Customer Reviews

Where We Have Hope: A Memoir of Zimbabwe

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

As a Zimbabwean living abroad I sceptically picked up a copy of this book. I would read with dread Andrew Meldrums daily news reports on the dire and continually worsening situation in Zimbabwe on a Zimbabwean news website. I was very pleasantly surprised by the depth of feeling he developed for the country and his positive outlook in this book. I was moved by all his personal experiences and interactions with people there and the dangers he faced on a daily basis just doing his job. Someone needed to speak up and let the international community know about the teriible things that went happened in Zimbabwe from Gukurahundi to the farm invasions and I admire him for his bravery and perseverance. He chronicled our history from an eyewitness point of view and brought it all alive again. It allowed me to relive the 80's and 90's again. I cringe whenever I hear news of Zimbabwe on the television but this book made me feel proud to be Zimbabwean and I have recommended to my non-Zimbabwean friends as a way of understanding what happened to Zimbabwe. Excellent book!

Meldrum delivers an excellent albeit admittedly biased depiction of Zimbabwe's efforts to come to grips with independence and the fight of the nation's majority against the power hungry Mugabe regime. The narrative is flawed at points as Meldrum's personal views as a journalist sometimes get in the way of providing a truly objective account, but on the whole his biases are forgivable and would be shared by the vast majority of people living in industrialized nations. For the most part, Meldrum offers a detailed description of Zimbabwe's troubled political scene and the rash of human rights offenses plaguing the country interspersed with personal accounts of his time spent in the country and his struggles as a foreign correspondent, leaving the reader with concern for the present state of affairs and, as the title suggests, a bright hope for the future.

As a visitor to Zimbabwe - I love it there, the people, the landscape, the optimism everything. And to read a book which does echo how most of the people feel is rare. There is still hope that Mugabe will be removed and democracy prevail. The so called issue with white and blacks is not as the media and Mugabe portray at all. People just want their freedom and a decent economy so they can have a standard of living above the poverty line. Andrew Meldrum may be biased as he does love Zim and the people but its about time that the truth is highlighted as no one has tried to prevent this on the international scene. I'm glad someone has tried to show the world what is really happening in Zimbabwe.

Andrew Meldrum is an American journalist who moved to Zimbabwe shortly after the country won its independence in 1980. He fell in love with the place and decided to put down roots, only to watch Robert Mugabe destroy Zimbabwe's economy and institutions in a bid to hang on to power. Meldrum was expelled in 2003 because of his critical reporting. To judge by his book, he got around the country, exposed human rights abuses, and showed courage in the face of harassment and a trumped up prosecution. Granted, his writing verges on treacle at times, and he's too politically "engaged" to be completely credible as a journalist -- but then it's hard to be fair and balanced when writing about a dictator like Mugabe. Meldrum has guts and his heart is in the right place.

That said, his book adds little to our knowledge of Zimbabwe. As a good journalist, Meldrum sticks closely to his personal experiences. Unfortunately, these consisted mostly of observing rallies and marches, interviewing opposition activists, consulting his maid about popular political attitudes, comparing notes with other journalists, and getting arrested. We learn little about the inner workings of ZANU-PF or the reasons for the economic collapse. Mugabe is no more than a stock villian. The rural Shona are a mystery. The role of white business in funding anti-Mugabe activity is alluded to but not discussed. We don't even learn about the contentious, often dysfunctional leadership of the opposition MDC party, or about MDC's rocky relationship with unions and civil society, even though Meldrum had friends and contacts in these camps.

Overall, there are too many anecdotes and too little analysis. Readers who want an introduction to Zimbabwe's modern history would be better off reading Martin Meredith's superb "Our Votes, Our Guns." But readers who want a lively personal story will enjoy "Where We Have Hope."

Andrew Meldrum was the last foreign journalist thrown out of Zimbabwe and, after spending 23 years in the country, is ideally placed to give the reader a first-hand account of the collapse of a once-prosperous country. Meldrum could have taken the easy cynical route and just described the calamity caused by Robert Mugabe and his increasingly corrupt and vicious inner circle. But he does more, by weaving in his own experiences, including a narrow escape from the intelligence forces when they came to his home to abduct him. He also does an excellent job of not just depressing the reader by harping on the problems (as some of the pop authors writing on Africa are apt to do) but by also writing about the resilience of so many Zimbabweans -- hence the (admittedly sappy) title. This is certainly not intended as a comprehensive history of the country. But it is a beautifully-written book by one very brave journalist.

Andrew Meldrum is a man of amazing courage, as evidenced by his determined pursuit of truth while surrounded by real dangers. The stories of his hopeful coverage of the nascent democracy born out of the Rhodesian War and then the rapid decline of freedoms, reports of massacre, torture and oppression over the succeeding years, until he was deported, are gripping. The people of Zimbabwe are so courageous. Their unfailing hope for fair elections is inspiring, and should make us appreciate our freedoms and voting privileges. This story makes you appreciate the value and importance of the free press, and the brave journalists who make it possible.

Andrew Meldrum writes a memoir that I feel privileged to read. He is a courageous person for his work to advance freedom in Zimbabwe. To learn of circumstances in other countries, especially in Africa, I often turn to memoirs by journalists living in the countries or assigned there for a period of time. Because of their own inquisitiveness, when I read I gain information that gives me a sense for reality at the human level while also educating me about the country. Reading a journalist's book becomes compelling. because of their talent and skill in writing, the remembrances of detail, the writing of true story. Andrew Meldrum writes with talent and skill, attention to detail about Zimbabwe. He did not let me down, and surpassed all expectations. When reading this writing, I now know things I can not forget, and it changes one as a person and what they stand for. Thank you Andrew. May freedom come to your family and friends in Zimbabwe.

I have always respected Andrew Meldrum's writings and perhaps this is not the best place to come from when you rush out and buy a book. As a personal journey, it was an excellent read although I was left feeling a little short changed. Perhaps his life in Zim was so exciting he tried to fit too much in the book? As a discourse on what happened it does not provide much information and I am still not sure what hope there is except the irrepressible resilience of the Zimbabwean people.
If you have never read Andrew's newspaper articles, this is still a recommended book.

I expected much more from the book. Lacks a lot of information on the conflict before Mugawe, why was he so succesful in his fight. It is interesting but I really wanted something more in depth.