Customer Reviews

Vision & Voice: Refining Your Vision in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (Voices That Matter)

5 star:		(20)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Most of the books about using Adobe Lightroom and Photoshop explain to a greater or lesser degree what the sliders, buttons and menus do to change the look of an image, but most don't try to tell you how to put together these effects to create an artistic picture. This is David duChemin's goal in "Vision & Voice: Refining Your Vision in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom".

The book starts out with a few chapters devoted to explaining what the author means by vision and voice. He says that every photograph really contains three images: the one the author had in mind when he took the picture, the one captured by the camera and the one created in post processing. He then goes on to discuss a vision-driven workflow, emphasizing intention, aesthetics, and process. He lays out a few principles next, like making blacks black, utilizing the histogram and even shooting in raw. He then discusses each of the tools in the develop module of Lightroom, but rather then give you a technical explanation, he offers his ideas about how those tools can contribute to the photographer achieving his or her vision. He finishes the book with twenty of his own images (much like Ansel Adams, in "Examples: The Making of 40 Photographs") in which he provides step by step descriptions of how he used Lightroom to transform those images into what he envisioned. There are copies of the images on-line that one can download to follow duChemin as he works the digital captures.

If you are one of those photographers who is interested in images that look as much like what was before your lens as possible, this probably isn't the book for you, although from my point of view, this book is probably just what you need. But if you are interested in creating (dare I say it) art, you must read this book.

As I read this book, I felt like I was watching a high-wire artist. So many authors say they will tell you how to be creative, and then end up explaining exposure and focus, but losing sight of the creativity. I kept waiting for duChemin to fall into the same trap, but he kept his footing all the way. Even when he told you that he had set, say, clarity to +90, I understood the artistic purpose of the move.

If you are familiar with Lightroom, you can just read the author's description of how he processed each picture. However, even skilled photographers will benefit from following along with the downloaded images.

This book will also prove useful to Photoshop users since the Adobe Camera Raw engine is the same as the Lightroom engine, although the latter has a more intuitive interface.

A great critic, Mark Schorer, spoke of technique as discovery, indicating that it was through the application of technique that the artist revealed his or her vision. David duChemin demonstrates the principle in this book.

First, a warning. This is NOT a book that goes into every menu and submenu in Lightroom and explains what the sliders do. If you want that kind of book, try the latest from Scott Kelby or Deke McLelland or a variety of others.

Next, a threat. If you bought this book thinking it was an item by item how to, and then trash it online, I'm going to break a chain letter rather than send it on to you and you'll have 7 years bad luck. Seriously, though. If this isn't what you thought it was when you bought it, return it or sell it. That wouldn't be the book's fault.

Finally, the gold star review...

DuChemin has several titles that talk about vision and voice. Many of them are very inexpensive eBooks available on his website,[...]. It's taken me about a year to understand what he's saying. I've got the voice part down, thanks to this book. When you see a picture from Ansel Adams or Anne Liebowitz, you don't need to see the signature to know who took it. In other creative genres, when you read about a hard-boiled detective, you know it is Hammet or not. Same with Monet or Picasso. They all have a voice.

Vision is a little harder to explain. When you take a picture, there was something that made you choose what to include or leave out, something that drew you to put camera to eye, something you wanted to capture. When you begin post processing, that initial view is rarely what you had in your mind. Vision is taking the image and making it tell the story you intended to tell, the way you wanted to tell it.

The first third of this book tries to explain both of these complimentary concepts in much more detail and in a much clearer manner than I've done here. (And with apologies to the author if I've messed it up; these aren't easy to define in a few words.)

After that, David takes you through his process, starting with a zeroed image (the RAW file from the camera) and explains what he did and why he did it from before he clicked the shutter to the moment he was ready to print. You do get to see sliders and adjustment brushes, but you see them in action; in context.

As David goes on to explain the process of realizing his vision (and by extension, as we readers use the concepts and techniques to realize ours) he talks about how people process images. He has a ten point bulleted list of what the eye goes to first. Things like Sharp before soft, warm colors before cool, etc. Then he writes a sentence that sums it all up, "This is the WHY of this book: understanding how to gently lead the eye through the image, to say to your viewer, 'Look here,' and to do them the courtesy of creating images that don't tire them out from the effort to discern important elements from unimportant ones."

If you are at a stage where you can benefit from guidance on how to make better pictures, as opposed to how to simply better exercise the features of your camera and software then this book is for you.

For me, it came at just exactly the right spot on my learning curve. More than that, when I read it again next year it will provide a second boost since I'll be able to absorb ideas that are still beyond my ability.

This book has my highest recommendation.

In my experience, books in the creative professions either have a bias toward the technical or the philosophical. It's clear which side of that continuum is more popular these days. It seems that the demand for "how to" is at an all time high... which is understandable given how much there is to learn how to use. That said, the "why" questions really ought to come first but at the pace the photo world is running, it doesn't seem that there's room for inconveniences like finding a personal vision and expressing a unique voice.

Then, along comes duChemin with this gift: a philosophically driven, technically sound book on putting Adobe's Photoshop Lightroom in its appropriate place... behind the artists vision... as instrumental for expressing one's voice. The technique isn't the end with this work... it's the means.

At first, I was nervous at the scope of ambition this book took on. But, in the end, the author does not disappoint. Making the case for placing vision central but then giving technical insight on what, when and how demystifies Lightroom as a tool while giving context to why its function can so ably serve its master... namely, the creative wielding that tool.

This is both an inviting book for the new photographer and reframe for those of us who've been at it for a while. I was genuinely inspired as I read and was moved to see my world a little differently because of it. More than inspiration though, it went one critical step further and offered me what I needed to more ably make good on my new dreams thanks to Adobe's powerful tool (the unsung hero in this review).

I believe this is the third book penned for photographers by deChemin. I hope he's just getting started though. When it comes to vision and voice, he's certainly found his. That said, I believe his legacy will be in how he empowers an industry to go further still.

This is a brilliant work and I highly recommend it.

Most books teach the science/craft of post-processing, with a little bit of the "art" that makes each person's style unique. This book flips the equation upside down by attempting to focus on the "art" side of post-processing. Writing about the less tangible, more mysterious and personal aspects of the craft of pushing pixels around in RAW files is a difficult task.

The book begins with 90 pages about finding your voice that I didn't connect with, followed by an introduction to most of the adjustment panels, and then 20 examples of processing RAW files. Kudos to the author/publisher for providing DNG files for the images for download. The best way to learn post-processing is hands-on.

Processing the 20 DNG files in the second half of the book will work pretty well as a Lightroom primer for beginners. If you've already gone beyond the Basic panel in Lightroom and are already using tone curves and local adjustments, there may not be much here for you.

As an experienced Lightroom user and instructor, I had two major issues with the techniques presented in this book:

1. On multiple image examples the Exposure is pushed beyond clipping and Recovery is used to pull back the blown highlights. Setting the white point with Exposure and then using Brightness to control the Lights would yield better highlight protection and image contrast. Only use Recovery when necessary.
2. Clarity is over used in many cases due to completely glossing over capture sharpening. Balancing lower Clarity settings with more attention to capture sharpening can give you more control and subtlety.

I don't want to downplay the importance of experimentation and play that are core to duChemin's thesis -- these are hugely important ideas that are key to keeping your work creative and fresh. However, it's important to note that most beginning and intermediate photographers who want to learn Lightroom would be better off reading Martin Evening's book first to develop strong fundamentals as a springboard to heading off into these more difficult territories of vision and voice.

Everyone reacts differently to teaching styles and methodologies. Just because I didn't connect with the author's style doesn't mean you won't love this book. I recommend checking out duChemin's blog and affordable Ebooks to see if his way of explaining the art side of post-processing is for you.

In modern digital photography there are several paths to great images. Some are crafted by photo technicians, previous film photographers who turn their noses up at digital post-processing and insisting that everything must be right "in camera." Then there are the software geeks, geniuses whose skills with software mastery over their computer hardware allow them to unlock the hidden potential in good images, frequently making them extraordinary.

Almost all digital photography books are geared toward one of these two audiences. David du Chemin, however, has written a book for the rest of us.

This is a Lightroom guide that dares to begin not with endless screenshots of menus, but with several chapters on Vision and Voice. In other words this book is as much about why one is bothering to take an image in the first place, as it is the step one takes to create final processed image in Lightroom 3.

It is about intention. It is about having an emotional roadmap. Because what difference does it make that you can use an adjustment brush to selectively adjust the Clarity on a portion of your image, if you don't understand the effect that will have on the mood of the overall image? And what good is it knowing that you can make a Clarity adjustment to affect the mood of the image, if you don't know what mood you wanted to create in the first place?

But with that said, this is not a stodgy, anti-software book. Far from it. In fact, du Chemin is unapologetic about in his advocating that digital post processing is an essential part of modern photography, with unique tools (compared to film photography) that are worth exploiting to their full capacity. Because it's not about what you do to an image, it's why.

And this book will show you how, as long as you are first thinking about the why.

To that end, you will not learn about every, or even most features, in Lightroom. This is not the only Lightroom book you'll ever need, if you are new to using the program. But, especially if you've been tinkering for a while--or have another Lightroom manual that has made you dizzy with its in depth coverage of every Lightroom feature--this book will effect the way you process your images, and make you more deliberate in your choices. And, yes, you will learn plenty of step-by-step techniques for adjusting and refining RAW images into the finished ones featured throughout the book.

I usually don't write reviews, but this time I simply *had* to.

This book comes at the very right time, if not for the whole photography world, at least for me. I'm a physicist, so the geek in me is pretty present, but I do strive to let my right brain express itself more. So all David DuChemin's mantra about vision (event though it might sound a bit too religious at times) is really what I need. A perfect balance between geekery and art, between how and why. Brilliant.

Other reviews explain in depth what this book is and what it's not, so I won't go there. I'll say that instead : get it, read it, absorb it, and then get go develop (or re-develop, for that matters) your beautiful images in Lightroom ! That's what the book did to me. Urged me to go to the digital darkroom with a fresh eye and a fresh mind. And that's invaluable.

Highly recommended.

Found the book staring at me amongst the myriad "in depth photoshop" and "lightroom uncovered" books at my local bookstore. The cover art in itself told me this book was different.
I'd bought a few of David Duchemin's e-books, and found him an easy to follow writer, who draws you into his own world and process with ease. This book doesn't disapoint. Well written, extremely clear in its objectives and methods, it leaves you wanting to revisit your own collection of works, and rethink them completely. I've probably learnt more "tips and tricks" from this than from any other book, if only because I now understand *why* to apply them.
This book may not be for people who are obsessed with technical specs and the latest gear, but if like me, you are always walking on the tightrope between your inner geek and your inner artist, it will open up a world of possibilities.

David is a great author who really has made me push the limits of my vision to become a better photographer. His first two books have made me recommend to others all the time and surely this one will be next. Its a trifecta! The thing that is nice about this book is that it takes a different angle of attack compared to any Scott Kelby book. This one makes you think, inspire to become better and more creative. A must read if you want the best photography book I have from 2010

Straight to the point, David DuChemin has created another fine work with Voice & Vision. It's the perfect ending (rounding out?) to Within the Frame and Visionmongers series. Don't expect to glean a great deal of understanding of Lightroom 3 from a technical standpoint, although you'll get a strong overview of the Develop module. It's more like the other books in that it is a look at the heart of the creation process...the passion of it, not the step by step. A true delight to read, and I'm sure, read again.

As usual, David DuChemin's book is easy to understand as well as entertaining. The precise examples of how he processes an image are worth the purchase. AND, he provides the files so you can practice and see first hand what he is doing. Terrific