Vows of Silence: The Abuse of Power in the Papacy of John Paul II [Hardcover]

Jason Berry (Author), Gerald Renner (Author)

Book Description

Publication Date: February 24, 2004

Going deep behind the headlines about scandals in the Catholic Church, Jason Berry and Gerald Renner's Vows of Silence follows the staggering trail of evasions and deceit that leads directly to the Vatican -- and taints the legacy of Pope John Paul II. Based on more than six years of investigative reporting and hundreds of interviews, this book is a riveting account of Vatican cover-ups and the tumult they have caused in the church worldwide. Both a profound criticism and a wake-up call to reform by two Catholic writers, Vows of Silence reveals an agenda of top-down control under John Paul II and a hierarchy so obsessed with secrecy as to spawn disinformation. Vows of Silence is not a book about sexual abuse; it is a book about abuse of power, throughout the Vatican.

The book cuts between the life story of Father Tom Doyle, who sacrificed a diplomatic career with the Vatican to seek justice for sex-abuse victims, and Father Marcial Maciel, an accused pedophile and founder of the militaristic religious order, the Legion of Christ. One of the most mysterious and powerful men in the Catholic Church, Maciel has built a network of priests, lay people, and elite prep schools in more than twenty countries, using the Legion as a fundraising machine to position himself as a favored figure of John Paul II.

In addition to accusations against Maciel of sexual abuse and of using Legion money for his own extravagant lifestyle, many ex-Legionaries claim that the order uses mind-control techniques to isolate seminarians and even priests from their families. And yet, because he enjoyed the protection of Pope John Paul II and members of the Roman Curia, charges against Maciel for sexual misconduct -- all of which he denies -- were blocked in the Vatican court system.

Drawing on in-depth interviews with Father Doyle and with ex-Legionaries who filed a canonical suit against Maciel, as well as interviews with Vatican insiders and an array of sources in Mexico, Ireland, Canada, and Australia, the authors provide a penetrating account of a hierarchy directly in conflict with its followers. With keen insight and scrupulous reporting, Vows of Silence is a powerful narrative that chronicles the church's struggle between orthodoxy and reform -- going straight to the heart of one of the world's largest power structures.

Editorial Reviews

Amazon.com Review

Authors Jason Berry (Lead Us Not into Temptation) and Gerald Renner (retired reporter for the Hartford Courant) team up for this highly accusatory report on the sex abuse scandal within the Catholic Church. The "vows of silence" speak to the Church's self-protective secrecy that made it possible to ignore the rampant abuse, despite all the early accusations and red flags. To reveal the history and scope of this problem, Berry and Renner expertly researched the parallel lives of two key players. The first one is Thomas Doyle, portrayed as an American hero priest. Doyle first heard about priests sexually abusing children in the early 1980s. Doyle immediately started to confront his superiors and blow the whistle at every turn. As early as 1983 Doyle wrote that the Church's secrecy caused any and all wrongdoings to be "denied, covered up and rationalized with equal zeal." Years later he became an advocate for! victim restitution, testifying against the Church in numerous court cases. The second character is more like the antichrist: Father Marcial Maciel, who was the influential founder of the cult-like order of Legionaries of Christ and accused of being a particularly cruel and long-term sexual predator.

This parallel lives approach makes for compelling storytelling, but it also creates a disjointed approach with much skipping around in time. What sets this apart from yet-another-expose about the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal is the in-depth reporting on the militaristic Legionaries of Christ, an extremely powerful and conservative order of priests and laymen that are affiliated with a worldwide web of prep schools and universities. Berry and Renner offer a fascinating conspiracy theory about how this international legion managed to protect its abusers and contribute to the long-term secrecy and cover-up. The bold accusations eventually land in the lap of Pope John Paul II, who seemed more invested in protecting the legion and the vow of silence than addressing the abuse. --Gail Hudson

From Publishers Weekly

This impassioned exposé explores the history of priestly pedophilia scandals, and their roots in what the authors portray as the Church's blinkered sexual morés and arrogant hierarchy, through profiles of two emblematic Church figures. The first is Thomas Doyle, an American priest who investigated abuses in the early 1980s; when his recommendations for reform were ignored, Doyle broke with the hierarchy and began testifying about the Church's cover-up. Doyle's antithesis is Marcial Maciel Degollado, founder of the Legionaries of Christ, a secretive, fanatically disciplined order of conservative priests and laymen with a chain of universities and schools that critics liken to a cult. Lionized by John Paul II, Maciel is also a pedophile and Demerol addict, according to at least nine former priests and seminarians who claim they were victimized by him. Investigative journalists Berry and Renner build on years of research and hundreds of interviews to paint a portrait of ecclesiastical corruption. They blame the Church's sexual doctrines-particularly the rule on priestly celibacy, which, they contend, has driven away heterosexual men and fostered a pathologically libertine "gay priest culture" at some American seminaries. The result is an atmosphere of silence and hypocrisy that simultaneously condemns and tolerates both homosexuality and priestly sexual abuse, in which an authoritarian Church hierarchy, reaching up to the Vatican, protects pedophiles, and buries accusations in labyrinthine legal maneuvers. The book's sprawling, somewhat disorganized narrative sometimes bogs down amidst incidental characters and insignificant details, and the panorama of sordid sex crimes, quasi-fascist brainwashing and cynical Vatican mandarins may lead critics to accuse the authors, professed Catholics themselves, of retailing lurid anti-Catholic clichés. But their exhaustive reporting adds up to a disturbing indictment of a deeply troubled Church, and this book will no doubt cause much discussion and controversy.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 368 pages
• Publisher: Free Press; First Edition edition (February 24, 2004)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0743244419
• ISBN-13: 978-0743244411
• Product Dimensions: 9.4 x 6.3 x 1.1 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.1 pounds
• Average Customer Review: 3.9 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (59 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #276,643 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Jason Berry's first novel, Last of the Red Hot Poppas, takes the reader on a ride through the corrupt and vibrant culture of southern Louisiana, which Berry has been reporting on for decades. This "spiritual comedy," as Berry calls it, borrows on the nove

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

120 of 132 people found the following review helpful

5.0 out of 5 stars A Gift to the Church February 27, 2004

By Jack Ryan

Format:Hardcover|Amazon Verified Purchase

I lived in a rectory with Father Juan Vaca, a major character in this book, 15 years ago. He poured his heart out to me about the abuse he now describes and was wounded to the heart. Those who love the church love the truth, this book tells the truth. I hope it is a beginning of a cleansing of our church and the replacement of a sick clerical culture with true gospel values. We priests must demand integrity of our leaders, it is the only way to restore the good name of the church. I would like to thank the authors, and especially Father Thomas Doyle who have helped to bring the cleansing light of day to this dark moment in the history of our church. I couln't put it down.

96 of 105 people found the following review helpful

5.0 out of 5 stars An insider's view May 10, 2004

By Thomas Patrick Doyle

Format:Hardcover

It may seem strange that one of the subjects of "Vows of Silence" writes a review, but the book is far too important to pass up this opportunity. Besides, the Legion of Christ has front-loaded the net with its own reviews.
Apart from the information about me (Doyle),which is 99% accurate, the only inaccuracies being very minor, the immense value of this book is the fact that it courageously uncovers the dishonesty of the Legion of Christ and its sexually abusing founder/leader. Catholics from the Vatican on down to the pews are duped by this outfit. Berry and Renner dug deep into the inner workings of the Catholic Church's strange governing world and found corruption. Many people, lay and clergy, are not able to handle what they found, but find it they did. The Church, Catholics and secular society are much better off because of the honest and detailed rendition of the bizarre story of this cultish organization. If men and women of integrity look for reasons for the senselessness of the church's response to the sex abuse crisis, they will find some valuable and shocking answers in this book. The blindness and the denial of justice starts at the top. Thomas Doyle

68 of 75 people found the following review helpful

5.0 out of 5 stars A Tale of Two Priests December 4, 2004

By Roy Man

Format:Hardcover

I wish I had read this book earlier when the clergy abuse scandal was in the headlines. This "Tale of Two Cities" - that of God and that of man - could really have been entitled "A Tale of Two Priests." Jason Berry and Gerald Renner tell the story of two men of the cloth, Thomas Doyle and Marcel Maciel - one a lonely advocate for victims of sexual abuse, the other credibly charged with being a serial sexual abuser - and the surprising fate that the Catholic Church under John Paul II has reserved for them. The courageous pastor to the marginalized is himself marginalized, moved from assignment to assignment, each time farther and farther from centers of influence; the cowardly child molester receives accolade upon accolade and is all but canonized while he's still alive. Fortunately for both - and for all of us - there's a life to come with judgment.

This book is well-researched and clearly written. It deserves a wide readership.

33 of 40 people found the following review helpful

5.0 out of 5 stars Heart breaking accuracy! March 31, 2004

By A Customer

Format:Hardcover

Incredibly accurate. I am a former member of Regnum Christi for many years. It all rings too familiar. I am saddened to see how much harm the Legion of Christ has done, but I am relieved to see that it is finally coming to the surface in the United States.

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful

4.0 out of 5 stars mandatory reading for all religious. March 8, 2007

By J. Iwasyszyn

Format:Hardcover

The book gave me a insight into the actual politiccal workings of the Catholic church. The extent of the cover-ups by bishops and cardinals of priest that abused minors was a crime. It should never have happened if the bishops and cardinals had done their job and turned the violating priest over to civil authorties.

This book should be required reading for all those studying to be priest, brothers and nuns. They should understand that if charged with violation of a minor that they could be subject to civil law.

28 of 34 people found the following review helpful

5.0 out of 5 stars Review of Vows of Silence:Abuse of Power in Papacy of JP2 April 19, 2004

By keith keller

Format:Hardcover

As a former Legionary, I'd like to thank the authors for a very professional, objective investigation of the Legion. Their book exposes the achilles heal of the Catholic Church: the arrogant disregard for victims of sexual abuse. The cultish, deceptive ways of this new Religious Order and her "saintly" founder are compared to a wonderful priest who sacrificed his career to aid these victims of a perverted clergy. The Catholic Church is at a crossroads similar to the early sixties. The prognosis isn't good for its very survival when a group like the Legion and its Regnum Christi Lay movement are hailed despite their deceitful fundraising and recruiting practices. If the root is rotten, can the tree florish for long? It's a must read for anyone who wonders why Organized Religion is failing and how out of touch the Vatican is especially with the American Catholic Laity. Some of our good Bishops are now becoming aware of the Legion's methodology and shallow spirituality and should be supported in their efforts to overcome the cover-ups of our current Pope and the Roman Curia!

24 of 29 people found the following review helpful

4.0 out of 5 stars One Wonders... November 28, 2004

By Carlos B.

Format:Hardcover

While the strands of this narrative often get tedious - one wonders whether the authors were in too much of a rush to get their book out while the clergy sexual abuse scandals were in the headlines - the detailed allegations made by Berry and Renner against one of the most "revered" figures of contemporary Catholicism, Fr. Marcel Maciel, founder of the ultra-conservative Legionaires of Christ, are shocking. While "Nuestro Padre" ("Our Father") as he is blasphemously called by his devotees (victims?) has denied the charges, he has made no attempt to vindicate himself through a recourse to the judicial system. One is left wondering if Berry and Renner have uncovered something that ought to receive more attention and that their targets have chosen to ignore them rather than risk contesting the allegations. Every Catholic should read this book.