Most Helpful Customer Reviews
39 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Jamie and Weber Do It Again!, February 21, 2007
This review is from: Weber's Charcoal Grilling: The Art of Cooking with Live Fire (Paperback)
I am a big fan of both Weber and Jamie Purviance. Weber sells the very best grilling equipment available today ( I have cooked on competitive products),and Purviance produces consistantly outstanding yet simple recipes for the grill. I have reviewed both of the earlier books, "Weber's Big Book of Grilling" and "Real Grilling" here on Amazon.
This book, as evidenced in the title, is exclusively about charcoal grilling. I started my grilling on charcoal, because that was all that was available "back in the day", but switched to gas "push button grills" to reflect the demands made on my time by a busy law practice. I still cook on my gas gills for various dishes, but have returned to my charcoal roots because when in comes to real flavor, nothing beats cooking over charcoal.
I realize through the comments of friends, that many view charcoal as "messy" because of the residual ashes and the charcoal dust one inevitably gets on one's hands. Soap and water deals well with dirty hands, and Weber's "one touch" and "Performer" charcoal grills make cleanup a simple task.
"Weber's Charcoal Grilling" continues the high quality cookbooks started by the two volumes mentioned above. All directions, including those which address fire preparation and maintenance are crystal clear. All the recipes are similarly simple and staightforward. All have ingredients that work with the main item being cooked to produce intensely flavored results, but none of them are excessively labor intensive. Other factors discussed include the utility of various charcoal types, smoking food and various direct and indirect cooking techniques.
In our home, we focus a lot on serving well flavored and well cooked food. The grills get used year round, even in the depth of our Northern Michigan winters. I have read other grilling books, but I keep coming back to Jamie when I want to maximize the quality of what I grill. if you own one or both of his earlier works, buying this book is a "no brainer".
Breaking down a person's reluctance to grill over charcoal, where such is present, is beyond the purview of a book review. All that your reviewer can reaffirm is that it really is tastier.
Finally, I note that I have a recipe in this book. Jamie and I have gotten to be online friends over the years when I have raised questions on grilling. However, I have no financial interest in either Weber or in this book. My passions include enjoying well cooked food (and wine), one of which "Charcoal Grilling" addresses with excellence.
Addition: I neglected to note that there is a website connected with this book, [...], which Jamie Purviance intends to develop into "the best go-to charcoal community" available.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Charcoal Grilling=Good Times, March 13, 2007
This review is from: Weber's Charcoal Grilling: The Art of Cooking with Live Fire (Paperback)
To me, the arrival of a new Jamie Purviance cookbook is akin to watching the bulbs sprout in the spring. I know something good is going to happen and I can not wait to enjoy it. Once again, I was excited to learn that Purviance had another aptly timed spring offering. This new edition was dedicated to charcoal grilling no less. Heaven.
I have previously reviewed all of Purviance's Weber cookbooks and have yet to be disappointed. One of the features I have enjoyed most is that besides the presentation of great recipes, Purviance delves into the mechanics of grilling. This book should be a required purchase with every Performer and One Touch Kettle that flows out of Amazon, Home Depot and Lowes.
Grilling is much more than dumping meat on a hot grate. It is the understanding of the characteristics of the grill, the fire and the flavors, that all go into making great recipe. Purviance delivers all three. For unusual, or off the beaten path recipes, Purviance not only gives the what, but the how and why. For years, I have enjoyed the delight of grilled artichokes and until I was forced to search the Internet several years ago, I had no idea how to prepare them. Purviance tackles everything from artichokes to burgers to brisket. I wish I had this book sooner in my grilling career!
For purists, charcoal grilling is a true love. Sure gas is convenient and in reality, most all die hard grillers have both charcoal and gas to suit their needs. But there is something about building a fire and watching it grow to create the platform for an incredible feast. That is where charcoal delivers and that is where Purviance has scored with this cookbook. Packed full of my prerequisite mouth watering pictures, this is a book that will soon be dog-eared and food stained.
My only complaints are criticism pointed towards the editor. I prefer the intuitive "named" tabs of the previous "Red Book" and Real Grilling. Multiple "P"'s (Yes I know the yellow one is poultry) and the "R's" for Red Meat just does not flow. Also, the note cards in the back are a waste IMO. Notes are for the white spaces around the recipes! Bring pack the great post-it notes from Real Grilling!
Do not let my quibbles stop you from buying yet another great cookbook from Jamie Purviance and Weber. As long as my Dad doesn't read this review in the next 24 hours, he won't know that I have already shipped one to him and his anxious kettle in Florida.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
BBQ Bible, September 20, 2007
This review is from: Weber's Charcoal Grilling: The Art of Cooking with Live Fire (Paperback)
This book is the bible of barbeque. The true definition of barbeque has been lost over time due to convenient changes in grilling technology. It is really defined as: "a rack to hold meat for cooking over hot charcoal usually out of doors." It is important to note that it says "charcoal" and not propane!
This book delves deep into the world of charcoal and cooking with it. I purchased this book as a source of recipes for my charcoal grill. I found the beginning of the book has absolutely no recipes in it, but is the most valuable section of the book. It deals with how to cook with various types of charcoal, how to regulate heat, different methods of cooking, smoking, and other tips that are crucial to barbeque success. Like the title suggests, cooking with charcoal is an art!
I have found over the years that what separates a casual preparer of food and a good cook is having a handful of tips and tricks in the kitchen. This book is packed with patio tips and tricks for the BBQ artist in training. Do you know how to deal with rubs that contain mostly sugar? What if the rub is completely dry? When do I apply my BBQ sauce? How can I avoid drying out my meat when cooking it? How can I get different temperatures on my charcoal grill? Am I marinating too long?
These are questions you may be asking or SHOULD be asking yourself. This book answers them all and much more. On to the other 90% of the book: the recipes. The recipes are complete, detailed, and mind-blowing. You will find that many great barbeque recipes are simple, but a couple gourmet touches and techniques set them apart. Each recipe will carefully tell you how to prepare the food and most importantly how to cook it. These recipes are not simply: "rub with these spices, throw on grill for 5 minutes per side." It tells you how to deal with different sized cuts of meat, temperature of the grill, and everything that goes into making it right. You will be even more impressed when you try some of the DESSERTS in this book!
The pictures in this book are amazing. Do not torture a loved one by purchasing this book for them to celebrate a winter holiday knowing they cannot possibly barbeque in that weather. You can't even get past the instructional section on how to arrange charcoal without firing up your grill and tasting one of these delicious looking recipes.
The only criticism of this book is that it may lack a volume of recipes. This is due to the full page color picture that normally accompanies a recipe. Personally, I feel this is the right amount of recipes. Barbeque is a specific cooking method which is the focus of this cookbook. This "art" is so well covered that any recipe you may already have for outdoor grilling will be enhanced by this book. This book has a section on rubs and sauces that can be applied to numerous meats, multiplying your possibilities. Even propane grillers can benefit from the recipes in the book. (Although, they may exchange their grilling equipment because of it.)
This book is a manual on barbeque that takes the form of a visually appealing cookbook.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|