Customer Reviews

Victorian Lace Today

5 star:		(54)
4 star:		(15)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

...then you'll love this book. Victorian Lace Today has a similar coffee table book type presentation to Meg Swansen's classic A Gathering of Lace. The designs range from what I would consider beginner level to advanced intermediate with the majority falling in the intermediate range. The publisher rates most of the designs as Intermediate with a few falling into the Experienced category and some rated as Easy. In terms of complexity, I see nothing in here like A Gathering of Lace's Mediterranean Lace or Frost Flowers.

It appears that all the designs are charted, which is my preferred method but those who like written out directions may not be happy. There are several designs knit up in Kidsilk Haze and similar yarns, many done in laceweights like Zephyr and some done in sport/dk weight yarns like Fiesta's La Luz. One of the nice features is a yarn comparison chart in the back of the book, offering advise about substitutions and emphasizing that substituting yarns is nothing to fear. I noticed several of the patterns mention the possibility of using a heavier yarn and doing fewer repeats.

The general tone of the book seems to offer reassurance that lace isn't all that hard without trying to dumb down the whole process. There's a nice section in the back that encourages you to design your own shawl and offers lessons in designing both centers and edgings.

The presentation of the shawls and scarves is both lovely and informative. Images are clear and sharp and the lace is generally spread out in a way that allows you to actually see the design. There is a bit of history offered but not an overwhelming amount. I'd say it's just enough to give you an appreciation of the genesis of the designs and the time and place in which they were orginally created.

I was going to count the number of designs but got sidetracked somewhere around 30. I know there are at least a dozen designs that jumped immediately to my personal 'must knit' list. I would say a majority of the designs are for rectangular stoles but there are quite a few triangular shawls and a few circular designs. There are a couple of collar/fichu type designs which are sweet but I find it difficult to picture them getting much use and a lovely little cape that seems to fall into the same category although it might work very nicely with evening wear.

One thing I like is that there is a wide variety of color in the designs. I like a white shawl as much as the next person but I enjoy seeing gorgeous stoles done up in acid green and raspberry and pumpkin. Of course, color is the easiest thing to change but it's fun to see these lovely designs knit up in sparkling contemporary colors.

All in all, I'd highly recommend the book to anyone who loves lace and would like a large selection of beautiful wearable patterns that offer a bit of a challenge but won't take a lifetime to knit.

I've been anticipating this book for a while, and it does not disappoint. Counting all of the variations, there are over 40 designs in the book. About half of them are on US size 7 (4.5 mm) needles in yarns like Kidsilk Haze, less intimidating for those new to lace knitting. For the more experienced lace knitter, the sections in the back of the book have great information about understanding lace patterns and adjusting them to suit, as well as neatly fitting borders around corners.

Most of the patterns are rectangular stoles with all-around knitted-on borders. There are a number of scarves that make use of fancy edging patterns on the ends, with a fairly plain center section for fast knitting. There are a few triangular shawls, and a very dramatic full hexagon and circle.

The photography is gorgeous. Locations are mostly around Cambridge or in the house and formal gardens at Belton House. The scarves and shawls are mostly in bright colors -- think hot pink, chartreuse, coral, scarlet. In addition to the artsy "shawl on a bridge railing" sorts of shots, there are plenty of good close-ups for most of the items, allowing you to see detail.

So what keeps it from a full 5 stars? First, if you're looking for really intricate lace patterns, this is probably not the book for you. Most of the designs are fairly geometric with short (though easily-memorized!) repeats. The thing that irritated me the most is that there's no comprehensive listing of all of the projects. The main table of contents lists the chapters (largely divided by source of patterns) and each chapter has its own table of contents listing the designs. But there's no way to quickly find something if you can't remember where it was from. I also find the use of the yarn weight classification system a little misleading. That's somewhat made up for by the photograph of all the actual yarns used, though.

Those quibbles aside, I'm delighted to have this book and have already started my first project -- after owning it for less than a week. I can foresee making many more.

Unquestionably this is a beautiful book visually. However, it is rife with mistakes! Be sure to look online for corrections and clarifications. I think there are more errors than have been found thus far.

This is a beautifully compiled book. It is not only a pattern book but also would make a nice coffee table book. Each section is preceded by a history and background of the area they are trying to describe. I really love this book, the only reason I did not have it more then 3 stars is that there are some mistakes in the charts for the patterns so you when you read them be careful to make sure they make sense to you. Also some of the yarns they used are difficult to find or EXTREMELY expensive so you may want to substitute. I jumped right in with several patterns and they work out very nicely. What ever you create from this book will truely be a work of art.

I had put off purchasing Jane Sowerby's book, because the title suggested little old ladies and their heavy woolen shawls. I couldn't have been more mistaken. The volume is part knitting instruction--for some of the most incredible lace shawls I've ever seen--part coffee table book, and part history book. (I thoroughly enjoyed the information on the Victorian authors who produced some of the first popular knitting books. the author's comments on the geneology of lace patterns was especially interesting.)

The presentation of the early abbreviated terms left me grateful for our more simplified approach. I am, however, used to an abbreviated verbal format and find chart methods a little confusing. I'm prone to getting off the track. Sometimes I rewrite them into a verbal format myself. I have to admit rather easily. Despite this, I acknowledge that the chart method is much more representative of the finished work. Not to mention that its economy of space, at least in this instance, left far more room for the incredible photography.

The book is chatty and includes information on some of the venues in which the splendid photography was done (mostly in and around Cambridge, ala the BBC Morse Mysteries) and leaves one with the urge to visit "Merry Olde England!"

The designs are some of the most beautiful I've ever seen. The black shawl with the leaf design is especially incredible, but it would take the patience of a saint to complete--which does not in any way describe me. The beginner will be able to start with the more simple patterns at the beginning of the book which also should be more easily completed. The more advanced patterns will most certainly coax the beginner to move forward with their technique, and will give the experienced individual a challenge.

Even just as a "wish book," Victorian Lace Today is a must have!

Shame that the instuctions in the book are not as beautiful as the photographs. More and more books from The Knitters Magazine Group are so poorly proof read that it is hard to justify the expense anymore. Gone are the days it seems that companies take pride in what they are producing and yet they expect us to pay large amounts of money for books of poor quality. As a very experienced knitter I have become saddened by the downturn in accuracy so have turned more and more to my older books and patterns where accuracy was a measure of pride.

I am a book loving life long knitter and have more than my share of books that I have purchased just because they had pretty pictures, or because they offered some insight into the history of fiber or garments, and some that are just technical. This book fits all three catagories very well. I am sure that I will be knitting up several of the patterns.

The end of the book is the real treasure here. There is a section that explains changing weights of the yarn and how to design your own shawl and/or border. This book will definitely get lots of use at my house.

This book uncovers and reveals great knitting patterns from the 19th century, and those of us who love knitting lace are understandably eager to own it. I recommend it highly for the border patterns and the inspiring way they've been used to create items we'd use today. Definitely NOT your great-great-grandmother's lace. HOWEVER, the photos are fashion shots, and frustrating to those of us who are knitters and want to know what the knitting really looks like. Several of the scarves use an unimaginative drop stitch for the body of the scarf (I am certain there were other choices to offer!) and the first item -- a mesh shawl with beaded fringe -- is certainly not lace. Given how few lace knitting books are on the market, however, and how eagerly they are snatched up by those of us who want them, I have to say that this colorful, modern book is worth the money for the new take on lace. It was a pleasure to page through and see projects that didn't look as if they belonged in a museum or historical recreation. I've marked seveal for holiday projects and purchased my yarn. If I change out a stitch pattern -- well, those borders really are yummy!

I have to begin with the disclaimer that I have not yet actually tried to knit anything from this book. I've been too busy drooling over the beautiful photography, studying the well-written instructions, reading the background info about our Victorian predecessors who inspired the patterns, and perusing the comprehensive "how to" section at the end. This book is thoroughly researched, clearly written, and just all around gorgeous.

If you are looking for some easy lace knitting, you'd better go elsewhere. Although several of the patterns in this book are labeled "EASY LACE," in my opinion there's only one that is suitable for a true beginner. If, on the other hand, you're the least bit adventurous, then this book cannot help but inspire you. I generally prefer relaxed projects that I can work on in front of the TV, but I am now itching to try some of the gorgeous shawls in here. If I can make something half as beautiful as the creations in this book, I will call myself an accomplished knitter.

I saw Jane give a 2 hour talk at Stitches West (Feb 2007) and had to buy her book. Each knitted shawl or collar is absolutely beautitul. I never thought I would be interested in knitting lace, but Jane inspired me to give it a try. Easy to follow instructions for the intermediate knitter, but might be a bit challenging for the beginner. The history of lace is a fascinating read. Highly recommend this book