I want to order Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory dvd (original with Gene Wilder), and I'm confused as to which format I should buy. Widescreen is supposed to be truer to the original movie format, right? But several reviewers of this movie said that their widescreen version was nothing more than fullscreen with the tops cut off. I would appreciate opinions from those who have one or the other formats of this movie. Thanks!
Fullscreen is 4x3 or 1:1.33 (old standard). New televisions are mostly widescreen 16x9 or 1:1.5 This movie version is 1:1.77 so it is made for theater and a little wider than 16:9 (hence the bars at top and bottom). Conversely a full screen movie is going to fill the widescreen TV top to bottom and have sidebars. But the widescreen 16x9 version is going to show a lot more content. Assuming you don't set your TV to stretch and distort it or use panning of course. I see no point in buying fullscreen versions for the future unless you plan to keep your 1999 TV around and dont care about the extra content being cropped off. Buy widescreen.