4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Girardi's images will haunt you, December 4, 1999
By A Customer
I haven't ever read anything written by this author aside from these short stories, so I cannot make any comparison's for you, but I was impressed with Girardi's ability to create suspense and "mood" with his words. Several of the stories ran through my mind for days after I read them. I guess I don't agree with the other reviewers. I think that this book is great BECAUSE the stories are disturbing and BECAUSE some of the scenerios are so far-fetched. Plus, the plots seemed very different to me despite the fact that they all dealt with similar issues of choice, fear, and regret. I look forward to reading one of Girardi's novels. To the other reviewers I say- instead of feeling threatened by the melancholy atmosphere of the book, perhaps you should figure out why it bothers you so.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Stuff, January 31, 2003
This review is from: A Vaudeville of Devils: 7 Moral Tales (Paperback)
We read this for our bookgroup, putting an end to three years of my intending to read it. The seven stories here range from 20-110 pages and are united by both the theme or morality and Girardi's excellent writing and ability to create a vibrant sense of place and dark tone. He's said in interviews that he's deeply influenced by Poe and Hawthorne, and it's entirely evident here, for these are not short stories in the modern style, but tales in the old-fashioned sense. Spanning genres, from historical fiction, to sci-fi, to thriller, to crime, to romance, the stories revolve around moral choices faced by individuals. The stories are not perfect however, due to their semi-mythic nature, some wander rather close to cliché and predictability. And at times, certain characters are a little too single-minded or focused on one thing. Different people will, of course, have their own favorites.
The opening story, "The Demons...", is the brief WWII tale set in occupied Holland. The tale of an SS officer ordered to kill a Dutch painter can almost be considered a warm-up for the rest of the tales. The next story, "Three Ravens on A Red Ground," is the least nuanced of the seven, and probably my least favorite. It switches back and forth between the story of a Seattle businessman whose firm is being bought out by a Japanese firm, and the story of his ancestor who fought in the Crusades. "The Dinner Party" follows it with a brief semi-surreal tale of alien invasion in which the question is raised as to whether one should compromise one's ideals in order to alleviate suffering for many. As a take on "The Last Supper" it's not a bad idea, full of vivid imagery, but not particularly satisfying either.
The fourth tale, "The Primordial Face," was my favorite-though interestingly enough, the least favorite of many of the people in my book club. It's the story of a Yemeni businessman in pursuit of a mythic treasure lost at sea who hires two freelance divers, one Cuban-American, one German, to join him on a secret expedition. There's a great mood of dark adventure and tension that builds to a somewhat uneven conclusion. Still, this is the tale that had me engrossed far more than any other. "Arcana Mundi" is an interesting sci-fi story set in Napa Valley of the past, just after a plague has wiped out the grape harvest. The moral question here is again one of whether one should sacrifice for a greater good or not. It engendered more discussion amongst our group than any of the other stories.
The sixth tale, "The Defenestration of Aba Sid" is a legal/crime story set in Washington, D.C. It concerns a hopeless public defender who gets assigned the murder case of a notorious Russian mafia type so that the Feds can be sure the Russian will get convicted. It's not really clear why the Russian can't hire a "real" lawyer, but putting that aside... The realization of why he is assigned the case transforms the public defender from schmuck to determined worker, and he digs deep into the Russian's case. The crime story is fairly interesting, as is the Russian Mafia background material. The moral issue reveals itself at the very end, and revolves around the notion of justice. The final story, "Sunday Evenings", revolves around an American expatriate in Naples, and is rather languid and desultory.
Altogether a highly satisfactory reading experience and one that'll have me seeking more of Girardi's work out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great, but the title is misleading..., April 26, 2001
...the "moral" part that is. I say misleading because "moral" implies that the author will be shoving his own personal world view down the reader's the throat. Thankfully, this couldn't be further from the truth! Rather moral refers to the value judgements the characters in each of these stories is forced to make; decisions which form the crux of each story.
The stories are already outlined in Amazon's review, so I won't rehash them. Two points worth making, however. First, each story is unique, and remarkably imaginative. They bear comparison in terms of the characters' feelings and decisions, but the similarity ends there. Second, Girardi is a remarkably talented writer, with a style very reminscent of Poe. The stories are frequently dark, even brooding, but their careful crafting and obvious literary merit save them from being tedious.
"Vaudeville of Devils" is a unique collection of wonderfully rich short stories. Even better, the theme of moral crisis will leave the reader chewing over them for some time to come. Enjoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No