24 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"Fact, Fiction or Fantasy?", March 27, 2002
"Warning of War" which takes place pre-World War II, tells the story of a mission to round up all the Marines manning outposts in China. But is it "Fact, Fiction or Fantasy?" Brady does not answer this question leaving it for the reader to decide.
FACT: Marines of the 4th Marines and the Legation Guard were stationed from Shanghai in the south to Peking in the north. Some shipped out to the Philippines, some were captured and spent the war as POWs and some may have been members of "Billy Port's Ride".
FACT: The march of the 4th Marines through the streets of Shanghai, down Bubbling Well Road to the docks for boarding on the "Harrison" for transport to the Philippines happened.
FACT: The actions of 2ndLT Huizanga and Chief Gunner William Lee also happened.
FACT: LT. Huizanga, WO Lee, Col. Samuel Howard and Captain Jack White were "real" Marines stationed in China.
FACT: There is no mention of this mission in any of the written histories of the Marine Corps nor is there any recording of this mission in the official records of the United States Marine Corps.
FICTION: Is it within the realm of possibility that such a mission was formed to gather the far-flung pockets of Marines? Certainly. AND--
FANTASY: Visions of being a part of an adventure such as this lives in the hearts of all who breathe adventure. So why not?
James Brady weaves the mood and emotions of the times as did artist/author Col. John W. Thomason Jr.'s chronicles of the Chinaside Marines of the 1930s. Great tales recommended to readers of adventure. Brady uses words spiced with salty, macho language. Grand stuff used by those in positions of leadership in all walks of life.
This story reads as a "National Geograhic" article with insightful, factual backgrond such as the detailed descriptions of the Legation at Peking, the Ritz Hotel in Boston, the gates of and The Great Wall with tour guide narration of the countryside for added flavor. The lesson in geography is worth the price of the book.
As in his stories on the Hamptons the names of the famous (General "Black Jack" Pershing, General Lewis "Chesty" Puller), the infamous (Pancho Villa, Rapputin), the rich (Prince Yusopov) and the ordinary (Dr. Han, Father Kean) appear throughout the story adding a degree of truth to the fantasy(?).
"Warning of War" contains sidebars of love and romance which are related without the need for the micro details of sex crowding the litrature of today. Also four letter words are few and far between used only occasionally in the dialogues of these tough, salty and macho men. Col. Thomason also wrote in this antiseptic but welcome style.
Approximately halfway into this fast-paced adventure tale the mood slows to a beautifully written scenario of Christmas as experienced by the members of "Billy Port's Ride". Carols, sincere holiday greetings, scenes of stars in the heavens pointing(?), all bringing a tug at the heart strings as good, or better, than any attempt at sentimentality written by the fantasy industry in California. This scenario brought pause to this reviewer's train of thought as he remmebered his Christmas in Korea, standing sentry duty, hearing Jo Stafford's rendition of "White Christmas" flow warmly over the newly fallen snow at his position. Memories, sad but mostly good.
This "Smell the Roses" pace is quickly absorbed back into the rapid flow of the story.
To those searching for history, read "Warning of War" for the love of adventure, not factual information. To all others, this fast-paced narrative may bring back memories and could provide you your own answer to the question presented by "Warning of War".
Is it "Fact, Fiction, or Fantasy"? It could be nothing more than a reading of a great tale of high-spirited adventure.
What more could you be looking for?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Warning! You Can't Put it Down!, March 28, 2002
James Brady has once again crafted a fine story and created some memorable characters based around little known historical events.
Like his reluctant hero, Tom Verity, in the Marines of Autumn, Brady has conjured up another believable character in Billy Port. Captain Port's mission is to take a small detachment of Marines and some civilian hangers-on and make his way across the Gobi desert gathering up outlying Marine detachments. The War Warning is in the air and before they make their way to the Great Wall of China, their comrades of the 4th Marines have fallen captive to the Japanese war machine. Port and his men realize they are alone and cut off.
This is a wonderfully paced story, with a lot of detail and insider descriptions. Brady really knows his stuff. You get the sense of the Chinese countryside, the interplay between all of the forces warring on each other "out there' on the other side of the Great Wall. But above all, you feel as if you are one of the "China Hands"; the feeling of total abandonment these guys must have felt, but above all the feeling to press on and continue in the Marine Corp way.
There are quick flashes of Griffin's Killer McCoy and his exploits in China and a lot of parallels to McKenna's the Sand Pebbles. But ultimately this book stands on it's own as a great record of a little known time and place in the big picture of WWII.
That is where I think Brady has excelled, he is able to personalize a small moment in history and surround it with momentous world events. He also highlights the professionalism and pride of the Marines that fall into this situations and as in The Marines of Autumn, shows the almost mystical relation between company grade officers and their NCO's.
Semper Fi!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A fine yarn, and maybe it really happened..., July 26, 2002
James Brady has always struck me as a novelist who routinely hits stand up doubles or even triples, if not long-ball home runs. His latest "Warning of War" is no exception with compelling insight into the psyche of American Warrior Marines, and with more than enough accurate documentation to make the relatively few historical errors confusing.
Did a Captain Billy Port and a platoon of China Marines really make a ride through North China and Mongolia towards an imagined Siberian sanctuary during the opening of WW2? Or is the book just an artful work of "alternative history?" Who knows? As Judge Roy Bean reportedly said, "If it didn't happen, then it should have." Either way, it's a fine summer read, and I enjoyed every minute of it.
For those of us former "Navy Pukes" who spent a few years attached to the Marines in the WESTPAC (even sometimes embraced as being "almost good enough to be a Marine"), the story rings true enough.
Thanks, Mr. Brady, for another fine novel. Keep 'em coming!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No