| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A good story not well told,
By A Customer
This review is from: A Very Public Offering: A Rebel's Story of Business Excess, Success, and Reckoning (Hardcover)
Now that the dust has settled, the volatility of the stock market during the dot-com boom is a memory that is already disappearing in the rear-view mirror of our collective conscious. It is time for the stories and histories to be told - the recent film Startup.com chronicled the rise and fall of, as you might have guessed, a dot-com startup; this book from Stephan Paternot, cofounder of theglobe.com, is ostensibly in the same vein.After a prologue talking about the euphoria of IPO day (on which theglobe.com's share price jumped by 1000% before closing up 700% for the first day), Paternot (with a little help from a ghost-writer) talks the reader through his early life, up until his entry into college at Cornell, and the founding of his company. I say, "talks through his life" - that is precisely the tone of the book. It comes across as more than a little rushed, though the story is consistently gripping enough that it scarcely matters that the author's writing style would not be out of place in a Dick and Jane story. There is no doubt that Paternot and his friend and business partner, Todd Krizelman, were in the game right from the very beginning, and created what was probably a terrific Web site that became the Apple Macintosh's number one online community destination. For a pair of 20-somethings, this was a wonderful achievement, and Paternot is rightly proud of his company and its achievements. Some might say a little too proud, and the hubris in the book is sometimes breathtaking; for example, it might surprise aficionados of the internal combustion engine to hear that apparently the Internet is the most important human invention since movable type... though there is little doubt in my mind that the author's enthusiastic knack for hyperbole was probably what allowed him to convince a number of business big-shots to buy into his vision (most notably the ex-Chairman of Alamo Rent-A-Car, Michael Egan). The book continues on, talking a great deal about stock price movement, and betraying the author's bitterness that theglobe.com was never quite so over-priced as so many other dot-coms (theglobe.com was one of the first companies whose value slid dramatically). Dust-jacket hints about salacious stories of an unconventional rebel wild-child flying in the face of the business establishment are few and far between, unfortunately - I was hoping for a few more tales of bacchanalian debauchery, but Paternot's life doesn't sound too different to that of most young, professional Manhattanites. Nonetheless, it's certainly an interesting read by a talented person - that talent may not be in the literary field, but then you would hardly read the autobiography of Richard Branson and grumble about lack of literary merit. Ultimately, though, the book fizzles out in a rather unsatisfying way, and I was left with the overwhelming sensation that it was as if the company had never really existed... Perhaps it is fitting, then, that despite Paternot's pride in the fact that his company was still operating at the time of publication, all that is left of theglobe.com today is a message on the Web site: "In 1995, theglobe.com confirmed the Internet's power to connect people worlds apart. Unfortunately, after six amazing years, theglobe.com closed its doors on August 15, 2001... Thank you for your patronage and for the incredible support over the years. Sincerely, theglobe.com"
9 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great idea. Poor execution.,
This review is from: A Very Public Offering: A Rebel's Story of Business Excess, Success, and Reckoning (Hardcover)
While reading a Very Public Offering, I was terribly disappointed and planned on coming to Amazon to pan the book. But, when I came here, I was taken aback by the virtiol in some of the comments. So, let me temper the criticism by stating that there is a *VERY* good story here. That said, the presentation is flawed on numerous levels and I'm not sure if blame should be placed on Essex (the co-writer) or Paternot. But since Stephen may be thinking of turning his book into a movie, here's some comments about the book's structure.First off, every character in this book, save for Paternot and his dad, come across as two dimensional. While most minor characters can be drawn this way, Todd, Stephen's mom, and Stephen's girlfriend need character arcs. They need to have their own struggles in this story, which may require a subplot or two. Addressing this problem may fix another problem: creating empathy for the other characters. Obviously, this book is told from Paternot's perspective, but it would be more enjoyable -- and educational -- if the narrator had an omniscient perspective. In other words, other characters should be presented with their motivations. For example, Paternot describes his sales staff as being greedy bastards, rather than understanding (and presenting) their positions. Second, the book starts with the day theglobe.com goes public. Unfortunately, this creates a flawed structure that requires a cheap device to sustain tension, i.e., at the end of every chapter, Stephen reminds us that he's going to lose everything. But, that knowledge is gained from the future, not from the conflict that kicks off this story. Instead, the story should begin when Stephen meets some guy on a plane (can't remember his name, but he's involved with Hollywood). Then, the conflict is Stephen has lost all his money and what is he going to do about it. That creates an obvious question, how did he get the money? Then THAT kicks off theglobe.com story, the rise and then the eventual fall. And he doesn't have to artificially remind us that he's going to lose the money since the conflict already does that. Finally, and most annoyingly, the writing is trite. Either Paternot or Essex would have done well to read "On Writing Well" before working on this book. Unfortunately, it's hard to pin down exactly why the writing is so annoying and so I'm hard pressed to come with examples. Perhaps what makes the writing trite is Paternot's writing voice, which actually comes through with surprising clarity. Perhaps the structure is just so bad that it amplifies the worst of his voice rather than illuminating the best of it. It's an enjoyable, but slightly frustrating, read. (...)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Very Honest Offering,
This review is from: A Very Public Offering: A Rebel's Story of Business Excess, Success, and Reckoning (Paperback)
A Very Public Offering is a unique guidebook on the peaks and pitfalls of the roller-coaster that is entrepreneurship. No-one tells this kind of story - an honest and sincere tale of a young CEO's very personal experience. It takes into account everything that happens in Paternot's life while pushing forward as a pioneer in an impossible time when little was understood about the internet and online communities. This book should be read by young entrepreneurs in the online space and is proving very helpful to me, a fellow founder of a community website.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|