Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
More good stuff from Mr Pelecanos, May 21, 2009
This review is from: The Way Home (Hardcover)
Less than 12 months after last book The Turnaround Pelecanos returns with another solid, enoyable read.
When Chris Flynn & co-worker Ben find $50,000 hidden in a cut-away floorboard while fitting a carpet in an empty house they leave it there, even though the temptation is there to take it. Both have been in trouble before & met in a juvenile detention centre but are trying to go straight. Ben fatefully lets their secret out to another ex inmate, the money is stolen & the people it belongs to come looking for it.
The book, though, is really about the relationship between Chris & his father, Tommy & how it is possible to change over time & earn a second chance. There is a lot of back story regarding Chris' time at Pine Ridge correctional facility & his day to day working life for his fathers floor laying firm after his release. This is the backbone of the book & balances the missing money plot nicely.
Pelecanos has a high profile at the moment due to his work on The Wire & well deserved it is, too. More mellow these days (the punky fizz of earlier Nick Stefanos books almost gone) he can still keep readers interested in the lives of his characters by making them plausible & real. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
It appears I'm the first to say it - but here goes - this novel is tiresome, preachy, and predictable, July 8, 2009
This review is from: The Way Home (Hardcover)
It looks like I'm the first reviewer to give The Way Home less than 3 stars so clearly I'm in the minority. My grievances with this novel can be divided into two categories; matters of personal taste and issues or problems with the novel that should be universal.
On matters of taste - I'm not a fan of stories about redemption and I don't like sentimental schmaltz. The Way Home is not so much a crime thriller as it is a novel about the relationship between parents and their children and the expectations that each generation has about the importance of 'getting ahead' and 'making something of ones' self'.
I also don't care for novels that view complex issues in a one-sided manner. The Way Home climbs right up on that soap box and preaches about the inadequacies of the juvenile detention system and the need for reform. The young criminals in this novel all redeem themselves in the end. The heavy handed message is that these troubled young men need to be understood and be given a hand up. I don't disagree, but the novel is so painfully one-sided that it actually loses credibility.
Of course, there are plenty of readers who like sentimental schmaltz. If you happen to be one of them, you'll find it here. It just doesn't appeal to me.
But even if you like schmatz, there are other issues that should bother anyone expecting a suspense novel. First off, did we really need another story about someone finding a big bag of money and the bad men who want it back? I didn't think so. Talk about a worn out plot device. And Pelecanos does absolutely nothing new or remotely interesting with this dusty old nugget.
I was irritated by gaps in logic throughout the novel, but perhaps the best example was when the two young men find the money. They are installing a new carpet in a house that was bought by a real estate agent who plans to flip the property. The previous home owner died and apparently had no heirs. The money is found in a gym bag under the floor.
It would seem that there are two clear choices that a normal human being would consider: say nothing and keep the cash or report the money and turn it in to someone (their supervisor, the police, the lady who owns the house - somebody). Instead the young men put the money back under the floor and lay new carpet over top of it.
Is it just me or does that strike you as incomprehensible? Who would do that? I can't imagine anyone would. It makes no sense. It's not like the two men are rushed. They have time to discuss what they are going to do. So why do they do this? The answer is obvious. Even though no human being would actually make the choice they did - the plot demands that they do it anyway. You see, they can't take the money because Pelecanos needs to show how the men are tempted, but reformed. They need to do the right thing. But they can't turn it in because the author needs the money left under the floor so it can be stolen later by someone else with a trail that leads to your friendly neighborhood carpet installers. It's a contrivance of plot that defies reasonable human behavior and it irritates me to no end. This is only one example, but there are others.
In conclusion, even if you like schmaltz, this novel still has a tired and predictable plot riddled with holes in logic. My advice is not to read it. But then again, I'm in the minority. Take from my comments what you will. There are plenty of better novels out there to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pelecanos: Am American Master, May 24, 2009
This review is from: The Way Home (Hardcover)
Okay, Greek-American, but whatever, George Pelecanos is one of America's best contemporary writers.
What is amazing is that he sustains the quality of his fiction while being so prolific. The Way Home is another amazing novel, featuring conflicted characters and their relationships and an impossible situation that goes from bad to worse.
The "bad guys" in this one really stood out for me. I really got a feel for them, even a liking of sorts.
The only thing I miss is some old Pelecanos characters I'd like to see show up more often...and that's not a complaint--Pelecanos creates these people who resonate with the reader, people we feel we know or could know. The author has a subtle way about his prose which is, at times, hard bitten and a nod to the genre, but to dismiss this as mere genre fiction is to miss one of the best things going in American letters.
And Pelecanos obviously has an ear to the street, from the cars, the music, the slang, everything feels right, all feels real. Another excellent book from a great American writer!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|