Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The American Dream seen through Irish eyes, April 15, 2009
This review is from: The Walking People (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
On the rugged coast of Galway, the Cahill family survives by managing their small holding and by illegally fishing salmon from the river, a privilege reserved for the leading family of the area. When things go bad for the family, the mother, Lily, desparing of providing her youngest two children of a good life, sends them off to America. The youngest, Greta, doesn't want to leave; her home and her mother are the constants in her life. But her older sister, Johanna, is a driving force also; and where she goes, Greta will follow.
Accompanied by a tinker boy, who yearns for a settled life away from the rootlessness of his roving family, the sisters emigrate to New York. Due to circumstances that arise, Johanna abandons the other two and strikes out on her own, always a free spirit who cannot be contained in one spot for long. Greta and Michael discover a comfort in each other's company, and forge an unbreakable bond that endures through 50 years, until Johanna again unbalances their lives with a rude re-entry.
The tale of Greta's emergence from a shy, unsure-of-herself wallflower to a self-assured matriarch is a stirring tale, well-told and absorbing. Mary Beth Keane, the author, invests a knowledge and love of the Irish landscape and people into every sentence in the book, as she develops Greta into the person she never thought she could be and gives Michael the cornerstone he has been searching for all his life.
This is one of the most well-considered books I have read in a long while. Full of descriptive prose, and pulsing with spirit, it takes us along on an intrepid journey from the comfortable old shoe of the homeland to a new and challenging world of strangeness and new ideas.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Secrets of the Irish, April 17, 2009
This review is from: The Walking People (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
There is an old adage concerning the writing business that advises the writer to write what he or she knows. In The Walking People, Keane follows this advice to the great advantage of her readers. She captures the experience of the twentieth century Irish diaspora in this winning novel. I suspect that she carefully researched the details of life in Galway and New York 50 years ago, but the most important details are not the result of research. They spring out of one's own experience, and sometimes grace the pages of a novel. This is just such a story, one that is certainly worth your while.
Keane exposes the intimate details of characters who live with secrets. The secrets are a part of their whole family. Greta, the protagonist, lives with a lie that she clings to, even when it threatens her relationship with her sister and her daughter. Watching Greta grow up, the reader can sympathize with her motives, which underlie her irrational and destructive behavior.
If you remember that time and place, you will meet a lot of familiar people in this book. Keane creates characters that are real enough to remind me of people in my own life. She describes their approach to calamity, discord, and happiness; their stoicism, restrained affections and displacement. They engage in the Irish way of fixing interpersonal conflicts by never speaking to that person for the rest of your life. If only that weren't true.
Keane's story never lags, never fails to fascinate. It started slowly, but gathered momentum as the characters become real people, and gradually took over this reader's life. I was genuinely sorry that the book came to an end. This is a masterful and painfully accurate description of family, love and hope. Although limited in particular details, the novel is universal in scope. I recommend it to all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An incredible debut..., April 5, 2009
This review is from: The Walking People (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Mary Beth Keane has written a remarkable debut novel with THE WALKING PEOPLE. This is a beautifully written story of the Irish immigrant experience, but with a slight twist in that the story begins in 1956 and ends in 2007.
Greta and Johanna Cahill are sisters living in a small seaside cottage in Ballyroan, a small village that at one time consisted of seven families, but know consists of the Cahill family - Big Tom, Lily, Jack, Padriac, Little Tom, Johanna and Greta - and one other neighbor. The closest town is Conch, about four miles away. Life is hard in Ballyroan (there is no electricity) and the Cahill men earn a living by illegally fishing and selling salmon. One day, a young woman named Julia Ward shows up at the Cahill's door. Julia comes from a group of travellers, sometimes known as "Tinkers". These people travel the countryside, never staying in one place. Thus begins a connection between the Cahill's and the Ward's that would last for many years and encompass both Ireland and America.
This is primarily Greta's story. There is nothing unlikable about her. Johanna is probably the least likable character, but at some point in the story, she becomes a periphery character, and you almost forget why she's unlikable. This is also a love story. Love between Michael Ward and Greta, love between Greta and Johanna's daughter, also named Julia whom Greta is raising as her own and love of "home", wherever that is, be it Ireland or America.
Keane has done a wonderful job in portraying life in a small Irish village and life in New York City. Her description's of Michael's work in the water tunnels of New York City is both alarming and gritty. Incredible written detail and beautifully drawn characters made this a pleasure to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|