Most Helpful Customer Reviews
39 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
More of the same for the final Watcher's Guide but also less, July 6, 2004
This review is from: The Watcher's Guide, Volume 3 (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) (Paperback)
First, for those who were wondering, this is the third and final volume in "The Watcher's Guide," the official companion to the late and lamented television cult show "Buffy the Vampire Slayer." Whereas the first two volumes dealt with a pair of seasons of the series, Volume 3 covers the final three seasons of "BtVS." Again you will find each episode covered in terms of writer(s) and director, complete cast list of guest stars and co-stars, Plot Summary, Quote of the Week, Love in Vein (keeping track of the complicated and often disastrous love lives of the Scooby gang), Pop-Culture IQ (explaining the popular pop-culture references embedded in the episode), Continuity (covering the twists and turns in the Buffyverse), Dramatis Personae (tracking the key personality traits in the main characters), and From the Original Teleplay (dialogue and humorous stage directions cut from the episode). At the start of each season there are a page of freeze frames from all twenty-two episodes; a list of episode numbers, names and original U.S. airdates, and the stars listed in the opening credits. In between seasons six and seven you will find a section devoted to the "Pop Culture Explosion" in season six when the Trio worked in all those references to movies, television, comic books, "Star Wars," "Star Trek," and anything else that came into their warped little minds. However, fans of the first two volumes of "The Watcher's Guide" are probably going to be disappointed by what else is in this volume. In comparison to what we have seen before, the information about "BtVS" is considerably less. There are neither character guides nor cast profiles, or sections by the writers or crew (and the spine is blue rather than black, as long as we are talking about differences). The rest is that by the standard established by the previous volumes of "The Watcher's Guide" this third one will suffer in comparison and long time fans are going to be disappointed. However, that does not stop "The Watcher's Guide, Volume 3" from being a necessary part of our "BtVS" library. Volume 3 is put together by Paul Ruditis, who previously put together a "Star Trek: Voyager Companion" and has written novels for the television shows "Enterprise," "Charmed," and "Sabrina." Ruditis does the duty alone, which may explain why the second half of the book comes off in a new direction. The second half of the book consists of a series of essays devoted to the series as whole and not just on the final trio of seasons: Ginger Buchanan's "The Journey of Joanathan Levenson: From Scenery to Sacrifice" covers the interesting transformation of a recurring minor character into a "Superstar" and much more. Hank Wagner's The Family Hour" talks about how he shared watching "BtVS" with his children and finds deep thoughts in the series with regards to parenting. Rob Francis' "London Calling: 'Buffy' from a British Perspective" explains the show's popularity in the U.K. despite having some American actors playing some of the Brits. Maryelizabeth Hart, who helped out on Volume 2, contributes "Slaying the Big Lies: Love Conquers All and Other Monstrous Myths," which looks at how love never seems to work out in the Buffyverse. Allie Costa's "A Part of Something: Or, 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer': My First Long-Term Relationship," is a fan's recollection of being a fan. Scott and Denise Ciencin, "I Know You Are, But Who Am I?" provides an analysis of how Dawn fit into the show over this period. In "Why I Like 'Buffy'" Charles de Lint provides a justification for liking a show with such a weird title, which is certainly something those of us in academia can relate to in terms of trying to foist the show off on students and colleagues. James Moore's "Monsters Made to Order" briefly looks at the similar themes behind key monsters in the show's history. The chief attraction in the back of the book is "'Restless': A Path to Premonitions," which has Joss Whedon's teleplay for the finale episode of the fourth season with commentary by Ruditis focusing on how Whedon set the stage for some key developments in what followed. For those of us who have figured out most of the connections, Ruditis does a nice job of filling in the gaps in our deconstruction of the episode. The final offering is Micol Ostow's "'Chosen': A Postmodern Postmortem of 'Buffy' as Contemporary Icon" looks at how well Whedon fulfilled his purpose of establishing a pop culture icon by flipping the horror movie standard of the blonde girl being slain by the monster in the dark alley. Given all the academic collections being published about "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" these essays are relatively light reading. Buchanan's essay connects all the dots with regards to Jonathan as do the Ciencins with Dawn, and Francis uses interviews with cast members to provide more of what we expect to find in the back of a "Watcher's Guide." So overall the essays occupy a sort of dead zone in between the musings of doctors of philosophy that are out there and the behind the scenes information we were used to in the previous pair of volumes. Again, the only complain here is that there is less here than what we expected. This is probably our payback for suggesting maybe there was too much in Volume 2. That would teach us except that the series and these guides are obviously both over.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Nice to own, most disappointing volume., September 21, 2004
This review is from: The Watcher's Guide, Volume 3 (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) (Paperback)
After the first two Watcher's Guides were must-own volumes, I assumed that the author(s) and the publishers were looking to finish their BtVS guides with a bang.
Not really the case.
At best this book limps along, the main author's clear bias to certain relationships incredibly evident.
It lacks the things that made the first two volumes great -- the special features, if you will. There's no character guides, no quote sections, no extensive interviews with the cast and crew. Yes, it has critical(?) essays. But most of the time the writers come off as either self-important or childish.
Yes, I own this volume, but were the first volume this disappointing I wouldn't have purchased subsequent books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Wholly Inadequate, August 24, 2004
This review is from: The Watcher's Guide, Volume 3 (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) (Paperback)
What a real disappointment this book is. The first edition of The Watchers Guide was a well-written guide to an inventive TV show that, actually, had a bit of thought to it but, sadly, it's been diminishing returns ever since.
This book merely sums up, for me, everything that's wrong about the whole concept of "official" guides to TV shows and movies. It's hollow. It doesn't tell you ANYTHING about any of the reasons why you're actually a fan of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, merely trotting out a standard party-line that every episode is an unsuppassed masterpiece (makes you wonder why 'Hush' is put on a pedestal when, according to the writers of the various Watchers Guides, all of the episodes are equally as good as each other). There's no critique, no depth, no _soul_ in this book. There's plenty of nice pictures though so, if that's what floats your boat then this is, to be sure, the book for you.
There are several unofficial guides out there and most of them are a hell of a lot better than this. My own particular favourite is Keith Topping's Slayer, but Nikki Stafford's book is also worthy of investigation. Both are infinately preferable to the mess that is Watchers Guide Vol 3.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
