Save Big On Open-Box & Preowned: Buy "What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hyp...” from Amazon Warehouse Deals and save 42% off the $24.00 list price. Product is eligible for Amazon's 30-day returns policy and Prime or FREE Shipping. See all Open-Box & Preowned offers from Amazon Warehouse Deals.
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hypothetical Questions Hardcover – September 2, 2014
|New from||Used from|
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Special Offers and Product Promotions
An Amazon Best Book of the Month, September 2014: What if everyone on earth aimed a laser pointer at the moon at the same time? What if you could drain all the water from the oceans? What if all the lightning in the world struck the same place? What if there were a book that considered weird, sometimes ridiculous questions, and it was so compelling that you found yourself skimming its pages to find out what would happen if you threw a baseball at light speed? With What If, Randall Munroe has written such a book. As he does in his extraordinarily popular xkcd webcomic, Munroe applies reason and research to hypothetical conundrums ranging from the philosophical to the scientific (often absurd, but never pseudo) that probably seemed awesome in your elementary school days—but were never sufficiently answered. It’s the rare combination of edifying and fun. —Jon Foro
“Randall Munroe is a national treasure.” —Phil Plait
“For scientists, the price of progress is specialization. When the goal of any researcher is to lay claim to a tiny niche in a crowded discipline, it’s hard for laypeople to find answers to the really important interdisciplinary questions. Questions like, 'Is it possible to build a jetpack using downward-firing machine guns?' Fortunately, such people can turn to Randall Munroe, the author of the XKCD comic strip loved by fans of internet culture. . . . For Munroe, who writes with a clarity and wit honed over eight years of writing captions for his webcomic, the fact that a question might be impossible to solve is no deterrent to pursuing it.” —Wall Street Journal Speakeasy blog
"By speaking the language of geeks. . . while dealing with relationships and the meaning of a computer-centric life, xkcd has become required reading for techies across the world….The Internet has also created a bond between Mr. Munroe and his readers that is exceptional. They reenact in real life the odd ideas he puts forward in his strip." —The New York Times
"With his steady regimen of math jokes, physics jokes, and antisocial optimism, xkcd creator Randall Munroe, a former NASA roboticist, scores traffic numbers in NBC.com or Oprah.com territory. One key to the strip’s success may be that it doesn’t just comment on nerd culture, it embodies nerd culture." —Wired, in an issue featuring "the people who have shaped the planet’s past 20 years"
"Sometimes the beloved geek-chic webcomic xkcd is funny in a broadly accessible way. Sometimes it’s achingly poignant, sometimes it’s socially intelligent, and sometimes it’s esoteric humor that programmers or scientists have to explain to the rest of us. But at its most ambitious, it either packs massive amounts of interesting information into a small space, or engages in breathtaking experiments with the medium….[A]t its best [xkcd] isn’t a strip comic so much as an idea factory and a shared experience." —Onion AV Club
More About the Author
Top Customer Reviews
Even though I'd already read the other 49%, I re-read them and was glad I did, as Munroe has added a few things here and there; plus, this stuff is just eminently re-readable. It's the perfect combination of irreverent, rigorous, technical, and fascinating. I look forward to every new "What If" (he posts them each Tuesday or Wednesday) and am always delighted to read the latest.
Even if you've read every "What if" ever posted to the website, this book is still for you - it's especially for you! This is a great way to enjoy older questions and answers over again, updated, and to share them with new people, and the new questions and answers - never featured on the website - are delightful; I won't spoil it for you, but my favorite has to be the answer to "If a bullet with the density of a neutron star were fired from a handgun (ignoring the how) at the Earth's surface, would the Earth be destroyed?"
If you have even a passing interest in science and ever enjoy daydreaming about the fantastic or the ridiculous, this book is for you. If you don't think that you enjoy those things, this book will prove to you that you do.
Also, this is a really great gift idea for basically anyone in your life who can read. Kids will love it, adults will love it (I'm ordering a copy for my dad's birthday), and they will be hooked from the first page (who hasn't wondered what would happen if the Earth suddenly stopped spinning?)
Gift season is coming up; thanks to this book my Christmas shopping will be a great deal easier. I don't usually write reviews, but I logged in and made an exception here. I cannot offer higher praise. Enjoy!
However, were you to relegate this amazing book to your WC, despite the number of flushes you hear in a day, there would always be a line.
In the case of "What If", this tragic location it is a far cry from what is deserved by the quality of writing, the subject and sense of humor herein. While obviously not having narrative, story or continuity, it has a greater consistency than could be called a topic- humor. OK, two. Humor and patience. Three: Humor, patience, and some amazing research.
A disclaimer from Randall Munroe: "I am a guy who draws pictures on the Internet. I like it when things catch fire and explode, which means I do not have your best interests in mind."
I was instantly hooked.
Further: For the question that warrants a different sort of answer- "What happens if you set off a nuclear bomb in the center of a hurricane? Would the storm cell be vaporized?" Munroe has only to quote NOAA as they reply, "Needless to say, this is not a good idea." Unsurprisingly, he cites their entire article. In fact, the text is followed by a goodly section of references.
There is no doubt he went the distance on these questions, and did so with a mind to give the most accurate, honest and flat out funny answer possible, in some cases going way further over the top than the original question requires. These are the truly great ones.Read more ›
The book, on the other hand, just screams "lazy". The editing is poor, resulting in too many avoidable errors. Also little effort has been made to convert the web friendly format into book form. And there is very little new content. The whole thing gives me a feeling that someone - either Mr. Monroe himself or his publisher - just decided to take the (excellent) web content and dump it into book form, without much further thought. And even worse: It gives me the feeling that they allowed themselves to do a half-assed job, because they knew the fans will buy it anyway (and give it automatic five star reviews). I don't know if this is true or not, but that's the feeling I get.
Of-course, the raw content is still superb. But a book is much more than its raw content. Presentation matters. And dumping a superb website into book form does not a good book make. This is why, while I do adore Randall's web work, I cannot give this book 5 stars or even 4 stars in good conscience. You might say that I'm giving it 4-5 stars for the raw content and 1-2 stars for the the execution.
And I would like to end my review on a personal note:
I know this review is going to annoy many fans. But I ask you, as fellow xkcders, to be fair when you vote for or against my review. If you really think I'm wrong, feel free to downvote me. But don't do it just because I went against the crowd, okay?
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I read xkcd online all the time. Giving Munroe a few pages to express his thoughts on things instead of a screen is just even more hilarious. I love it!Published 5 hours ago by Carol A. Roach
it was fun and entertaining to read. I also learned a few things so great! Fun for when you have some spare time.Published 10 hours ago by Marco
The book contains a lot What If? posts from the Mr. Munroe's blog, but it also has a lot of new content. If you're a fan of xckd, you need to buy this book.Published 12 hours ago by Friendly Neighborhood Superhero
Purchased this as a gift. I got a chance to read parts of it. I've read every entry on the What If? blog, but I think Randall added a lot of special content for this book, which... Read morePublished 1 day ago by Ecksc
A clever, fun, and fascinating look at the science of (I hope) impossible things. Got this for my husband as a gift and we're both enjoying the questions people thought of asking... Read morePublished 2 days ago by TMTaylor
I bought this as a gift for a friend and she loves it! When she first unwrapped it, she didn't seem to sure about it... but upon opening & actually reading it, she loved it! Read morePublished 4 days ago by Melissa K.