18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Honest and Compelling Review of the Lives of Prodigies, November 4, 2001
This review is from: Whatever Happened to the Quiz Kids?: Perils and Profits of Growing Up Gifted (Paperback)
Several years ago, I used this book in a study of gifted children. It was a fascinating look at the lives of child prodigies. But I'm sure that many will identify with the statement made by one man who was asked about what became of the Quiz Kids: " I hope they all turned out to be garbage collectors!"
It would be a tragic waste if that man had gotten his wish. But that is a realistic summary of the the feelings that many people have towards child prodigies. The photos of Ruth Duskin Feldman as a child reminded me of an overacheiving girl I once knew, and any body who has ever suffered the childhood indignity of verbal comparisons between themselves and someone who was considered more brilliant might not wish such children very well.
Of course, they didn't all turn out to be garbage collectors, and they can count a Nobel Prize Winner (James D. Watson) among them, as well as an actress (the late Vanessa Brown), a Jesuit Priest (Jack Lucal), and actor and dialect coach (Bob Easton), and a producer (Harve Bennett) among their ranks. On the the other hand there was the early death of one of the most promising Quiz Kids, Gerard Darrow, for whom certain social and academic needs could never really be met.
As is the case with many child celebrities, some of these Quiz Kids feel that their parents exploited them. As a Jew, Feldman discusses the bias against her and other Quiz Kids of the same faith. The story of how the non-Jewish Quiz Kids were sent to shake hands with the anti-semitic Henry Ford during a visit before she and the others could, in order to curry favor with the famed auto maker, was quite an attention-getter.
Duskin also sheds light on the sexism of the time, stating that girls often had to allow themselves to be deferential to boys on issues in order to continue to appear "feminine".One girl even advised her not to appear too brilliant if she wanted to get dates.Thank Heaven times have changed!
What Ruth Duskin has ultimately given us is a longitudinal study of gifted children that is sincerely told. No one could accuse her of being too arrogant about her prodigiousness, especially when she discusses the rejection she suffered.
Incidentally, I myself did very well on the report in which I used this book, and would highly recommend it to others. It's a fascinating study.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This program should have aired decades before it did!, April 26, 2010
This review is from: Whatever Happened to the Quiz Kids?: Perils and Profits of Growing Up Gifted (Paperback)
Whatever Happened to the Quiz Kids, Perils and Profits of Growing Up Gifted
Ruth Duskin Feldman, 1982, 2000
ISBN 0-595-00727-9
iUniverse.Com
370 pps., Ppbk.
The Quiz Kids, a weekly radio program the 1940s and early 1950s. showcased gifted children, the youngest four or five years old. Quiz- master Joe Kelley asked the youngsters questions in their specific categories. His warm nature and non-competition with the panelists also made the show fun. American children, glued to radios, tried to answer faster than the contestants.
Quiz kids were articulate and well-rounded and often surprised audiences with their wit. The kids were self-motivated, but parental support fostered their learning.
The show hopefully encouraged better teaching for gifted children. In that era precocious children were ignored in schools, their abilities seldom challenged and fostered. I personally have always regretted that eduational failing.
Ruth Duskin Feldman, the first girl quizzer, starting at age ten was a regular contestant for years. As an adult she wondered what her fellow quizzers had accomplished in life so interviewed many of them. They'd become community leaders, but only one was famous (as a movie star). Feldman lists each interviewee and their occupations, from housewives to important scientists and college professors.
Especially for seniors who remember the program, an enjoyable read. And a realization that gifted children need special attention to meet their full potential.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No