Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent contribution to understanding Classical Greece, August 22, 1999
This review is from: Warfare and Agriculture in Classical Greece, Revised edition (Biblioteca Di Studi Antichi, 40) (Paperback)
Warfare and Agriculture is a scholarly, yet very readable, analysis of the effects of war on agriculture and rural life in classical Greece. Drawing heavily on contemporary sources, Hanson clearly illustrates the inextricable connection between war and agriculture in the Greek world. With the notable exception of Sparta, Greek infantrymen typically were farmers themselves who were often torn between their role as ravagers of agriculture in enemy territory, and the need to tend to their own crops. Hanson's main premise is that many previous analyses of agricultural devastation in classical Greece have overstated the severity of its effects. He points out the ravaging was usually a means to incite battle with enemy infantry rather than an end in itself, and argues convincingly that the ravaging often associated with the seasonal cycle of warfare, while certainly contributing to hardship among the invaded population, was far from complete and had relatively short-term effects. Drawing on his first-hand experience as a farmer, Hanson illustrates some of the practical difficulties with destroying the olive trees, vines, and grains that formed the staples of Greek agriculture. In the course of his analysis, he brings to life the Greek countryside and its relationship to the urban center of the polis. Although Warfare and Agriculture will be of interest to any reader interested in the classical world, it is probably of greatest interest to readers with some familiarity with Greek history. The extensive references to contemporary and modern sources, including many recent sources cited in the Updated Commentary to this revised edition, guide the interested reader to a wealth of additional information on the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb book, uses concrete experience to make a fine point., January 11, 2001
This review is from: Warfare and Agriculture in Classical Greece, Revised edition (Biblioteca Di Studi Antichi, 40) (Paperback)
The author uses his concrete experience as a farmer in the San Fernando Valley to develop a fine point about the "low intensity" character of Classical Greek warfare. He argues that, the Greek city-states waging warfare through part-time citzen militias, the war strategy of all Greek polities centered on the idea of forcing a pitched battle in order not to keep citzens away too long for harvesting at home. The means used to force such a battle being to disturb the enemy's harvest, which, however, given the low technology tools avaliable and the resilience of the crop-species - specially olive trees - could never amount to permanent damage. Therefore the general low-intensity, boarding game character of much of Classical Greek military history. A fine argued, important book, specially for the firm grasp of the concrete realities at play.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Looking at war sideways, July 3, 2011
This review is from: Warfare and Agriculture in Classical Greece, Revised edition (Biblioteca Di Studi Antichi, 40) (Paperback)
This monograph covers one of those little considered subjects that, in fact, has a great deal to do with the waging of war, particularly war in ancient times. Raised on a farm, Hanson has a lot to offer on this subject. Not only does he understand just how hardy orchards, vineyards, and grain fields can be, he ran his own research projects, cutting down fruit trees, pulling up the stumps, even burning out the stumps only to have new shoots appear the following year. Vineyards don't burn like they did in "A Walk in the Clouds." Grain fields are susceptible to burning only within a small window of time. Green grain doesn't burn easily. And time--the time it takes to do these things is not conducive to ravaging and rampaging across the land. It's hard, time-consuming work. I learned so much in this monograph. In fact, I would recommend any work by Hanson. He's direct and pulls things together so that his histories are strong and easy to follow. His is not elementary work; it's important work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|