54 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Still Excellent - leaner, improved 2nd edition with better maps, updated accomodations, May 7, 2003
This 2006 new edition of Walking the Camino de Santiago is now 7 ounces and 182 pages easy to read, fact filled guide with sketch maps, elevation profiles, and something about the history, and the flora and fauna of the trail. It covers the trail from St. Jean-Pied-de-Port near the French border to Santiago de Compostela and on to Finisterre.
Walking the Camino de Santiago is a route oriented guide. It does have information on where to stay, but most of the text is still on what happens in between places to stay. You get a flavor of recent and ancient history as well as current conditions.
The original sketch maps have been augmented with more comments, symbols showing vegetation, revised symbols - overall easier to look at. The accomodation list has been updated, so for the moment is reliable. Refugios appear and disappear, so in 2007 and beyond you will still need to supplement this with more current information, either from the internet or the current Confraternity of St. James guide below.
When walking the Camino, the mandatory guide for English speakers is the Confraternity of St. James Pilgrim Guides to Spain I. The Camino Frances. This is a barebones 76 page guide focused on pilgrim food and shelter - how far is it, how many beds available, what does it cost. A very brief guide is the Camino chapter out of the Lonely Planet's Walking guide to Spain - about 35 pages.
I definitely recommend Walking the Camino de Santiago for anyone starting at St. Jean or in Spain. I still say that getting the current confraternity guide is mandatory, because it gives you a great level of comfort about how far, what to expect, and cost of the next place with food and/or shelter.
If a pilgrim starts in Le Puy en Velay, then Alison Raju's the Way of St. James: Le Puy to the Pyrenees would have to be used until you reach St. Jean. It is a more terse, difficult to read guide than the Davies and Cole guide.
We had a difficult time finding information on the Camino before doing it in 2001. Now there is a lot of info on the web - just check the online forums of gocamino or santiagobis or google for camino santiago, or even backpack45 and you will get a wealth of information.
When it comes to what guides to carry, my recommendations have not changed. Always carry the Confraternity guide and either this guide (Davies and Cole) or the John Brierley guide. For before the trip reading, the large Gitlitz and Davidson's The Pilgrimage Road to Santiago gives you more than you may want to read on the history of the route. Also read some of the personal experience books such as Susan Alcorn's Camino Chronicle: Walking to Santiago, or Joyce Rupp's Walk in a Relaxed Manner: Life Lessons from the Camino.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Terrific guidebook-- funny and smart., October 15, 2004
Excellent guide for the English-speaker walking the Spanish Camino. Davies and Cole balance wealth of information with the obvious weight restrictions to come up with a book which was helpful, interesting, and often very funny. The remarks about the towns and the available Auberges were so helpful that pilgrims of other nationalities walking the camino at the same time as I would often make a point of asking me what my book said about what they could expect in the day ahead.
I also appreciated the advice on the special things to do and see. The Best of the Camino list was right on target and we were very pleased on the occasions when we took this "best of" advice.
As the book was written in 2003 and a great deal was changed on the Camino for the Jamesian Year in 2004, I recommend annotating your copy with updates which can be found at the publisher web site.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Essential, useful, and accurate, March 20, 2004
By A Customer
I rode the Camino de Santiago in September of 2003, and while this book is, obviously, for people interested in walking the Camino, it is equally useful for people who ride bicycles. All the information I used was accurate and helpful. Riding on a bike, I took two books (the other being the Confraternity book mentioned below), but if I was limited to one, this would be it. The directions are clear, the maps are accurate, and the brief section on flora and fauna a nice addition. Buy this book and go. Buen Camino!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
