Amazon.com Review
From Publishers Weekly
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Reason for enjoyment depends on reader's background,
By
This review is from: The View from a Monastery (Mass Market Paperback)
Contrary to the Amazon editor review, Br. Benet was raised Catholic in a mixed Lutheran-Catholic marriage. As for Jon Hassler's comparison to The Seven Story Mountain, I find the relationship weak at best - as if he and I read different books for one or the other. I point these items out because false expectations can easily make one fail to enjoy the book for what it is.It is not a conversion story. It is not even a particularly spiritual story. It is gentle musings by an older brother of the Blue Cloud monastery on his experiences in the monastery - musing of the same nature as casual conversation as two people get to know each other. For its gentle musings, the book is one of several good books on monastic life. Personally, I prefer A Monastic Year : Reflections from a Monastery. It is also an astute study of how monastic communities adapt the Rule of St. Benedict to contemporary life and to individual situtations within the monastic culture. Here the book is the best I know - anyone reading the Rule must also read this book. Finally, the book provides the context within which Roberta Bondi and Kathleen Norris (both Protestant) write. For those unfamilar with the monastic culture, this is an excellent way to gain a realistic (not idealistic) view of the life style they have come to value. For this, too, I highly recommend the book. As for the book itself, it is filled with delightful characters - saintly and not-so-saintly. There is the German monk for whom nothing American will ever measure up. There is the monk who appoints himself library censor, the infirmary nurse into folk remedies, the missionary to the Dakotas forced to take a "sabbatical", the mischevious dog, the "falling" priest, the gentle scholar, the novitiate who left and when dying of AIDS has the community come to his support. All of them described in brief chapters that are a pleasure to read - clear, unobtrustive prose that values the message above the word. If nothing else, after reading this delightful book, everyone should be able to say "I, too, can be religious ... <name> is as flawed as I".
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delightful representation of daily life at St. Cloud Abbey,
By Kathy Wiley (Mt. Pleasant, Iowa USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The View from a Monastery (Mass Market Paperback)
Every year I visit a monastery for a few days to retreat into a quiet environment and reconnect with the spiritual. This year I found myself at Blue Cloud Abbey near Marvin, South Dakota. There was a joyful spirit there which helped my find my smile and begin again to radiate the glow of Christ's love. These Benedictine monks present themselves wholly transparent to their visitors. They reveal their true personalities without reserve. They are, therefore, delightful and personable. It's refreshing, especially for a woman, to leave the daily duties of a household and career and be taken care of by a holy community who happen to be men. It sort of restores a woman's faith in the abilities of the opposite sex. I was given the gift of getting to know a few of these men before I met Br. Benet and found out through a fellow retreatant that he had written a book. I spent the next day reading it and was inspired with his ability to transcend joyful laughter as well as reverence through his skillfully written stories. I loved his honesty: "There are many false notions about monasticism. Pious people think that monks are holy. People who don't know much about religion think we are peculiar. The truth of the matter is that we are neither, though I have known individual monks who were both. Most of us are ordinary men who find that it is easier for us to be holy here than in some other place." I also loved the pictures he painted with words of his most memorable friends: "Brother Patrick was holy. His holiness was not the kind that is commonly associated with sanctity, but he was my kind of saint. He was not a plaster saint. He had a solid piety without being the least bit sanctimonious." Br. Benent then proceeded to describe this unusual monk who had fought in the Battle of the Bulge, and worked on the General Motors assembly line before joining the Benedictines. Br. Patrick's tendency to spin tall tales,especially regarding his war days and his pranks at the expense of the other monks made this monk a colorful person indeed. Even at his bedside, as he lay dying from inoperable cancer, his colorful spirit presented itself: ". . eager as ever to entertain all of the "brethren" (as he called us) who gathered at his bedside. Sitting on the edge of his bed and chain-smoking cigarettes ("Why not? I don't have lung cancer"), he regaled us with war stories and recollections of his youth in an upstate New York town where he could buy a bucket of beer for a nickel." Being Protestant, I found this book helpful in explaining Catholic practices, the difference between Trappists and Benedictines and the meaning of St. Benedict's Rule. But the most wonderful thing about this book is how Br. Benet has revealed the everyday life struggles and celebrations that are unique to monastic life but are not so very different from experiences that we all have in other communities. The mystery exists, however, that there is something special here. Not everything can be put into words; some things have to be experienced to be understood.
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Down to Earth.. enjoyable!,
By A Customer
This review is from: The View from a Monastery (Hardcover)
I was pleasantly surprised with this book. Especially with the amount of other dull, short books on the subject. "The View From A Monastery" is very down to earth, and let's you hear, in great detail, about the various characters and goings on, of a monastery today. Whether you're curious about monks in general, or earnestly seeking a religious vocation, this book is a must read!
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|