Most Helpful Customer Reviews
58 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent book about a truly underapppreciated American hero, September 19, 2005
Why a magazine columnist from New Jersey would choose to write about Rhode Island's unsung Revolutionary War hero is beyond me, but I'm sure glad he did. To me, it's quite clear that Greene was never adequately recognized for his wartime accomplishments because he died unexpectedly in 1786 of a stroke at age 44 and never had the chance to participate and obtain fame in the founding of the new nation.
Who knows where events would have lead had he lived. He clearly had Washington's utmost respect and gratitude, and he demonstrated the highest integrity, leadership, dedication, competency, determination, and ability to get things done during times of great stress and deprivation.
Nathanael Greene's "Southern Campaign" is probably the most under appreciated aspect of the War in the books coming out today. The recent best sellers "1776" by McCullough and Pulitzer Prize-winning "Washington's Crossing" by Fisher seem to imply that after the surprise victories at Trenton and Princeton the war was all over, but this couldn't be further from the truth.
The next several years were dismal (the winter at Valley Forge was 1777-8), and it wasn't until the war later moved into the South and Greene assumed control that the colonialist learned how to defeat the British--inflict punishment, lead the British away from their supplies, and then retreat into the woods. This was Greene's strategy, and he executed it with utmost ability and skill. This is why a battered Cornwallis headed to Yorktown, to get desperately needed supplies. Washington had the personal touch, but Greene got things done, and Washington knew it and appreciated it. Everyone knew that if Washington was injured, Greene would take over.
The book read very quickly, especially the exciting section on the Southern Campaign. It also presented the more human side of Greene very well--his fondness for his very attractive wife Caty, his fierce loyality to Washington, his weakness for needing to receive recognition for his accomplishments from Washington, his determination to derive personal profit from the war, and his strict aesthetic Quaker upbringing against which he rebelled.
Earlier this year I visited the Greene homestead in Coventry, Rhode Island. It's a very simple home, set on roughly ten acres of land that is amazingly just now being cleared of overgrown brush. I'd definitely recommend a visit. The curators mentioned that there were more visitors from the South than the North. I still have a hard time believing it, but at least now I understand this better. Apparently, down south, Greene is getting his due. It's kind of a shame for the Rhode Island home boy.
The Sept 7, 2005 reviewer mentions that the two maps in the front of the book, indicating where battles were fought, could have been better. I'd have to agree.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
29 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Introducing General Greene, August 7, 2005
Years ago I attended Nathanael Greene Elementary School in Pawtucket, RI, but it is only now that I can see I know anything of substance about a man who can claim a great deal of responsibility for the favorable concluding of our Revolutionary War.
The author presents, if in a manner occasionally lacking direction, a photograph on a Revolutionary Hero whose fall to the second or third tier of Founder status was certainly not due to his ability, his efforts or his promise. His portrayal is of a common man of the period - constantly concerned with his finances (as were all those we count as leaders of the Independence effort); very guarded and jealous about his reputation (another common trait among these folk); but clearly fallen on one side of the fence dividing Tories and Revolutionaries.
Greene's escapades thru the Carolinas and Virginia, and the cat and mouse game he played with British General Cornwallis, gave the rebels the opportunity to win the war. Without these accomplishments, the British might have indeed, as Washington worried, gain command of the southern colonies, and with that foothold, move their way northward. Instead, Greene's dance led them in a variety of different directions, and ultimately to their fate at Yorktown.
The author has captured in his portrayal of Greene, the marks of a hero, and the flaws and failings of a man. His accounts of Greene's quarrels with Congress, his unwavering pit-bull defense of Washington, and his arguments with, among others, John Adams, color the general as a man of conviction, if not always grace. At the same time, the author shows the easily bruised ego, the roving eye for financial opportunities, and the man who cannot say NO to his beautiful young wife.
The coverage given to Katy Greene is either too much or too little. For the amount of space she inhabits here, the conclusions that can be drawn about her, beyond her fertility, are few.
Overlooking a few editorial miscues (On at least a few occasions, the book refers to Greene's activities in Conventry, RI - instead of Coventry), this book takes you away from the hero worship that is given to a handful of people from this era, and brings home the notion that the war was fought and won, not by Adams or Franklin or Jefferson, but by those whose existence was murky, and whose commitment to this effort lived through circumstances so dire that we can only read about them. We certainly cannot grasp or understand them.
It also tells you about the dangerous nature of those times. That Greene could die within 5 years of the war's end, in his mid 40s, from a sudden illness, reminds us that living in those days was difficult in even the most basic ways.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Greene Gets His Due........., July 3, 2005
Terry Golway's "Washington's General" is a marvelous piece of history written in the same manner as McCullough's "1776", in which Golway pays tribute to the most important figure in American history behind Washington.
In Golway's arousing and commanding writting style we are transported through history to a time that seemed as if there was little hope for the vision of independence held by Washington and Greene.
Through Greene's Quaker religious upbringing and sparse education, we see the developing stages of a man who would go on to lead the American Republic through the trials and tribulations of a new political idealogy.
Though Greene was stigmatised by critical condemnation, his unyielding dedication to Washington and the cause of liberty elavated him above those who espoused the elements of a new republic but lacked the self sacrifice that requires victory.
Greene accomplished and sacrificed much for the new Republic from his assigned duties as Quarter Master General of the Contental Army, which he lothed, saving the starving army of Valley Forge and Jocky Hollow with his adminstrative skills and underming the Conway cable who sought to undermine Washington at a time that questioned his abilities to lead the army to the victories it so strived to achieve.
Greene lead the victory with brilliant hit and run strategy of the southern campaigns that brought an end to Cornwallis's expedition through the Carolina's and his eventual surrender at Yorktown.
There is much to learn about a true unsung hero of the American Republic and with Golway's exuberant storytelling Nathanel Greene's historic legacy has been brought to its rightful forefront of American History. Brilliant, rewarding and insightfull.............
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
