Customer Reviews

Voices From Hitler's Army 2 Disc Set - Blitzkrieg, Luftwaffe, Waffen SS, U Boats, Russia - The Unholy War, Defending Berlin

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

1. This is not a bargain-priced set of two DVD's, by any means. Nevertheless, video and audio quality are first rate, as is content. Altogether, running time is about 300 minutes, or five hours of viewing. Hailed as a last chance to hear from defeated soldiers who fought for Germany in World War II, it is a must-see for anyone interested in the period.
2. There is an expected bias, since interviews are only done with Germans who fought in World War II. Most of them talk disgustedly about what happened under the Nazis and their feelings seem genuine. One can't help but sympathize with Germans who fought so bravely, but the point must be made: they were the aggressors. Several even admit they deserved their fate. None seemed bitter about having lost the war. Maybe they now realize they were better off losing?
3. Although this set is announced as new it carries production dates of 2000 and 2001. Therefore, one must assume it was produced first for a European audience and lately distributed in the U. S. Production firms listed on the outside box include Kultur, Cromwell, and Eagle Media. Eagle has also been involved in other World War II videos, including Hitler's War, Waffen SS-Hitler's Elite Fighting Force, Gestapo-Hitler's Secret Police, and Hitler's Secret Weapons.
4. With few exceptions, documentary footage was surpisingly new to me. Most is black-and-white and must have been recently discovered in archives and private collections. High quality suggests that films have been re-mastered for this production. Video imaging also employs modern technology, with still photographs and graphics mixed in with films from the 1940's. It's quite effectively done. There's little of the grainy character to the video which can be a disappointment with other WW-II sets. Sound quality, as noted above, is topnotch throughout.
5. Although some horror scenes appear, mainly from the Eastern Front, they do not overwhelm the viewer. Similarly, not much is shown from death camps which probably fits with the overall theme of the DVD's. All persons interviewed denied knowledge of the camps and say their friends and relatives were in the dark, too. This might indeed be true since the interview subjects come from middle and lower ranks of the German military.
6. How any of the German survivors lasted 60 years to tell their story is amazing. A number became Russian prisoners and had to serve 20 years hard labor in Siberia before release. Physically and psychologically these are very tough individuals.
7. Of the six titles, two that impressed me most were "The Luftwaffe--Messengers of Death" and "U-Boats--Iron Coffins." Both offer examples of human endurance and heroism on either side of the conflict. Both videos also recount horrendous losses to the Germans who served at the time--70,000 air crew and 30,000 submariners. Leaders of the Luftwaffe and the U-boats, Hermann Goering and Karl Donitz, respectively, are featured. Donitz was almost too good for the Allies to beat; Goering, with his many blunders and vainglorious personality, may have been indispensable to Allied victory.
8. In addition to the toll taken by the Russian and Anglo-American armies, Hitler's forces had to cope with increasing supply problems as the war progressed. Especially scarce were food, fuel, and ammunition. Allied air raids reduced the German capacity to produce supplies, including synthetic fuel for its war machine; thus airplanes, tanks, and other vehicles became almost useless toward the end. Where Hitler had earlier tried to starve the British with his U-boat blockade, the Allies and Russians later achieved a similar result with airborne bombing.
9. The Waffen SS is depicted as not quite the elite, fanatical force shown elsewhere. As the final months of the war approached regular army soldiers were drafted into the SS making them subject to special revenge from the Allies. Such SS draftees may not have deserved their fate.
10. Still unanswered are questions of how the Germans could have followed someone like Hitler; also, how Hitler thought he could defeat the British, the Americans, and the Russians all at the same time. Couldn't he count? Did he have a death wish? We'll probably never know the answers but pursuit of them is endlessly fascinating and important. This is not only for what happened 60 years ago, but for today, as well. The rise of Islamo-fascism in the Middle East carries parallels we overlook to our peril.

An enjoyable set of DVD's. Too often the German side of WWII is overlooked in the sense that the Wehrmacht's veterans don't get to fully tell their side of the story.

This is worth spending time on to get a different view than is usually one we read about or see.

This is a great series that looks at all areas of the German military and gets prespectives from surviving members of the prospective services. These veterns are thining out daily, so this is great stuff for the period enthusiast.

The first documentary to really hear a wehrmahcht soldier's opinion and life during the war years was the BBC's World of War series back in 1974. One would have assumed that many more would follow. Sadly, that has not been the case.
In many ways this series picks up where the other left off. That in and of itself makes this video quite unique and very interesting. This documentary has covered all branches of service, including the feared Waffen SS. All the soldiers interviewed are candid and open in their remarks on the front line, including the atrocities. Most however, discuss their fighting against the allied soldiers, not their brutal behavior in the occupied Eastern territories.
With the passage of time more and more of these soldiers are passing away. Most likely there will be no remembrance ceremony in Germany once the last of "Hitler's Army" soldiers dies. Tragic, since most fought for their homeland, not Nazi ideology.

I bought this for myself and for my roommate, we are big into WW2 documentaries. I thought the price of this was a little steep, but considering the reviews I though it might be worth it. We made it almost the entire way through, but on disc 2 it stopped playing. We tried it in different DVD players, but no luck. We weren't that bummed because it wasn't very informative, and both of us didn't learn anything knew. It would have been worth it if it was 20-30$ but $50... totally not worth it.

Pretty good documentary style of allowing the actual German soldiers to basically narrate this film.

As the years go by we lose more and more veterans from all sides of the battle, and giving the 'men in the trenches' a chance to explain what they felt and saw is important.

There is plenty of real footage from the war although you may have trouble watching all of it because most of the soldiers were speaking in German and you will find youself reading the subtitles whilst having to ignore the footage to some degree.

The Uboat segment turned out to be the most interesting to me. I learned alot about this aspect of the war here.

The price of this film is WAY too high however so I am not so sure I can completely recommend you buy this unless you just have to have EVERYTHING that is World War II.

This is a pretty good film. It's got alot of luftwaffe guys talking about what they did. Well, I think it does. Unless I'm mixing it up with another movie in my collection. Buy it, not too bad for the price.

Delivered as promised.