Customer Reviews

Weeds

5 star:		(13)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

A harsh but realistic look at rural poverty and the bleak life it imposes on those who are born into it, particularly the women. Not for those who romanticize country living and childbirth, but definitely worth reading and one of the most beautifully-written books I've ever encountered. Both depressing and enlightening.

While there were times when this book was difficult to read, it's unflinching look at rural poverty -- and at life for women before birth control, central heat, running water, electricity, supermarkets, washing machines, etc. -- was powerful and incredibly moving. You don't always like or understand Judith, but you feel deeply for her and her family. If you are interested in learning how people lived -- really lived, day to day -- in early 20th century Appalachia, you must read this book. I loved it.

This book was very moving to me as I thought back on my mother's role in my life growing up on a farm. Though not near as stark or hard as the main character's, Judith, it was fairly brutal at times. I love my mother more for having experienced this book.

WEEDS tells the story of poor tenant farmers in rural Kentucky with great power and simplicity. The book's unique greatness comes from it's portayal of this life through the eyes of a spirited and analytic young woman. Set in a ten year period just around World War I, we watch this creative and resilient woman face the overwhelming challenges of rural life. The story is filled with the details of the everyday drudgery and hopelessness of a poor farmer's wife. Though dark, it always has a glimmer of hope and resoluteness that is inspiring. A wonderful novel for women's studies and people interested in rural sociology. Originally written in 1923, Weeds is a classic work that sheds light on both these fields.

I also purchased this book thinking it was recently written. Edith Summers Kelley was definitley before her time. I loved the characters and found it to be a fast read. This book is up there with the best I have ever read.

Given what I had heard about this book before I read it I expected a monotonous novel about a mean-spirited woman to leave me prematurely thinking, "What am I gonna read next?" Happily, I found myself the opposite.

First of all, I love Ms. Kelley's style of bold writing. She doesn't beat around the bush when it comes to supplying detail. So many writers of the time before it became "hip" to try and shock readers with unspeakable situations were often obscure and obtuse about such things, but details about "the knitting needle," and premarital sex not only surprised me, but allowed me to continue the flow of the story without having to try and decipher what was going on through ten pages of puzzle pieces.

And as to the character of Judith, I agree she has some flaws (as is human) but I don't think she is evil. She makes mistakes, but that keeps her interesting. However, she's not without some redemption. For example, when she is contemplating the possible death of her child, she doesn't wish it for hope of a lighter load of work for herself, she wishes only that they escape the life she knows is destined for the child. And in the end she prays for their life. I would call that a mother's love to want true happiness for that child.

The conclusion is a rather painful one. It makes sense and follows the timbre of the story, but leaves one with a sadness that things should have turned out better for her. On the outset, it seems to be almost a relief, but there is a great sense of loss which left me with a broken heart. This is definately a great read.

To catagorize this material as 'social realism' as some have done is a mistake. It is a universal story of lost youth and the profound disappointment of unfulfilled potential.

In the book "Weeds" for one of the few times, I found I was so concerned with "Judith", I could scarcely bear it. Mrs. Kelley captures this poor woman perfectly and, you too, will care!

It really blows my mind that this was written more than 80 years ago! The struggles of the main character are really no different than they are today...with modern twists. It all comes down to doing what is best as a strong-willed woman for yourself and for your family. I enjoyed reading about such an energetic young lady and following her into marriage and motherhood. Really, a wonderfully written piece of literature.

Lengthy and well written, but a disappointment in theme. In the era that this book was originally published, the general theme may have been better received as a true pioneer in women's literature; however, I had a hard time sympathizing with a woman who seemed to take no joy in her life at all. Are we supposed to associate her manly ability to work and take joy in the cultivation of fields, her inability to forgive a mistake made by her husband, her inability to cope with her children or to deal with anything in the sphere of the periodic woman's world as virtue? I found what was described as a precocious child to grow into a selfish adult who shuns her responsibilities. "Judith" does not exhibit resourcefulness and by mid to end of the book wallows in her plight by acting out and against her family and neighbors. She is not a likeable character: she is self centered. I do not consider this a prototype of the Feminist novel, because I believe feminism is only defined by positive action toward the betterment of the woman's experience. Judith does nothing to better her earthly stead. She's a jerk.