29 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"I shall have here but one mistress and no master.", August 4, 2009
This review is from: The Virgin's Daughters: In the Court of Elizabeth I (Mass Market Paperback)
Though much has been written about Elizabeth I, Westin finds yet another aspect of this extraordinary woman's lifetime: the agony of impossible passions in the Virgin Queen's court, Elizabeth's great love for Robert Dudley; Lady Katherine Grey's unrequited passion for Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford in 1562, and Mistress Mary Roger's affection for Elizabeth's godson, Sir John Harington, in 1599. In 1562, Elizabeth is not yet thirty, Kate Grey but twenty-three, both susceptible to the temptations of romance. While foreign court Elizabeth, she becomes more adept at avoiding marriage contracts, vowing "my people will be husband and children to me and it will be enough". As much to keep the throne to herself as to save Dudley from scandal, Elizabeth endures the particular pain of one who dare not give in to her heart's desire, Dudley never to rule at his beloved's side. Likewise, the queen insists that her ladies-in-waiting remain virginal as well, refusing to allow their marriages.
While Kate has put her youthful love for Edward Seymour aside, his return to court awakens a deep yearning in a solitary, lonely existence. Named heir to the throne, Kate does all in her power to alleviate Elizabeth's suspicions. Kate's sister, Lady Jane Grey, lost her head thanks to her parents' ambitions after the death of Henry VIII, Kate terrified of meeting the same fate. Now, like Elizabeth, Kate is tortured by her love for Seymour, who begs to wed her. Nothing good can come from a union the queen decries, harbinger of yet another threat to her hard-won throne. Westin describes tension-filled days at court, Kate desperate to allay the queen's suspicions, yet hopelessly in thrall to Ned. Though Dudley and Seymour risk all in pursuit of the women they love, for the women there is only danger. Elizabeth dare not tolerate any exceptions, even for herself.
The most poignant aspect of this brilliantly structured novel is the contrast between the two love affairs, Elizabeth's with Dudley and Kate's with Edward, the queen proven right by history, Kate paying a terrible price for having what the queen cannot. In 1599, Elizabeth has ruled for near forty years, Dudley replaced by the handsome and ambitious Robert Devereaux, Earl of Essex, the second great romantic scandal of Elizabeth's reign. Westin's Elizabeth Tudor inspires mixed feelings as she rails against the infidelities of Kate and, later, Mary, a monarch unable to bear the love matches of others when she must endure loneliness. In 1599 Mary Rogers encounters a different queen, burdened by a lifetime of difficult choices. Mary's dilemma is equal to Kate's, the monarch unbending in principle, even as she is battered by an unfortunate affection for Essex. The Virgin Queen stands alone once more.
Westin perfectly captures the relationship between queen and ladies, Kate and Mary facing years of repressed feelings and a constant fear of exposure. Ravaged by time and played false by the last of her unrequited loves, Westin's portrayal of Elizabeth is powerful, the long life and terrible choices of a queen who demands the impossible from those who love her. It is Kate's and Mary's devotion that provides the fodder for this tale of a court where love must always defer to loyalty, honor a bitter consolation in the dark. Luan Gaines/2009.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
In the minority here...., September 27, 2009
This review is from: The Virgin's Daughters: In the Court of Elizabeth I (Mass Market Paperback)
I have to admit going into this one being confused about what the story was actually about, so many reviews go into such great plot detail that I found my head spinning - I'm keeping it short and sweet. This is actually two stories of two different women who served Elizabeth Tudor at two different periods in her life. The first, Katherine Grey falls in love with Edward Seymor and wishes to marry him but Elizabeth refuses to give permission for the two to wed - and their defiance leads to drastic circumstances. The second *daughter* is Mary Rogers (distantly related to Katherine) who joins Elizabeth's household in her later years and finds herself in love with the rakish Sir John Harrington, but Elizabeth has other plans.....
And that's pretty much it. While I enjoyed a look at a couple of lesser known ladies instead of the focus being on the monarch, I have to say that this book fell a tad bit flat for this reader. I didn't find much chemistry between either pair of lovers, Elizabeth was pretty un-intimidating in the first half of the book (thankfully that improved in the latter half), but worst of all was the portrayal of Robert Dudley. Instead of being the "Machiavellian master courtier" as he's been described he reminded me more of those irritating *barflys* I used to come across in my younger days - just a man who would flirt with anything in skirts. I never felt real connection with any of the characters, nor did I feel I was immersed into the period itself - I was always on the outside looking in. A good book, just not a great one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It's complicated, August 11, 2009
This review is from: The Virgin's Daughters: In the Court of Elizabeth I (Mass Market Paperback)
If this novel had a Facebook page, the line for relationship status would most definitely read, "It's complicated." The book focuses on the women of Queen Elizabeth I's court who fall in love with forbidden men and arouse the queen's jealousy and ire. Lady Katherine Grey, the queen's most dedicated servant, falls in love with a handsome earl, while Mary Rogers falls in love with the queen's godson. Both women know that to pursue these relationships will mean alienating the "Virgin" queen, who must remain unwed if she wishes to retain her power. what they choose to do, and the resulting messes that unfold, make this a gripping read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No