108 of 110 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally a Wonderful Book for Disillusioned and Disappointed Parents, July 17, 2007
In all of the troubled years of struggle with my children's problems surrounded,or so it seemed, by successful parents and their perfect children, opinionated teachers, and therapists with their conflicting suggestions it never occurred to me that my seeming inability to solve these problems was anything but my own and their father's "fault" and due entirely to our inadequacies. What these inadequacies were I did not know and still do not to this day, to a large extent, despite all the professional advice I sought and self help books I read. I felt completely alone and ashamed and a failure and unable to understand how it had all come about. Now (at last) along has come Dr. Coleman's book and the relief I felt as I read it was immediate and enormous. In it he points out so articulately and so well many of the reasons behind my dilemna and showed me I am definitely not alone and that many parents suffer needless guilt and pain and shame around their parenting (long after the active part is over) and that there are many reasons for this as well as many causes for a child's problems. Importantly,he also has many helpful suggestions for healing the pain of a parent who feels a failure because of how his child has "turned out" or because of a grown child's rejection....a frequent if sad situation these days. If you are a parent and disappointed about how it has all turned out buy this book. You will not regret it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
70 of 71 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A compassionate and caring author, December 20, 2007
I've been trying to finish this book and to write this review for some time. This is an important topic, one that doesn't occur to us when we are parents of kids who are growing up. As we read them stories as they go to sleep, drive them to band practice, teach them how to make cookies, share in the joy of their success at a skill or cry with them over a disappointment we don't think of the possibility that some day they will say, "I don't want to have anything more to do with you," and then you will never hear from them again. This does not cross our minds back then. Why would it? It seems IMPOSSIBLE!
I have a large selection of books on the subject of family estrangement. Some are written by parents. Some by mental health professionals who have also experienced estrangement. Some by people who just think they know what they are talking about and that they are qualified, for some reason, to give advice.
I think that Joshua Coleman's book, When Parents Hurt, is the most compassionate, the most understanding, and the wisest book on the topic of conflict and estrangement between parents and grown children. He covers many contributing factors to estrangement including differences in personality, overinvolvement by parents, perfectionism, mental illness, divorce, family history.
He covers more ground than any other book on this topic that I have read. He does so in a kind and compassionate way, attempting not to point fingers. He offers suggestions to parents for ways to communicate that might lead to resolution. Although the suggestions that he offers would be most helpful to those who are still able to communicate with each other. The suggestions could be particularly helpful to those who are having a conflict ridden relationship with their children that has not yet gotten to the point of complete estrangement.
For those parents who are experiencing complete estrangement from their grown children, there are some good suggestions for coping with the pain and for moving on. There is one chapter on that particular situation of being estranged by a grown child and not being able to reconnect. Since that is the situation that I am in myself, I wished there was more on that particular subject. There are a lot of parents whose children are far past their adolescence and who are far past the days when they were dealing with the difficulties of the teenage and young adult years. There are a lot of parents like me who miss having a relationship with their completely grown kids and who have been unable to reconnect no matter what they do.
I think that Coleman is making an overall suggestion of an attitude to take that will lead to less conflict and to reconciliations for some parents and grown children when the reasons behind the estrangement are not of the most serious kind. In the cases where those suggestions can't work, he offers some alternate suggestions for parents on coping with the pain and for getting on with their lives.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
56 of 56 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Understood at Last:Solutions for Reviving Relationships with our Difficult Children, July 24, 2007
I have 3 grown children. RAISING THE FIRST TWO WAS A WALK IN THE PARK. I believed the proof was in the pudding: Good parenting produces good kids. I HAD MY THIRD--MY ACCUMULATED PARENTING SKILLS WERE RENDERED USELESS. Prior to reading Dr. Coleman's book, When Parents Hurt, my self-esteem as a parent was dropping by 'the incident.' I felt like a failure. My attempts to support my daughter were often met with rejection. She pushed me away at times when when she desperately wanted and needed me. Being a voracious reader, it seemed like I spent years camped out in the 'Psychology' section of the local book store searching for info regarding my dilemma: How can we love and care for difficult children, while maintaining our sanity in the process? Dr. Coleman's book offers insight, experience, and compassionate guidance. His eloquent excerpts from work with patients, speaks to the level of pain we experience and the validation we crave in raising a difficult child. Dr. Coleman sheds light on the complicated web we find ourselves weaving with our repeated attempts to connect with a grown child who reacts from a place of vulnerability and insecurity. I feel I've gained a refreshing new perspective along with formidable tools to implement change. For the first time in 27 years, I'm optimistic the relationship will finally move in a healthy, more satisfying direction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
