Most Helpful Customer Reviews
29 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Still One of the Best Procedural Series, July 7, 2002
In this fifth outing, Inspector Rutledge of Scotland Yard is once again sent out of London to help the local constabulary investigate a murder and to placate local powers that be. As he painstakenly uncovers each clue, Rutledge begins to put the puzzle of a local priest's murder together in spite of the local police declaring that they have found the killer. The conclusions he draws will shock the local people as well as the local policeman. Todd has one of the four best British procedural series going (the others being Crombie, Robinson, and James). Todd's series is special, however, because he has set it immediately after World War I and his character is flawed because of his experiences in the trenches of France. Todd's writing continues to be impressive and his plotting superb. He does not use devices that will give his detective more information than he gives his readers. He has maintained Inspector Rutledge's voice and that of his alter-ego Hamish in this outing. Todd has written a procedural - it is not machine gun paced - it's not supposed to be. If you're looking for a book that you can read in a single setting and still figure out whodunnit, don't pick up this series. But if you enjoy going along with the detective as he/she investigates a crime step-by-step, then try this series. You won't be disappointed. If you intend to read this series, start with Todd's first effort A Test of Wills so you get the sense of the character and his suffering.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent, complex mystery, October 14, 2002
I love this series. I think book this was an excellent "breather" from the major internal conflict of Rutledge and Hamish. Of course, I look forward to the next book returning to that conflict, but this was a very intriguing mystery. I love the world and the premise of the series. I certainly don't think the series has weakened with each subsequent book. My own favorites were the second, third, and fourth. Todd is one of the few authors I buy in hardback. I do know Brits who drink cream in their tea. I guess they aren't self-respecting. I must have been deceived...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Intriguing but not the best effort to date, September 14, 2006
Once again Inspector Rutledge is sent out of London to deal with a murder in a rural constituency. This time he goes out to the 'Boards' of East Anglia, which even today is a desperately poor part of England. A priest has been murdered and his Bishop has asked Scotland Yard to make sure that the local constabulary doesn't 'muck it up'. The local chap, Inspector Blevin, is determined to prove that the person who did it was not one of his 'flock'. He quickly latches on to a suspect who he is determined to hang, so as to be done with it. The problem is that there's little or no proof that he did the deed, and has an alibi for the day of the murder. Inspector Rutledge must work he way through a cast of characters, all of whom know some of the truth, but only the real murderer knows the whole truth. Rutledge is determined to track that person down and bring them to justice. One of the side characters is a young lady by the name of May (Marianna) Trent who has her own secrets. She is tormented by an sevent that she doesn't remember and doesn't want to face. Sound familiar. Like many victims of shock, she has no memory of before or after the event, the sinking of the Titanic. She still has nightmares, but can't remember what happen to her elderly companion, or how she managed to get safely away. She makes the perfect mirror image for Rutledge, who more than once comments on her appearance. The denouement is interesting but the ending (which are separate) is in itself a disappointment. It's almost as if you can see 'TO BE CONTINUED' after the last paragraph. You get the feeling that this story will be revisited at some time in the near future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|