From Publishers Weekly
Given an unfinished story about dolphins by the late author of Island of the Blue Dolphins as completed by that author's widow, the temptation to publish must have been strong-but it should have been resisted. A familiar adventure indeed seems to beckon as Coral, a girl dolphin, seeks her older brother to aid their pod against attacks by killer whales, or orcas. Her journey becomes a catalogue of human abuse of sea life (including drift nets, whaling and otter-hunting), and it culminates in Coral's capture for a Sea World-type exhibit. All seems to be lost but, far too coincidentally, her brother and the leader of the orcas have also been taken; Coral compassionately helps the orca gain his freedom, and he, whistling "salmon and seals. No dolphins," lets her know that he will not be feasting on her pod. Her brother in turn rescues Coral, in her case from fruitless love for one of her keepers, and eventually she, too, heads for home waters. Unchecked anthropomorphism, sentimental incidents of interspecies cooperation and other moralizing outweigh any interest generated by the action. Ages 12-up.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 4^-6. O'Dell began this manuscript, and his wife finished it after he died. Coral, the narrator, is a young, female dolphin whose father sends her to find her brother and bring him home to help the pod, which is beset by orcas. On her journey, she meets humans, an enemy worse than the orcas, who seem determined to kill everything in the sea. Eventually, Coral is captured and set to work training rescue divers for the navy. She also falls in love, but Mark, a human, has too many limitations for underwater living. The dolphin characters are not interestingly developed, and Coral's crush on Mark seems silly. What redeems the book are its scientific underpinnings and its underwater perspective on dolphin hunting and shows, which readers will find more attractive than the anthropomorphic characters or the plot.
Mary Harris Veeder