Customer Reviews

The Wadsworth Casebook Series for Reading, Research and Writing: Cathedral

5 star:		(32)
4 star:		(8)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(7)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

It is a cruel, un-poetic injustice, that Raymond Carver's life was tragically cut short just when his stories began to take on glimmers of hope that were nowhere to be seen in his earlier collections.

When this book first came out, I was eager to read new stories from my favorite "minimalist" (isn't there a better word these days than "minimalist"?) writer. Instead, I was reading stories about compassion, good-natured friendships, and even salvation and forgiveness. Sure there were still the choppy sentences, quick observations, and weighty silences. But it was different. Many of the stories, not all, ended with an unusual (for Carver) sense of closure, even understanding. As so many reviewers have noted, the title story is just glorious. The narrator, a sarcastic and distant husband, finds human contact in the strangest circumstance. And when he does, he simply states, "It was like nothing else in my life up to now." Simple, but it leaves a serious lump in my throat each time I read it.

Unlike so many writers who came before him, Carver cuts to the bone--with a sharp, jagged knife. Sometimes what you find there isn't what you were looking for: the epiphanies aren't astounding; you're not going to scream anything (especially not Eureka!). No, Carver will, though, leave you nodding, talking to yourself ("It's just like that, isn't it?"), as you fill your glass and wonder why you were fooled by the gloss and shimmer of modern living. "A Small, Good Thing," "Feathers," "Cathedral"--these are contemporary masterpieces. You know they are because when you're done reading them you can't tell whether you've been cheated or rewarded beyond your investment--it's the latter, it's the latter! What do you give to a short story? An hour, maybe? Usually, you give less. What do you hope to take with you? A smile? A smirk? Certainly, no answers? Ah! But, guess what? Carver answers questions nobody who is well paid and well fed and not dying for a drink wouldn't ever think of asking. Not that you have to be desperate to get it. But if you are (in your own secret, silent way), then read these stories. The flowers won't be any brighter, the sky any clearer, when you're done. But you'll see yourself a bit more clearly (more honestly, I almost want to say, but how many of us do that?) and maybe understand those people you've never understood, who don't waste too much time trying to amuse themselves.

There are a lot of people out there who want to tell you what to think about Raymond Carver. Shut the door on them, read CATHEDRAL and make up your own mind. This is a strong collection of stories; I think it bears comparison to Joyce's DUBLINERS. Each story is separate from another, but together they build a cohesive vision of the dusky corners of life in the later half of the 20th century. Sure his fiction is littered with alcoholics, divorces, and failure, but he finds the sympathetic quality that keeps you reading. In terms of structure, he creates a setting and exposition according to conventional rules of story construction, then subverts the climax into the protagonist's interior, so that the action is really about an invisible turning point in a life, when something goes out of it or lanes are switched, when self knowledge is made or lost. You would think that would mean so many characters stepping up to the plate and getting hit with the same ball, but each story is unique. The collection has variety and texture; it has heart without sentimentality. The prose is clean and undecorative, but never sterile. Carver gets it right; he should not be blamed for the plethora of boring contemporary literary fiction that has tried to ape him ever since he took the world's notice.

This is what we think about when we think about great writing. How can one person know so much about ourselves and everyone? Carver has been in all of our heads and has put us all down on paper, exposing us for who we are and what we really think about. Cathedral is the highlight of this collection. The images that are conjured up when a blind man help a man with perfect sight learn how to draw a cathedral he sees on televison is the most moving set of words I have ever read. These stories make you wonder what you are really like and then you realize that he's right, this is what you're like. A coaxing baker torments a family by hounding them about a cake they haven't picked up for their dead sons birthday. They confront him and he ends up being the grounding force for these grieving parents, the voice of reason and sensibility that brings them back to normal. These stories are wonderfully simple and simply perfect.

I just finished reading a review saying that Carver was dull and overrated and that the reviewer felt sorry for students who were force-fed his work. Having just graduated from high school, I am forced to explain that any teacher brave enough to try and teach such a deep and incredible writer should be commended. This is the kind of writing that students need to see, realistic and gripping. Carver writes extraordinary stories about ordinary people. I am eternally in debt to the uncle who pointed me toward Carver's work.

From the blind man who merely wants to feel a cathedal under his fingers, to the lonely baker surrounded by cake frosting, the characters in "Cathedral" are so real it's sometimes painful to read. Only Carver is capable of leaving out all authorial commentary - he presents a situation, and leaves the reader to digest it, taking away what he or she will from the people and their lives. Anyone who says "Cathedral" is boring simply has no imagination - Carver leaves the reader to continue the stories by themselves, on their own time, and he allows them to glean however much wisdom they desire from each tiny slice of life. If you are tired of being told how to feel by writers who believe they know everything about human emotions, Carver is perfect for you. He is minimalism at its best, yet with such a profound grasp of human interaction that he feels no need to share the obvious - and in an age when morals are thrown in our faces, it's nice to know there's still someone who believes in letting the readers draw their own conclusions.

"Cathedral" was actually the first time I read a collection of Carver stories. I'd heard his name alot but don't read short stories much. Great realist storytelling about working class people facing changes/crisis/alterations in life. It made me think of my 70's childhood and the adults around me then(since I think the stories were from that period). I also recognized one of the stories from Altman's "Short Cuts" movie. I plan to read more Raymond Carver.

Raymond Carver's short stories in the book "Cathedral" do tell perhaps of his life's stories but there is more here. It is what he doesn't say that makes the stories so unique. It is what is left when one finishes a story...the feelings, sad or dismayed or maybe even "I don't care" that come from the writings but are not of the writings It isn't what he writes but what he doesn't write. It is what he leaves you with and each reader can be left with something different. Carver is one writer who can be enjoyed by a man or a woman. His slices may be short stories but they are huge slices indeed. This is a book to read when you don't mind thinking a lot!.

for the title story and "a small , good , thing" alone , this set is definitely worth thumbing through . i'd read a carver story in a short story collection in jr. college before being bounced out (it's hard to study and focus on certain subjects) for failing to apply myself sufficiently . that story prompted me to look at this book in a library . i think you'll like his style . being a braniac is not a pre-requisite .

While "Where I'm Calling From" and "Cathedral" are probably two of the best short-stories in American literature, the rest of the stories in this collection don't reach the same high-water mark. These are snapshots into the mundane lives of ordinary people - which may be poetic in one sense but makes for a boring read in another. While there isn't much happening in the stories, Carver's pacing is also painfully slow at times. Nonetheless, Carver is a master of the craft - what he does with point-of-view is amazing. I recommend this book to all short-story writers - take notes - there's much to learn from Carver's style.