Mesa, Arizona reservation and participant in a love-triangle of sorts between saintly teacher Lois Wilson and corrupt Indian agent Noah Beery.
It's a while before THE VANISHING AMERICAN introduces its main players and arrives to tell its modern day story, though. Whole populations of peoples arise, flourish and die off against the imposing mesas and bluffs and desert stretches of Monument Valley, a Monument Valley presented without quite the muscular suppleness technology allowed Ford in the coming decades. The first reel takes us from cliff dwellers to basket weavers to the mid-16th century arrival of Spanish explorers. The root causes of a group's destruction is clearly presented. Priests are mocked and ridiculed, the martial spirit is stunted or non-existent, people become fat and lazy. These pre-Columbian slackers are ripe for the plucking, and plucked they are. But even a martial race, Nophaie's ancestors, are helpless against the technologically superior Europeans, who first appear riding "monsters" and carrying "thunder sticks." This slightly dubious cultural Darwinism, which puts the pious warrior at the top of the food chain, undergirds the movie, so it's no surprise that Nophaie is constantly presented as the greatest warrior in his tribe.
What makes THE VANISHING AMERICAN remarkable is its critique of then present-day Indian relationships. The Mesa Navajos have been herded onto a barely fertile strip of land. The Indian agent steals their horses and their land. Treaties have been made and broken. A number of Native American men volunteer for service in World War One and come back with honors only to discover that Indian agent Beery has discovered another method of bilking his charges. Still cheated.
What I liked most about THE VANISHING AMERICAN was that it took a sensitive look at issues critics of Westerns rightly accuse the genre of ignoring: betrayal, broken promises, corruption, even miscegenation anxieties. Another strength of the movie is that it addresses what was then current conditions. The final act in this 1925 pits WWI Navajo vets against a corrupt Indian agency. There appears to be a number of Native American extras in this one, as well.
The print is in good shape, all things considered. There are no extras save chapter selections, but a new score (considering the applause heard at the end, I assume it was recorded live) makes this a worthy addition to any Western fan's collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Zane Grey's western novel turned into a silent film epic, November 27, 2003
This review is from: The Vanishing American (DVD)
"The Vanishing American" is one of the great silent epics. Directed by George B. Seitz from a Zane Gray story, this 1925 silent film stars Richard Dix as Nophaie, a modern American Indian who heroically fights the Germans on the battlefields of Europe in World War I only to return home and find his people are still being horribly mistreated by a crooked Indian Agent named Booker, played by Norah Berry. One of the first films filmed on location in Monument Valley, this 148-minute epic also stars Lois Wilson as Marion Warner, the local schoolmarm who encourages Nophaie to make something of himself, and if you can spot Gary Cooper as an extra in this one you have better eyes than I do (but that is not saying anything). "The Vanishing American" puts the plight of the Indians in the context of the inevitable march of history where one culture inevitable crushes another. Yes, there are melodramatic elements and the acting is slightly above par for a silent film, but there is a sense of scope and an attempt to make a "message" film that I appreciate given the times. Remade in 1955 with Scott Brady, Forrest Tucker and Audrey Totter in the three main roles, except now the hero's name is "Blandy"; I rest my case. Trivia Note: the production brought a herd of 14 bisons to Catalina Island for the film and ended up leaving them behind. Today the herd has grown to about 225 and is actually being hunted to control their numbers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Unjust treatment of the Navajo nation, October 10, 2008
Adapted from Zane Grey's novel, THE VANISHING AMERICAN was filmed on location in Monument Valley and the Betatakin Cliff Dwellings of Arizona. It's in part a history of western Native-Americans and the progression of conquests right up to the white man's defeat of the Navajo and the tribe's relocation to a reservation.
Just after the turn of the 20th Century, a corrupt Indian agent steals and sells to the highest bidder the tribe's best horses. With America's involvement in the Great War in Europe, a captain comes in search of the horses the agent was supposed to have paid for and delivered to the Army.
A kindly schoolteacher convinces a tribal leader (Richard Dix as Nophaie) that if his people help the war effort they will get justice when the fighting ends. Believing her, the leader delivers horses to the military and he and several braves enlist for service overseas. After the Armistice, they return home to "business as usual" and most feel the time has come for revenge. An army of Navajos besieges a government stronghold, and only Nophaie stands between them and all-out war.
THE VANISHING AMERICAN is also available on DVD.
In the early sound era, Richard Dix starred in the first western to win a Best Picture Oscar. CIMARRON is the epic story of the Oklahoma Land Rush and a heroic man who built from scratch a city and newspaper. ( VHS version) ( DVD version)
Parenthetical number preceding title is a 1 to 10 viewer poll rating found at a film resource website.
(7.8) The Vanishing American (1925) - Richard Dix/Lois Wilson/Noah Beery/Malcolm McGregor/Shannon Day/Charles Crockett (uncredited: Gary Cooper)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
