147 of 156 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A valuable concept that was poorly presented, September 23, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: The Whartons' Stretch Book (Paperback)
While I agree with the authors' approach to stretching and flexibility, this book is really aimed at advanced athletes who already have a good degree of flexibility.
My three distinct criticism are as follows: first, the authors state that most of the workouts can be performed in 20 minutes after a short learning curve of about three weeks. In reality, the program I use - body building, consists of 49 to 50 exercises, takes about 34 minutes [50 exercises x 2 sides x 2 seconds contraction/stretch x 10 reps = 2000 seconds or 33.3 minutes] and that would be non-stop with no allowance for set-up into the next set. The ACTUAL time from start to finish is almost 1 hour - hardly convenient.
Second, the book never mentions the resting period between exercises.
Third, the drawings are generally poor representation of the progression of each exercise AND the clock face is often not in agreement with the persepective of the body position.
A final criticism has to do with the initial self-test. My home, and I imagine most others, are not set up with the type of floor level mirrors to evaluate the clock position. Also, even a floor mirror such as on a closet door require the athlete to pull out of position or lock into a difficult position in order to view the relative clock position (degree of flex). This defeats the exercise completely. Case in point, trying to view the seated torso rotations. The position calls for the chin to be tucked into the chest during the flexion sets. You cannot do this and look up into a mirror at the same time - severly limiting the accuracy of the test.
To summarize, a valuable concept, poorly presented. I would suggest at a minimum black & white model photos - not line drawings. A rewrite of most of the text - especially as related to the time requirement for each exercise/sports routine. Added material covering steps to improve flexibility prior to using the advanced routines in this book. I found the stretching to be a full blown and moderately difficult workout.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent buy!, May 7, 2001
This review is from: The Whartons' Stretch Book (Paperback)
About two months ago I started to research new stretching methods. I had injured myself numerous times on several occasions during the previous 5 months, and I recognized that I desperately needed to change how I worked out in general. Up until that point, I had done weight training and running off and on for about 6 years. I decided to pay attention to a previously neglected part of my training, that of stretching.
I ended up running across the method of active isolated stretching, and eventually settled on this book in order to learn how the method worked. Let me say that first and foremost IT WORKS. You don't hurt yourself, you can actually watch your body make flexibility gains while you stretch, something that I NEVER experienced to the same degree in all my previous years of stretching. The addition of the rope is essential: not only does it make the stretches possible, it also supports the leg and makes sane, reasonable stretching a possibility.
When I finished my first day of stretching, I felt like someone had handed me a new pair of legs. All my previous methods left me legs feeling like they were ripped apart (my muscles probably were), whereas I now felt fresh and ready to spring into action. It really has given me a new body, and alot of energy. I prefer it to yoga, and I do the trunk stretches every day.
Having applauded their work, there were a few cons. Figuring out the stretches was somewhat difficult: it was like trying to figure out how to work your new VCR. After alot of picking your brain, eventually you understand all the subtleties within each stretch. Furthermore, it is ESSENTIAL to memorize all of the different muscle groups in the body. Only when you know where your muscles are will you be able to stretch properly. Once you know where they are, and how they elongate and contract, most of the stretches presented are intuitive. Although that takes time, it is worth it. In reality, I never should have expected in my previous years to do weight training and stretching without knowing where all of my muscles are, their uses, and how to train and stretch them. But I tried anyway, because I didn't want to spend the time on learning how the body worked, I just wanted to follow someone's program and get results without understanding what it was based upon: the human body.
Once you understand your own body, this book falls into place and makes remarkable sense. Also, the routines do take alot longer than they allege. The trunk routine takes me on average 15 to 20 mins with only 5 reps each stretch, the shoulder and arm routines together take about 20 mins if you do them all with 5 reps a stretch. I've modified it to fit my own routine and I get my shoulders and arms stretched out great in about 15 mins. Alot of the other stretches I do whenever I have some kinks I need to work out.
Basically, I thoroughly recommend this book to anyone. It will take some time to figure out, but in doing so you gain invaluable knowledge on the biomechanics of the body. The stretching method is second to none in safety and efficiency. The only thing I would add would be a more in depth explanation of many of the exercises and better illustrations. Still, I owe a big debt to the Whartons for making my life a whole lot easier and enjoyable. Thankyou.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
50 of 52 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Skip this book and buy the original by Aaron Mattes, October 30, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: The Whartons' Stretch Book (Paperback)
Skip this book and choose "Specific Stretching for Everyone" or "Active Isolated Stretching--The Mattes Method" by Aaron Mattes, the guy who first developed these techniques. His site at http://www.stretchingusa.com has more info on these stretches.
The exercises and the narrative descriptions in the Wharton book are copied almost verbatim from Mattes' original book--nothing new or helpful is added other than some self-promoting anecdotes about athletic successes--and Mattes' original book has clear and helpful photographs, unlike the amateurish and confusing line drawings in the Wharton book. Mattes' book also includes detailed stretching routines for upper/lower body, neck/shoulders.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No