27 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An very nice concurrent sequel to Freehold., July 24, 2005
The second book in Mike Williamson's Freehold universe, The Weapon is less a sequel than a concurrence: the start of The Weapon is actually a good bit earlier than the start of Freehold, as it follows the career of a Freehold Military Forces soldier through some of the backstory and many of the events of Freehold. It helps to have read Freehold first, although this isn't essential; The Weapon is much more of a military book than Freehold, and nothing (about the society or the military) is considered to be assumed knowledge. You can read them in either order.
It'd be fair to say that Freehold is about a society; The Weapon is about a soldier. As in Freehold, Williamson spends a lot of time describing harsh and painful methods of training; unlike Freehold, this isn't such an important part of the book and there's nowhere near as much of it. The main character then goes on to Mtali, described in passing in Freehold but in far more detail (with specifics on how the troubled planet got to be that way), here. There are more training exercises and drills as the main character, Kenneth Chinran, works his way up the ranks; then the Freehold war begins, and Chinran is a black ops man on Earth. If you know the ending to Freehold, you'll already know what he does.
There's bodycount that makes John Ringo look cheap, some sex (less than the profligate girl-on-girl scenes in Freehold, thank God), and a lot less political comparison: yes, it's about a guy from the Freehold going to Earth (as opposed to Freehold, about someone from Earth going to the Freehold of Grainne), so there's a slight mirror-image thing as Chinran views Earth through Freehold-accustomed eyes - but not an in-depth one, because that's not the point of this book. If you were offended by excessive politics or sex in Freehold, you won't have a problem with The Weapon.
Probably the biggest problem Weapon has is, well, the lack of a dynamic plot or any *individual* bad guys. The only antagonists are at the national level, no individuals you can really hate. And the plot is 'course-of-events', not 'action-reaction-action'; Chinran is a soldier who goes where he's sent, and the only decisions he gets to make are at the tactical level. No real suspense in what he'll do next, especially if you've already read Freehold. It's a train ride, not a car chase.
On the other hand, it's also a very *nice* train ride; there's a different view of the Freehold, a highly amusing look at Earth (some of Williamson's description is hilarious), and the combat is great. There's enough personal stuff that you don't know *exactly* how it ends for Chinran, and I do remember wondering towards the end if he was even going to survive- there are devices you can use to allow that in a first-person novel, and the story would work either way.
You don't get military sci-fi like this every day, or (how often does David Drake publish?) many times a year. Williamson isn't Drake, but he's one of the tiny handful of authors who're in his ballpark - different, and not necessarily inferior in every aspect. An excellent work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 52 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Mad Mike Marinates Marvelously, July 25, 2005
Mad Mike Williamson's debut novel Freehold was fantastic, with its tale of a woman's journey from patsy to hero, from moral infant to adult citizen. The Weapon is the second novel in Williamson's series about the Freehold War.
The biggest difference between this book and Freehold is that in Freehold there are winners. In The Weapon, there are only survivors. Nobody wins.
Williamson is uncompromising in his portrayal of a ruthless patriot, capable of destroying half of Earth to preserve his planet, yet who shows that he can love and be loved. There is simply no sentimentality in this book.
Thomas Jefferson said, "The Tree of Liberty must be refreshed from time to time..." and Williamson explains in detail how that happens.
If you expect a happy ending, you will be disappointed. But if you want the real thing, this is it.
Excellent writing, excellent characterization, excellent plot and vibrant story. When Williamson really gets his career cooking, he is going to be one to watch.
Walt Boyes
The Bananaslug. at Baen's Bar
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
intriguing tale, September 4, 2005
This is set in the same world as Freehold but starts earlier and takes a very different tack on warfare. I found this take on the training of a covert ops soldier very interesting. The book is start to finish a look at the world through the eyes of a character that i was very near to writing off as a worthless, arrogant twit and putting the book down. I'm glad i didn't the book does take some wrenching twists, but it is all part of a tightly written story that is more than it first appears and not your run of the mill sciffy adventure tale. Dark, bleak even but well worth the read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No