Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Crime fiction - not fact, August 21, 2003
I started getting suspicious when all the deserving bad guys seemed to get killed or commit suicide in the first several stories. Then I got to the one about the hollywood actor who starred in a TV family comedy that ran 10 years from 1974. Cute, except no such TV show exists, nor does the named actor. When this many facts have been changed there no longer is any basis in reality. As another reader mentioned, the case involving the hungarian ex-policeman who claims he's being threatened with death when a pig's head is found with a message in his mouth is VERY loosely based on a case in England. In the real case there was no crippled child to add pathos to the "story", nor was there a similarly crippled forensic scientist who miraculously solved the case. Fictional cases, fictional experts, fictional criminals - Why is this book listed in True Crime? I've been completely cheated by buying this book and if I could I'd demand my money back from the publisher! When I want to buy non-fiction I want non-fiction, not this tripe. Buyer beware and skip this book, there are better works on forensics that give more accurate details on procedure and demonstrate real cases.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Farfetched, October 18, 2004
While reading this book I found the details of some cases to be unbelievable. Also, the "photographs" of the murderers and detectives all looked fuzzy and more like drawings. I've read a lot of true crime and never heard of catching a murderer because he breathed his asthma medication on the murder victim's hair. Or because they chemically deduced which cologne he wore. And who leaves their backdoor open when they know a violent Doberman Pinscher has been getting through their backyard fence? Sure, just let that dog on in. And whose place of employment has a record of all employee's blood "groups" (not their TYPES, just their GROUPS), when the employee doesn't even know HIMSELF what group he is?
Then I read the introduction, which I always skip, and found out this book is FICTION, not true crime as the cover announced and in which section it was in in the book store.
As FICTION, it's okay, (I prefer Agatha Christie), but I don't believe the forensic work in this book is even based on any fact. So read it for entertainment, but don't be so gullible as to believe any of it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
pulp fiction?, April 24, 2002
The jacket of What the Corpse Revealed proclaims Henry Miller as "the author of many nonfiction books and several successful novels." This book had me wondering which category he was aiming for: nonfiction book or True Detective Stories magazine. The cover, complete with glowing reviews from Publishers Weekly, lead me to believe this was a serious book on the ever-increasing role of forensic science in modern criminology. The preface, however, tells another story. Here Miller reveals that "the names of the characters, places, and certain incidents and photographs... have been changed and/or fictionalized." This information is repeated in a note to the reader immediately following the preface, making his claim of the forensic details being genuine hard to take seriously. The alphabetical index in the back lends an air of legitimacy to the book, though referencing material that may or may not be "changed and/or fictionalized" seems pointless. While entertaining, this collection of 16 stories read like a cheap detective novel. The stories themselves are indeed fascinating, but I found them impossible to read without wondering just how much truth, if any, they contained. The details of the forensic procedures used to solve these "cases" may be technically accurate, but they were lost in the film noire, dime-store style of storytelling. The stories are all fairly predictable, thanks to an abundance of stereotyped villains, persistent gumshoes and thick-headed cops. What the Corpse Revealed was informative in one respect; I now know where the expression "you can't judge a book by its cover" came from. I'll be more careful next time I go book shopping.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|