Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lyrical but Anguished, August 1, 2005
Abdelrahman Munif's novels are brilliantly written and, in my opinion, offer the same satisfactions as the novels of Gogol and Dostoyevsky; in this particular novel, the tone is much more lyrical and wistful, and the characters behave with more heroic motives, than in "Cities of Salt" (tragic) or "The Trench" (satirical). This describes the series of struggles for control of the soon-to-be Sultanate of Mooran, both within the [Saudi-modelled] royal house, and among rival clans.
Set in the 1920's, when the fate of the Arabian Peninsula was uncertain, and the role of the British Foreign & Colonial Office was potentially decisive, this novel pays special attention to the relationship between Khureybit and Hamilton. Hamiton, incidentally, is based on Harry St. John Bridger Philby (or Jack Philby, father of Kim Philby; Wikipedia has an excellent write-up on him). The tension between Hamilton's concerns about the growing corruption in the Mooran ruling house, and his loyalty to Khureybit, are sensitively and carefully portrayed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Mooran more - last of a trilogy, March 19, 2008
This review is from: Variations on Night and Day (Hardcover)
Mr. Maclean's excellent review gives you the historical perspective and Amazon's description gives you the story details of Munif's final book in his Cities of Salt trilogy.
While I didn't enjoy this quite as much as the first two, it was still an enthralling read - if for no other reason than Munif's ability to write and Theroux's ability to translate.
The trilogy provides an in depth story of a way of life that we can hardly fathom. The time span covered is not that long ago, but impossible to recapture except for dry textbooks or (much better) books by someone like Munif. I'm not sure there is another Munif, and if there is I'm don't know how a better job could be done.
Read this for enjoyment. But make sure your mind is fully engaged so you can achieve some understanding of a place and time which is the basis for so much of our current world.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A haunting look at the human relations behind the scenes of nation building, October 20, 2010
This novel is set in the 1920s and `30s--before the introduction of the automobile--in an Arab and Muslim nation called Mooran, which could very well be the early Saudi Arabia. The description of the novel on the back cover gives us only a sketch: the novel _Variations on Night and Day_ "chronicles the creation of a Persian Gulf nation by a corrupt Arab monarch and conniving British empire builders." Of course, it's more complex. The human relations involved are tricky to map because the British character, Hamilton, is essentially well-intentioned, even idealistic--in contrast to the two other British agents of empire--and Khureybit is a clever, even wise, local ruler. The tension arises--as the reader might expect--when the British decide to expand their "national interests" and aren't sure if they should give the money and guns to Khureybit or to one of his two Arab/Muslim neighbors. Just at this time, Khureybit decides he wants to go from being an emir to becoming Sultan by expanding his domains; when he shows his strength in small battles, he earns British attention and the money and guns to take over the two neighboring nations (one of which, Awali, is actually culturally superior to Mooran).
The key factors in the British ability to expand their colonial outposts are that they hire intellectually bright men. Yes, the empire builders are talented, ambitious, and know how to ratchet up the tension with a few words, or how to vacate the scene and be gone long enough to be missed by the Sultan. While Hamilton becomes indispensable, Khureybit has complex advisors--Abu Mishael and Ibn Bakhit--and two intelligent and complex sons--Khazael and Fanar. The key factors which Khureybit must manage if he is to succeed at this grand game are the Muslim fundamentalists who--you guessed it--claim that Khureybit is too close to the British infidels. Fanar is the son chosen to learn English and visit London with Hamilton. Miss Margot, Hamilton's aunt, is well-educated, literate, and culturally savvy about imperial strategies; her presence in the novel shows the stark contrast between European women and the Arab women who have no such freedoms but must burn-out their intelligence in palace intrigues.
Originally published in Arabic in 1989, _Variations on Night and Day_ is the third book in Munif's triology, which includes _Cities of Salt_, and _The Trench_. Clearly this novel is the prehistory of our 21st-century international relations. In one of the final scenes, after Sultan Khureybit has militarily controlled his neighboring nations, and seemingly garnered the patronage of the British empire, he and his Arab advisors know such victories are only temporary. The British advisors announce that they think there is oil under the sand and are sending a crew to investigate. Well, that is to be expected, but to read this novel is to be able to write your notes in the margins of the book at exactly the places where someone says something that tips the balance of power one way or another.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|