From Publishers Weekly
Edgar nominee Reuben (Julian Solo) launches a new mystery series featuring a young New York insurance claims investigator who will either charm or cloy, depending on how you feel about Nancy Drew. Fritillary "Tilly" Quilter and arson expert Isaac "Ike" Blessing, who happened to probe the fire Tilly accidentally started years before as a teenage babysitter, team up to look into a suspicious claim put in by Faith Browning after her sister Dorsey dies in an apartment blaze. The pair dutifully grill a conventional circle of suspects, including a spurned suitor and a married lover, with the veteran Ike taking much of the lead while Tilly focuses on reconstructing the victim's life. Details of Tilly's temporary jobs before she discovered her calling slow the narrative, while the step-by-step arson investigation proceeds a bit ploddingly. Despite the author's own expertise as a professional fire investigator, her efforts to share the fascination for the minutiae of her craft with the reader fall short. Little suspense surrounds the fire's origin, and the murderer's identity will be unsurpr?sing to most. Tilly's crush on Ike and her naïvete make her seem more like a star-struck teenager than an independent professional. Still, Tilly has an engaging voice that will appeal particularly to younger readers who care more about character than crime.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Paperback
edition.
*Starred Review* The only unappealing part of this story is the name of the protagonist: undoubtedly one of the more annoying in the genre. But as much as her moniker might make you shudder, Fritillary Quilter herself will warm your heart. A tough, tell-it-like-it-is New Yorker, Fritillary also is humble, eager, sincere, kind, and like the butterfly she is named for, sometimes fragile. In the course of investigating her first arson case, she describes her thoughts and actions in such detail that readers will imagine they are looking over her shoulder. Faith Browning, whose sister has just died in a fire in their family home, files a quick and questionable claim with Fritillary's insurance company--but refuses to let them inspect the property. Tillary (short for Fritillary!) is sent in to investigate, along with Ike Blessing, a veteran freelance arson investigator. As Tillary and Ike take on the imperious Faith, a true picture of the night of the fire gradually takes shape. Fans of procedurals will love the step-by-step detail as Tillary puzzles out the case, but the best aspect of the story is the keen pupil-revered teacher relationship between Tillary and Ike. A triumphant series debut whose grim subject matter is overshadowed by its life-affirming heroine.
Jenny McLarinCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to the
Paperback
edition.