7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Feel as if you are walking the trail with the author!, November 22, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Where the Waters Divide: A 3,000 Mile Trek Along America's Continental Divide (Paperback)
Karen has succeeding in writing an intimate, lively book. She succeeds in taking the reader along with her on the trail. Her descriptions are immediate and rich in detail. It is a shame they have elected to leave out Daniel's journal entries. I thought they were a great part of their book about the Pacific Crest Trail. Karen and Dan try to see both sides of the issue, even when they are passionate advocates. This is a rare trait, much to be valued. I think she may need to read Edward Abby's Desert Solitaire again, he is more complicated than she sees him. She paints truly beautiful word pictures of the high country along the divide. I disagree with her on one point. She seems to have compassion and understanding for most wildlife but a pathological dislike for cattle. As an example is her description of the cattle running down the trail ahead of her, looking back in fear. She sees the animal as stupid for not just running away from her. Perhaps she has not recognized this as a herd animal, used to being herded by humans. Maybe the cows were in reality wondering if this crazy human really knew where it wanted her to go! It may be more exasperated than frightened. Just a thought. If you want a sense of what it would be like to hike the Continental Divide this book is for you. I hope Karen & Dan keep hiking and writing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What an undertaking!, February 21, 2007
This review is from: Where the Waters Divide: A 3,000 Mile Trek Along America's Continental Divide (Paperback)
The couple had already hiked the Appalachian Trail (AT) (they met on the trail) and now decided to hike another long-distance trail. But like they soon found out, the CD trail is nothing like the AT. The CD is more remote, more challenging. There is less water along the way and in portions the trail is poorly marked. And in many sections the trail goes through private land that the ranchers guard protectively.
I live about 80 miles from the CD in Animas, NM where the story starts. New Mexico was a constantly battle for water and fighting off the cattle that often contaminated the water sites. Sometimes the windmills were dry and abandoned. I think the author's perceived anger toward cattle come from her experiences of near dehydration from no water because what water they did find at times was claimed by the cows.
Colorado was all up and down, both figuratively and literally. The 12,000' peaks, the weather on top, spotting a mountain lion, getting too close to a lightning bolt...
And then Montana. I was relieved when the couple made it into the Big Sky country but then they had to beat feet to the border because an early winter came that year. The end was anticlimatic, as they reached the Canadian border and the border crossing had just closed for the season.
The story was well written and it was obvious the wife was at times physically pushed by her husband. At times she was exhausted when he had no problem. They were helped along the way by an eldery retired couple who'd follow them in their old van at various meeting towns along the way. The couples' conversations in bars with ranchers and cowboys and locals was at times stressful, but I think she handled the diversity well. (But did the locals?)
The CD is no AT. After reading this I'm in no way inclined to hike the CD any time soon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hiking off trail and 'in-the-know', September 2, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Where the Waters Divide: A 3,000 Mile Trek Along America's Continental Divide (Paperback)
Karen Berger and Dan Smith report from their 3,000 mile trek about issues that are near to the heart of any hiker. They discuss issues around cattle on public land, about the use and misuse of water and about the way hikers influence the land and the people around them. The narrative includes information on the history of the American West and historical 'hikes' such as the Lewis and Clark expedition. By mixing these tidbits with a delightful report of the difficulties and wonders of their hiking they create a book that is best read by candle or flashlight in the comfort of your tent. The only problem is that it is too heavy to take on a long-distance hike. Recommended for anyone contemplating the Continental Divide Trail or any other long distance hike.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No