2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful source material, disappointing illustrations., November 20, 2009
I've taught Jewett's story for years and find it to be a terrific introduction to the heroic journey motif in literature. Watching little Sylvia ("child of the forest") choose to defend the mystery of nature against her own human interests is a rewarding reading experience that can open many opportunities for discussion. A conversation on the relationship between humanity and nature is one any age group can benefit from.
That being said, I'm not sure the story is really appropriate for young children, and so the attempt to cast it in children's storybook form seems unwise. Though the line drawings have a certain grace to them, they don't actually add much value to the tale. This may be because Jewett's story may not lend itself to portrayal in images, or it may be a failing of the art--though beautiful, the line drawings seem to lack the vitality of the text. This has the unfortunate effect of rendering the story boring, which by itself it certainly is not. Thus, I think small children might be unimpressed.
Also, the depiction of Sylvia seems off. She's nine, but the girl portrayed in the pictures seems far older...12-13, perhaps. This might be quibbling, but to my mind it alters a key element of the tale. Sylvia's youth makes her sacrifice all the more heroically heartbreaking.
I bought this as a gift for a Sylvia I know--the daughter of friends--on her first birthday. I view it as a sort of heirloom book--one that Sylvia will return to over the years. In this context, I think the book will work very well. But I don't think it is the most ideal presentation of the affecting story if children encounter it only a few times.
It's certainly a very nicely assembled text. The book is printed on heavy paper, the cover is very solid, the type is easy to read, and the pictures (as noted) are drawn with expert care. My criticisms, then, are not so much with the execution as they are with the concept. The story is great and the book is beautiful, but they don't seem to mesh well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No