10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Importance of "War and Mayhem", February 21, 2001
This review is from: War and Mayhem: Reflections of a Viennese Physician (Paperback)
Ernst Rodin's "War and Mayhem" is a must-read for students of the Holocaust and for anyone interested in understanding how Adolf Hitler managed to captivate and ultimately cripple Germany in the period between 1933 and 1945.
Rodin is a mischling, or "impure" Austrian, who nevertheless gets drafted into the Wehrmacht. In "War and Mayhem," he looks back on his life and offers us two points of view that are skillfully woven together: an eyewitness account of what it was like to be a young man growing up in Vienna during Hitler's rise to power; and an analysis of the most cataclysmic period in modern history from the perspective of an adult survivor.
Rodin's book is accessible and engaging. We follow young Ernst to school, a place he has little use for in his younger years, and to the summer swimming parks that he and his older brother sneak into because they cannot afford admission. We suffer along with him as he loses his biological father, a "ne'er-do-well" who abandons the family, and we hope, in vain, that his mother's second husband will somehow fill the void left by his biological father.
At the same time, Rodin, a retired neurologist, now living in Utah, offers us an adult perspective on how the day-to-day events of his childhood were being played out against a much larger and unsettling screen. He captures the flavor of pre-war Vienna and offers unique insight into factors that contributed to the latent, simmering anti-Semitism of the era, anti-Semitism that boiled over so viciously after Hitler came into power. Rodin is careful to explain historical factors that led to the Anschluss and includes valuable information about Austrian clergy and politicians, whose roles in the 30's and 40's have not been well-detailed in other books written about this time period.
As an avid reader of World War II-era non-fiction, I've read books written by Jewish authors, Christian authors, American authors, German authors. What intrigues me about "War and Mayhem" is Ernst Rodin's distinctive point of view. Rodin fought in the Werhmacht, yet was considered "less than German" because his maternal grandfather was Jewish. He suffered from anti-Semitism at school but is quite candid in his observations about how Jews in Vienna were easily targeted for mistreatment because they did little to embrace the community at large. His tone is straightforward, always honest, always enlightening.
I recommend Ernst Rodin's "War and Mayhem" to every historian and layperson interested in reading a first-rate account of life in Vienna before and immediately after World War II. Rodin's final assessment of the events he witnessed deserves our immediate and collective attention: given the right conditions, history could easily repeat itself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Moral lessons from extraordinary personal experiences, September 27, 2011
This review is from: War and Mayhem: Reflections of a Viennese Physician (Paperback)
I have just a few comments to add to the excellent Amazon review by Erica Diamond (02/21/2001, here) of Ernst Rodin's book War & Mayhem involving his experiences in Vienna during World War II. Rodin presents a highly engaging personal account of his life before, during, after the occupation and annexation of Austria into Nazi Germany in 1938. But, this is far more than a book about history; rather it is an honest account of the moral choices and compromises that Austrians faced during very challenging times. While Rodin never tries to force his views on the reader, his account implies many lessons that carry over to other locations and times. Very few heroes and villains occupy Rodin's account; most of the characters are ordinary people forced to cope with extraordinary circumstances. As I read through this book, I could not avoid asking myself what actions I would have taken had I lived through these times.
Rodin is a neurologist with training in psychiatry (these were combined as a single field at the time of his education). I found his critical discussion of Sigmund Freud and psychoanalysis quite interesting. The Freud family was poor and early on lived entirely in a one room apartment. Apparently, several of Freud's younger siblings were conceived with the young Freud in the same room. Did this fortuitous experience lead directly to the field of psychoanalysis and all its ramifications? The mind boggles!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No