Most Helpful Customer Reviews
35 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Easily the most interesting and honest Cash book!, October 17, 2006
This review is from: I Was There When It Happened: My Life with Johnny Cash (Hardcover)
Marshall Grant, despite what others might believe, would know more about J.R. Cash and Johnny Cash than others who have managed to pick the bones of the legendary singer over the last few years. Unlike others who seem to want to make the man greater than his legacy, Marshall Grant opens that dangerous door of letting the reader know exactly what kind of performer Cash was while never ignoring his all too human dark side - which was darker than some might want to hear about. Grant forces readers to face the fact (in a very untabloid-ish manner that grabs your attention and demands your respect) that while Johnny Cash only seemed like someone who redeemed himself to achieve the god-like status he has been cloaked in, he was way more flawed and damaged a person than most people might imagine...He had some very nasty demons who chased him nearly all of his life and who made themselves known in horrible ways - including Cash's unfair firing of Grant in 1980, the unfair rumors of Grant's departure which evolved into a major lawsuit, the enormous amount of money withheld from both Grant and Luther Perkins estate, Cash's questionable financial habits, the fallout from his numerous "no-shows," his demanding nature to act above everything and everyone around him at times, his constant battle of never completely ridding himself of pills again and again, and his many indulgences that were as destructive to the people around him as they were to the singer himself. Grant also balances out his portrait of John Cash by offering many recollections of the many acts of generosity and his uncanny identification with those far less fortunate than him. Above all, Marshall Grant finally gives the late Luther Perkins the enomrous credit so many others might trivialize. If you want to hear the truth from someone who was closer to Cash than anyone except June Carter than Marshall Grant's book (endorsed by Cash's daughter Roseanne) is certainly well worth reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Concise, insightful, poignant and a balanced viewpoint- Gripping, May 26, 2007
This review is from: I Was There When It Happened: My Life with Johnny Cash (Hardcover)
Despite what die hards may think, I found that Marshall's tale was told in a balanced and moderate way, never lacking in compassion. None of us know the cause for addiction and certainly cannot claim to know the cure; but one of the hallmarks of the "dis-ease" is denial and in reading Cash's self penned book it seems that he seemed to be floating above the truth some of the time.As part of the viewing public we see the illusion that is embodied by these charismatic superstars and we get shaken when we feel someone has revealed too much of the human side of our idols. Marshall points out that Cash was the ultimate humanitarian, generous to a fault and always sympathetic to the underdog. When we are riveted to Cash and cannot take our eyes and ears away from him when he is performing, it is because he is all there in his human wretched glory- able to convey the poignancy pf life in every syllable. Marshall never slams and blames Cash, just explained life as it was for those surrounding Cash. There is a great deal of industry insider info, and lets not forget that while Johnny Cash was the headliner and the lead, Marshall was an artist as well, performing and sharing of himself on and off stage. I enjoyed the panorama of the story and I appreciate that Marshall has penned this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thank you, Marshall. Loved your book. Readers, BUY THIS ONE., December 15, 2006
This review is from: I Was There When It Happened: My Life with Johnny Cash (Hardcover)
What a neat book. I loved all the humorous pranks that those wandering troubadors did to amuse themselves on the road. Priceless stories. The book is loaded with information. It's all here, both good and bad. I couldn't put it down. Sat up until 4:30am reading the sucker. But I must say, the last 50 pages or so, I couldn't stop crying. Tears streamed down my face with every line. I cried like a baby. I deeply felt the pain that both Marshall and John went through, and this book really stirred my soul. Marshall's stories are all so touching. I loved the ones about John pulling that little cannon through the hotel lobby; setting up and tearing down that makeshift bedroom in the elevator lobby just to confuse the bellboy; and one of the funniest stories I have ever heard in my life -- John's hijacking of an army tank for a midnight joyride on a military base in Korea (or was it Germany?), and poking its long gun barrel through barrack windows. The photos are great, and from Marshall's own scrapbook. Too bad he didn't include one of that little cannon, as I would love to see what it looked like. The darker stories were also well told: Glen Shirley, the hardened criminal that John worked diligently to have released from Folsom Prison. But Shirley was just that: a hardened criminal, and John eventually learned that the hard way. Very sad story. Marshall tells it like it was -- everything about Cash -- his countless givings of generosity to everybody he could help (even strangers, people he didn't know). And he also gives a grisly insight into John's dark side -- things that are disturbing to any Johnny Cash fan -- trashing of hotel rooms (and even Marshall's house), really for no apparent reason, and his addiction to barbituates throughout his entire adult life. His self-destructing ways and how that affected everyone around him. I am the same age as Cash, and have been a huge fan since the beginning. Actually, I lie awake nights worrying if there's a Johnny Cash DVD or CD "out there" that I don't have. However, I do find it difficult to comprehend John's physical brutality against June, as Marshall describes it, especially since everything I have ever read about them indicate they were totally devoted to each other and a very loving couple. I have also recently read a book by Peggy Knight (a must read), who was their cook and personal companion for 33 years. And she describes them as a loving couple who adored each other (which I do believe). Anyway, I absolutely loved the book. And after staying up till 4:30am reading it, I re-read it the following morning, since I couldn't sleep until I did. Bravo to you, Marshall. You have written a marvelous testament on the Man in Black. And thank you for not sugar-coating anything and being so honest. After all, you were there when it happened, and so I guess you ought to know.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|