Customer Reviews

Voices from the Trail of Tears (Real Voices, Real History Series)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is Ms. Rozema's third book on Cherokee History and an excellent complement to her others. Voices from the Trail of Tears is a collection of first person accounts of the infamous Cherokee Removal of 1838. Drawn from letters, journals, military reports, contemporary newspaper accounts, and even physicians' reports, it offers an in-depth and very personal account of the tragedy referred to by the Cherokees as `The Trail Where We Cried.' This book is different from previous books on the Cherokee Removal because it consists primarily of first person accounts of events leading up to, during, and immediately after the removal and while Ms. Rozema provides introductory notes to each account to explain the events and people who wrote the accounts, the eye-witness accounts are the focus of the book. This book deals more with the experience of the Cherokees held in camps during the summer of 1838 while they were waiting for removal led by Chief John Ross and where it is believed most of the deaths (due to sickness) actually occurred rather than on the trail than previous books. This book also deals more with the actual experiences of the Cherokees on the `Trail Where they Cried' where previous books deal more with the events leading up to the removal.
Voices from the Trail of Tears is an excellent choice for anyone interested in Cherokee history or the removal of the southeastern Indians. It would also be an excellent choice for teachers or researchers including those doing genealogy research. The book is thoughtfully indexed and carefully noted with unobtrusive endnotes and extensive bibliography at the end of the book.

You can't get a better perspective on an event than first person accounts. This book was written in such a way. There are accounts by people who were actually there taken from medical reports and recorded information taken from first person accounts of people who were actually in the middle of "The Trail of Tears" as it was happening. An excellent read and factual event of history that just happened to be overlooked in school history books.

This book made you feel like you were a bystander actually watching history happening. A good read.

This book does provide first-person descriptions of events at the time, which is historically revealing. However, it is very dry reading...probably unavoidable. Most interesting to me is how differently the removal of the Indians from the South was viewed by different people, almost like they were talking about a completely different experience.