17 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
sure NOT to please, July 14, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Visits from the Drowned Girl: A Novel (Hardcover)
Benny Poteat, tower-climber, part-time fry cook and full-time redneck witnesses (from his perch on a tower) a young woman set up a video camera and tripod, strip off her clothes, walk into a river and drown herself.
Benny packs up all her belongings, which include a series of videotapes she made as a film student, and hides them in his duplex. He doesn't report the incident and instead watches the tapes one by one over a series of weeks.
Why does the girl drown herself? Why doesn't Benny report what he's seen and hand over the girl's stuff? Your guess is as good as Steven Sherrill's.
Although alive with colorful characters, the novel is deeply unsatisfying and frustrating--purposely frustrating--to the reader because it sets up intriguing questions which the author has no intention of answering.
It's also really, really gross. Besides countless scenes of Benny masturbating, the reader is also treated to: two acts of semi-public male on male fellatio, gang rape, gang dog-on-dog rape, and attempted goat-on-midget rape. And that is just a partial list. Also difficult to read, though lower on the gross-out scale, is Benny's senseless, passive, motiveless cruelty.
But yet more offensive--and more BORING-- is that the novel, like the pretentious film-school videos made by the drowned girl, is fumbling toward some "statement" about Art: Benny is Us. We are all voyeurs. All art is a porno because we sit passively and watch the participants. Or some such tedious falderal.
Sherrill accurately (and, I think, intentionally) depicts the reaction his readers are likely to have to "Drowned Girl" through Benny's reaction to the drowned girl's movies:
"Benny paused the tape. Sat back in the rocker. Sighed. He didn't think he could stand another night of pretentious nonsense. Benny needed some sense of progress, of forward motion."
Benny keeps watching, but many people probably won't keep reading.
It's both sad and annoying to see such an evidently talented writer waste his time (and ours) on a book which is designed NOT to please on any level whatsoever. The small minority of people who like their art offensive, annoying, and unpleasant may not regret the time they spend reading this, but most everyone else will.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Ditto...Sad Waste, October 9, 2010
Ditto to the reviewers who panned this book. I find it annoying when a writer of such obvious ability wastes everyone's time condescending to cartoon characters, faux crackers with names like Jeeter, Dink and Doodle, whose incomes are derived from tropical fish maintenance, hash-slinging, and off-hours fellatio. A mash-up of motiveless incidents, gratuitous, distasteful, unkind and grotesque, weakly strung together by the theme of sequential viewing of videotapes left by a young woman whose drowning suicide the hero, Benny Poteat, witnesses. Little information is gleaned in sum and none illuminating. The author could not pay me to raise the least interest in these characters or the story -- he shows equal weary indifference for these former and his audience. Please.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great read -- not sure why so many reviews are so negative, August 31, 2010
I picked this up at the library, having never heard of Minotaur. I loved it -- and I read voluminously across a wide variety of fiction and nonfiction. The characters are certainly believable and the side-excursions into various not-quite-relevant-to-the-plot topics are the best part. I *know* people like Benny and Dink. He has captured the true flavor of parts of the deep south. I laughed outloud, I winced, I marveled at the outrageousness of some of the story lines (Max was especially despicable). I swear I could taste the hushpuppies. At heart, it's a darn good yarn. Don't listen to the critics! Just go read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No