From Publishers Weekly
Whitmer ( Aquarius Revisited ) weighs in here with the third in the recent spate of unsuccessful unauthorized biographies of legendary gonzo journalist Thompson. Though Whitmer can write stylishly--"Thompson was a rock star trapped in the mind of a journalist"--he sketches his subject's life and work with little depth. Whitmer interviewed Thompson in 1983 for the Saturday Review , but his recollection of him offers less insight than bizarre detail: Thompson drank Bloody Marys with a side of coffee. Moreover, Whitmer lacks the sources of E. Jean Carroll's oddly annoying The Strange and Savage Life of Hunter S. Thompson (Nonfiction Forecasts, Dec. 14, 1992). He did not speak to Ralph Steadman, Thompson's illustrator sidekick, whose tale of a trip to cover a heavyweight title fight in Zaire is the highlight of Paul Perry's otherwise undistinguished Fear and Loathing: The Strange and Terrible Saga of Hunter S. Thompson (Nonfiction Forecasts, Nov. 16, 1992). Were these three books mixmastered and then joined together to make one Thompson biography, readers would be better served. Photos not seen by PW.
Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Because the 1960s lifestyle has become an item of fascination for many Americans, it seems fitting that Hunter S. Thompson, one of its symbols, has become the subject of several new biographies (E. Jean Carroll's Hunter: The Strange and Savage Life of Hunter S. Thompson , previewed in Prepub Alert, LJ 10/15/92, and Paul Perry's Fear and Loathing: The Strange and Terrible Saga of Hunter S. Thompson , Thunder's Mouth, 1993). Whitmer, author of Aquarius Revisited ( LJ 7/87), has produced an unvarnished picture of a self-destructive writer at work and at "play." Fueled by alcohol and drugs, Thompson's raw, angry style of writing came to be called "gonzo" journalism. Writing of politicians from Richard Nixon to Bill Clinton and events from Vietnam to the Kentucky Derby, Thompson has covered the American scene for a number of newspapers and magazines, but he is most closely associated with Rolling Stone. In many ways, this is a sad story of a creative person who wasted much of his talent. Recommended for biography and popular culture collections.
- Rebecca Wondriska, Trinity Coll. Lib., Hartford, Ct.Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.