Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
THE AMERICAN DREAM..., February 26, 2006
This is a rich and evocative memoir of the author's chaotic childhood. Growing up in rural Puerto Rico, while often living in primitive conditions, the author's lush and lyrical prose paints a vivid picture her early life. The flavor and rythms of her island home come alive under her expert hand, creating an unforgettable picture of her early childhood.
The author grew up in a poor family. During her childhood, she lived in Puerto Rico with her unmarried parents, who were always at war with each other, as her father was a somewhat irresponsible philanderer. It was her mother who centered the family and who always sought a better life for all of her children. When an irrevocable break occurred between her parents, her mother moved to New York during the nineteen sixties, eventually settling with her seven children in the mean streets of Williamsburg, Brooklyn in New York City.
The author details her life's journey from rural Puerto Rico to Brooklyn. The author was transplanted to Brooklyn at the age of thirteen, and her description of her life in Brooklyn is every bit as interesting as that of her life in Puerto Rico. Her oftentimes bewildering transition from her native, Spanish speaking Puerto Rico to an English speaking environment is engagingly chronicled. The author takes the reader on her journey through Brooklyn's public school system to the prestigious High School of Performing Arts, where she graduated and went on to attend Harvard University on a scholarship.
This coming of age memoir is so engagingly written that I was left with the desire of wanting to know more about the life of this remarkable woman. I was also very taken with her writing style. So, I went ahead and bought every book that this author has ever written and look forward to reading each and every one.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great book, would highly recommend, January 21, 2009
The novel, When I Was Puerto Rican, by Esmeralda Santiago, is a true story based on the life of the author as a child, growing up as an immigrant in the United States from Puerto Rico. Her memoir deals with many issues and conflicts she has to overcome as a child and a young adult, but she is able to develop scenes in great detail, describe her encounters with self-discovery, and draw the reader into conflicts that are emotional and powerful.
Scene in a memoir is very important because it is manipulated greatly by the viewpoint of the author. Throughout Negi, the main character's childhood, she lives with her large family in a multitude of houses in areas ranging from the dirtiest slums to upscale apartments in New York. Negi's first house in Macun was described in great depth, going right down the holes the insects burrowed under the wooden plank floors. In another instance, her family went to a relative's house to wade out an impending hurricane, and Negi goes to great lengths to describe the actions the people were performing, the foods the women were preparing, and the battering the house got during the storm. The scene is the basis for the novel, and Santiago's ability to create a strong scene lends itself to writing a great novel.
Negi is forced to assimilate into a new society while still living under the confines of her old culture in her house. Her parents are 100% Puerto Rican, and they expect their children to follow the ways of a Puerto Rican child. However, Negi is a very intelligent girl who learns how to be more American and has to constantly cope with discarding old ideas that were once important to her, but are now seen as demeaning or not applicable in American society. For example, Negi grew up as a young child wanting to be a "Jibara," which basically meant a more rural individual who lives off the land and lives a simple life. However, once she started school, classmates made fun of her and called her a Jibara, and it suddenly became a derogatory term that Negi wanted nothing to do with. Also, she discovers rather quickly on her own the nature of sexuality and how men and women interact with each other. On one occasion, Negi and her cousin exchange glimpses of each other's private areas, and Negi is shocked and taken back by things that come with puberty. Negi discovers many aspects of her new life on her own, especially since she is living life in a culture quite different from her parents.
Conflict is a big part of all memoirs, but Negi is exposed to conflicts of many sorts and sources. Negi has conflict within herself about Papi because she sees the caring and nurturing side of him, and also the lying, cheating, and irresponsible side of him. Negi has do deal with the conflict between her Puerto Rican background and her new American culture, and the differences in the beliefs and norms between the two. Her status as "casi senorita" is also a source of conflict because she is regarded as not completely adult, but not a child either. She sees no benefit of this because she has all the responsibility of an adult, but still all the rules of a child.
I feel reading this memoir has made me a better memoir writer because
I have seen how a good scene and detailed plot are formed. Santiago excels at creating scenes with great detail, and describing the emotions felt by the characters in the story. I feel this book should be offered again because it is a fairly easy book to follow and I felt like I got something out of reading this book. I would highly recommend this book, even if you aren't the reading type like I am.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderfully Honest Memoir, November 14, 2008
I enjoyed this memoir. It was honest. Esmeralda talks of her childhood, and unlike some memoirs does not portray herself to be anything but what she was. There were times she was a spoiled brat, times she embarassed herself, times she was scared. She lays it all out there. The memoir covers her childhood from I'm guessing 5 or so till age 14 or 15. I was not clear on what age she was when or what year it was at the time. That would be my only complaint. I felt as tho I was really getting to know her throughout the book, feeling her frustration at being the oldest of eleven children (must not have manufactured condoms yet), the difficulties of being poor, and her embarassment at going to the welfare office with her mother. Truly, not an easy childhood at all, especially being uprooted and moved every year or few months. Esmeralda definetly overcame all obstacles and became an amazing writer, injecting humor into truth.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|