Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A man we love to hate, September 11, 2002
This is a biography of William Tecumseh Sherman by Stanley P. Hirshson, Professor at Queens College, City University of New York. On the surface, it seems to be an un-biased story of the life of a very complicated man. Like so many Civil War generals on the Union side, Sherman was almost a failure in civilian life. He tried his hand at many professions, but never really made enough money to support his growing family. In the army, however, he had moments of brilliance. And brutality, evidenced most clearly in his march to the sea. He could send his men into a town with orders to destroy it, then wander through the same town afterward looking for friends who lived there when he knew them. He admitted that many of the soldiers he commanded during that time were not much more than thieves and ruffians. The book starts slowly and ends the same. Most of Sherman's story is the Civil War, four years of privation, desperation, and triumph. Maligned by his enemies, again as were most successful generals, his fights after the war were political, although he never sought political office. Rather his ambitions were for himself as the highest ranking officer in the U.S. Army, and for the Army itself. Although this is a scholarly work, it is an easy read, especially for a Civil War buff. There are moments when the reader will feel she is attaining some insight into his personality. But those moments slip away quite often. Because of this, the reader might wonder if something is being held back. For instance, I would like to have seen more details of the post-Civil War Army policies toward the Native Americans, something Sherman had much to do with. This is a must read for the Civil War scholar, American military history fan, and those interested in 19th century America. Sherman lived in much of the U.S. and details of these places in his time add to our understanding of life when our great-grandparents were young.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good book, Bad maps., November 17, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: The White Tecumseh: A Biography of General William T. Sherman (Paperback)
The book presents a few maps poorly drawn without relief, detail, contrast or clarity; primitive and in every aspect uninformative. It makes this reader sick to follow the detailed accounts of 3 armies maneuvering against 2 opposing forces in a complex geography; where each commander is trying to maximize every geographical advantage, and be referred to the included maps that actually detract from the clarity of the story. Every military historian knows that in a conflict between two forces the geography is always the third combatant. Nowhere more so than in the last half of the US Civil War where the minority forces were in a protracted defensive struggle. Shermans only equal, Joe E. Johnston, was a master of defensive topography; all the more reason to bless Sherman's biography with maps worthy of both characters and the conflict. Hirshson, if he understood this, let his editor proffer maps that are "cute" rather than useful. In reading this book you should take along your copy of the "West Point Atlas of American Wars Vol.1.", or refer back to Mr. Foote's boatanchor for topographic resolution. Burke Davis's book "Sherman's March" covering only a portion of Hrishson'seffort is a better product.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Timeless Cump, September 8, 2001
Mr. Hirshson puts forth a complete life picture of General William Tecumseh Sherman (Tecumseh was his birth name in 1820, William added for his baptism as a young child). What strikes me foremost after reading this comprehensive biography, is that William T. was, just like anyone else, an ordinary man that was making his way as best he could. Losing his father at a young age, he then had to adjust to going away to military school at West Point, in Upstate New York. There, he was the bane of the schoolmasters: never living up to his potential, was the constant troublemaker, and always challenged authority. Ultimately, this affected his overall grade, and it would cost him an appointment in the regular army after graduation. With the prospect of a future in the army gone, Sherman tried to make his way: banker, lawyer, school teacher....all the while trying to support an ever expanding family with wife Ellen. This was a constant struggle during his whole married life; not having faith in any kind of religion, he constantly sparred with his wife and her Catholicism. He adored his children; the pain of son Willy dying in 1861 pained him the rest of his life. Another son, Charles, died without ever seeing his father. Third son, Tom, became a Jesuit and was forever as good as dead in his father's eyes. The secession of South Carolina started what was then known as the "War Between the States", and history for the ages was made. Bitter defeat at Shiloh (and a reported, supposed bout of insanity) to the ever famous March to the Sea, the end of the war coming with Johnston's surrender. Hirshson does not get into great depth with Sherman's relationship with Grant, but he does competently relay the affection the two had for each other as friends. Equally, the pain of betrayal equally relayed when, as President, Grant forsook his longtime friend in a bitter game of politics that darkened his administration along with its corruption. Falling suddenly ill, Sherman followed his wife's lead into death on Valentine's Day, 1891. The Catholicism he battled personally his whole life was laid upon him in death, and he was put to rest with those Final Rites. His ending was quick, and merciful...fitting for a man of history. Put this one in your collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
